As soon as I finished watching All is Lost I landed on a Reddit post that eviscerated the sailing accuracy. While I’m sympathetic to the annoyance at a niche skill being misrepresented in cinema (to be fair The Holiday got trailer editing pretty accurate), it has little retroactive impact for me.
The lone Robert Redford starrer is like Cast Away without the prologue, or the third act, or an island... or Wilson. Ok, maybe that’s a bad comparison, but the…