Reviews
Matthias Becher. Charlemagne. Trans. David S. Bachrach. New Haven: Yale
University Press, 2003. 154p.
Jolyon Timothy Hughes
Colorado State University
Translated now from the 1999 original, Karl der Grosse, published in München,
Matthias Becher, professor of medieval history at the University of Bonn, presents
his readers with a solid overview of the reign of Charlemagne (768-814). He delves
into the situations that allowed Charlemagne’s ancestors, who had the title of Mayor
of the Palace, to assume power over the Frankish empire from the Merovingian line.
Becher then describes the events that unfolded to make Charlemagne the undisputed
ruler of Western Europe and the only real threat to Byzantium in the east and the
Muslim empire to the southwest.
While Charlemagne is a very readable text, its only serious flaw is that it is littered
with typographical and other orthographic errors. Despite the editorial miscues,
the text serves as a solid introduction to one of the most important historical figures for any European country. Becher ably describes the life of Charlemagne, his
family (his immediate family such as his brother and his sons as well as his wives
and concubines) and his political acumen. Another emphasis of Becher’s work is
to discuss Charlemagne’s relationship with the Church and how this relationship
is often misunderstood through the legend that has grown around the figure of
“Karl der Grosse.”
Central to the Carolingian Renaissance was Charlemagne’s ability to govern an
area that Becher successfully argues had reached its limits of expansion. Charlemagne
undertook efforts to create centers of learning, reform weights and measurements,
and create new courts with juries based on revised and codified Frankish law. These
accomplishments are essential for a ruler trying to establish himself not only as “patricius Romanorum,” but as “pacificus imperator, Romanum gubernans imperium.”
His importance, according to Becher, extends far beyond his dynastic conquests
of the various Germanic tribes. In taming the fragmented Saxons (with their various
leaders and numerous peoples), as well as the Lombards, Eastphalians, Westphalians, Bavarians, and Avars, Charlemagne not only conquered lands and peoples,
but spread Christianity to these areas. There was more to Charlemagne’s conquest
of these peoples than the legend would indicate. According to Becher, Christianity, with its hierarchical structures, provided Charlemagne with the opportunity to
FALL 2005 ROCKY MOUNTAIN REVIEW 1
assign Bishoprics to the newly conquered areas. These Bishoprics in turn had farreaching impact on patterns of settlement and provided central locations in which
impressive stone structures, such as churches and cathedrals, showed Charlemagne’s
power and resolve.
Becher’s most intriguing points of contention are with Charlemagne’s official
biographer Einhard, who wrote his Vita Karoli Magni about ten years after the great
ruler’s death. Becher takes issue with Einhard on a great many issues, but gives him
fair representation and treatment allowing the reader to be informed of what was
said, how it was said, and what that meant to an author in Einhard’s time. But Becher
establishes that Einhard exaggerated and was inclined to make Charlemagne, his
close friend, seem more magnificent than he probably was.
The book ends as it begins, with succession issues to be resolved among Charlemagne’s heirs. The similarities to the situation of Charlemagne’s own succession
in relation to his older brother Carloman are shown as a continual dynastic struggle
that would continue to shape the face of Europe for centuries to come. There are
a few tables or charts (2) that show the Merovingian and Carolingian dynasties
up to the year 845, but charts depicting the succession of Charles the Great are
conspicuously missing.
Charlemagne at 154 pages of text, 170 if all indices are included, is easily accessible and is written well enough to hold the reader’s interest. Becher is careful not
to get bogged down in minutiæ and is able to show Charlemagne as a human ruler
with faults, but also with an ability to rise above them. The organizational style of
the book also lends itself well to accessibility of information, making this text an
excellent reference tool.
2 ROCKY MOUNTAIN REVIEW FALL 2005