ISSN 1751-8229

Volume Five, Number One

The Grundlogik of German Idealism: The Ambiguity of the Hegel- !helling "elationshi# in $i%e&
Joseph Carew, MASTER Erasmus mundus - Europh !osoph e
In a re"en# essa$, % &e' ma'es a "!a m #ha#, #o man$ readers, mus# appear ou# o( p!a"e w #h n h s wor') *+e,e!-s -o.er"om n,- o( S"he!! n, s a "ase n #se!() S"he!! n,-s rea"# on #o +e,e!-s dea! s# d a!e"# " was so s#ron, and pro(ound #ha# more and more # s "oun#ed as #he ne/# 0and "on"!ud n,1 s#ep n #he nner de.e!opmen# o( 2erman Idea! sm3 0% &e' 2449a) 12215 The e((e"# o( #h s "ommen# s #wo(o!d) no# on!$ does # s#r 'e #hose mmersed w #h n "on.en# ona! a""oun#s o( #he h s#or$ o( ph !osoph$ as essen# a!!$ wron,, 6u# # a!so h ,h! ,h#s a (undamen#a! am6 ,u #$ a# #he "ore o( % &e'-s read n, o( 2erman Idea! sm and, 6$ "onse7uen"e, h s own ph !osoph$, nso(ar as h s para!!a/ on#o!o,$ s per"e .ed as a rea"#ua! 8a# on o( #he mo.emen#5 I( #he !a#e S"he!! n, s, (or % &e', n some sense #he "u!m na# on o( 2erman Idea! sm, #he (u!( !!men# o( #s n#erna!, se!(un(o!d n, !o, ", wh$ does % &e' re(er #o h s pro9e"# a,a n and a,a n as Hegelian, 6u# ne.er as Schellingian: The pro6!em s amp! ( ed when one en,a,es #he 'e$ % &e' an #e/#s "on"ern n, 2erman Idea! sm5 In 6o#h #he Ticklish Subject and #he Parallax View, (or e/amp!e, #here are pra ses o( S"he!! n, as #he ,rea#es# ph !osopher o( #he pre-s$m6o! " Rea!, o( #he na#ure o( #he mposs 6!e ;, #he je ne sais pas qoui, wh "h pre"edes "ons" ousness as #he mos# "en#ra! #heme n pos#-<an# an ph !osoph$ and wh "h reappears n #he wa'e o( #he =a"an an su69e"#5 % &e' e.en ,oes as (ar as #o sa$ #ha# S"he!! n, was *#he ( rs# #o (ormu!a#e #h s #as'3 0% &e' 24496) 1>>1 and #he ph !osopher who

