There is a great movie to be made with this original and compelling premise and a fine lead in Hoult but Juror #2 is not it. Desperately needs the narrative rigor and visual flair of a Fincher and a screenplay with a semblance of life. The themes & commentary only "work" because the whole movie depends on contrivance and cliché. If you thought this was good you didn't think about it for longer than 5 seconds