*,a.e #he mos# de#a !ed a""oun# o( #h s ; n h s no# on o( #he 2round o( E/ s#en"e3 0% &e' 2444) 5515 ?h$, #hen, does he "hara"#er 8e #he (undamen#a! 7ues# on #ha# "ons# #u#es h s pro9e"# as a *proper!$ +e,e! an one) how does appearance itself emerge from the interlay of the Real:3 0% &e' 24496) 14>1: Moreo.er, #here s a 7ua! ( "a# on o( #h s e/a!#a# on n % &e'-s "ru" a! wor' on S"he!! n, The ndi!isible Remainder, an a##emp# #o d sa.ow an$ a6so!u#e dependen"e o( #he 7ues# on on #he !a##er-s own answers5 Immed a#e!$ a(#er h s pro.o"a# .e read n, o( #he 6 r#h o( #he S"he!! n, an su69e"# ou# o( #he Rea!, % &e' , .es a s"a#h n, "r # 7ue o( S"he!! n,-s !o, " and ar,ues (or #s n(er or #$ #o +e,e! an d a!e"# "s5 ?here S"he!! n, #r es #o ,round "rund and e/ s#en"e n a6so!u#e nd ((eren"e, #he +e,e! an mo.emen# o( #he ne,a# on o( #he ne,a# on does awa$ w #h #he need o( an e/#er or pr n" p!e o( med a# on5 In wha# #hen "ou!d #he S"he!! n, an 6rea'#hrou,h "ons s#, so #ha# # wou!d 6e #he culmination o( 2erman Idea! sm, ( +e,e! an d a!e"# "s s super or: In #he (o!!ow n, I propose #o read % &e' against % &e' n order #o demons#ra#e #he "omp!e/ n#er#w n n, o( S"he!! n, an on#o!o,$ and +e,e! an !o, " a# #he hear# o( h s own #h n' n,55 ?ha# we w !! see s #ha# ( #he "rundlogik o( 2erman Idea! sm s #he rad "a! on#o!o, "a! n"omp!e# on o( rea! #$ announ"ed 6$ #he a6$ss o( (reedom "ons# #u# .e o( #he <an# an su69e"#, #hen unders#and n, #he am6 ,u #$ o( #he re!a# onsh p o( #hese #h n'ers w #h n % &e' s "ru" a! (or ,rasp n, #he mo.emen# as a who!e5 Ne #her +e,e! nor S"he!! n, are a6!e #o "ome #o #erms w #h #he (u!! mp! "a# ons o( #he dead!o"' o( (reedom 6$ #hemse!.es and #ha# # s on!$ #hrou,h a re#roa"# .e re"ons#ru"# on o( #he nner !o, " o( pos#-<an# an ph !osoph$, a p!a$ n, o( #hese #wo ( ,ures a,a ns# one ano#her, #ha# % &e' s a6!e #o presen# h s read n, o( #he rad "a! na#ure o( su69e"# . #$ n 2erman Idea! sm5 I5 Me#aph$s "s n #he ?a'e o( <an# In order #o #a"'!e #he na#ure o( #he am6 ,uous +e,e!-S"he!! n, re!a# onsh p n % &e', we ( rs# need #o ou#! ne #he s#a'es n pos#-<an# an ph !osoph$ and #he spe" ( " wa$ #he$ are #a'en up n #he ear!$ S"he!! n, and +e,e!5 ?ha# we w !! see s a new, pro.o"a# .e read n, o( #he mmanen# de.e!opmen# o( 2erman Idea! sm h n#ed a# 6$ % &e'-s ph !osoph$5 @$ (o!!ow n, "er#a n premon # ons w #h n <an#-s peda,o, "a! wr # n,s wh "h appear #o ! n' #rans"enden#a! spon#ane #$ #o #he ps$"hoana!$# "a! "on"ep# o( Todestrieb, % &e' reads +e,e! an A6so!u#e Idea! sm a,a ns# s#andard n#erpre#a# ons 6$ "!a m n, #ha# +e,e!-s a##emp# #o #h n' su6s#an"e as su69e"# mp! es #he on#o,ene# " emer,en"e o( (reedom #hrou,h a se!(-sunder n, o( 6e n,5 Ao!!ow n, =a"an-s "!a m #ha# *<an#-s pra"# "a! ph !osoph$ B sC #he s#ar# n, po n# o( #he ! nea,e "u!m na# n, n Areud-s n.en# on o( ps$"hoana!$s s,3 % &e'-s pro9e"# "ou!d 6e des"r 6ed as ha. n, #wo ,oa!s 0% &e' 24496) D815 A rs#!$, 6e"ause #he =a"an an su69e"# s !a"' n, an$ #heor$ o( #s own on#o,enes s, % &e' #urns #o 2erman Idea! sm #o de.e!op a d a!e"# "a! ma#er a! sm #ha# wou!d ,round #, nso(ar as #here s an o6. ous s#ru"#ura! para!!e! sm #ha# e/ s#s n #he under!$ n,

pro6!ema# " p!a,u n, 6o#h pos#-<an# an ph !osoph$ and "on#emporar$ ps$"hoana!$s s5 Se"ond!$, ( we read <an#, +e,e! and S"he!! n, #hrou,h =a"an, we "an see an under!$ n, den# #$ #ha# e/ s#s 6e#ween #he ps$"hoana!$# "a! su69e"#, haun#ed 6$ #he Todestrieb as #he "ons# #u# .e ,round o( #s .er$ e/ s#en"e, and #he opera# .e !o, " o( #he 2erman Idea! sm #rad # on) The 'e$ po n# s #hus #ha# #he passa,e (rom *na#ure3 #o *"u!#ure3 s no# d re"#, #ha# one "anno# a""oun# (or # w #h n a "on# nuous e.o!u# onar$ narra# .e) some#h n, has #o n#er.ene 6e#ween #he #wo, a ' nd o( *.an sh n, med a#or,3 wh "h s ne #her na#ure nor "u!#ure E #h s In6e#ween s s !en#!$ presupposed n a!! e.o!u# onar$ narra# .es5 ?e are no# dea! s#s) #h s In6e#ween s no# #he spar' o( logos ma, "a!!$ "on(erred on Homo sapiens, ena6! n, #hem #o (orm h s supp!emen#ar$ . r#ua! s$m6o! " surround n,s, 6u# pre" se!$ some#h n, #ha#, a!#hou,h # s a!so no !on,er na#ure, s no# $e# logos, and has #o 6e *repressed3 6$ logos E #he Areud an name (or #h s In-6e#ween, o( "ourse, s #he dea#h dr .e B555C a momen# o( #horou,h!$ *per.er#ed,3 *dena#ura! 8ed,3 *dera !ed3 na#ure wh "h s no# $e# "u!#ure5 0% &e' 2444) F>1 Aor % &e', #h s * n-6e#ween3 ( nds #s e/press on (or #he ( rs# # me n <an#-s pra"# "a! ph !osoph$ n #he ne"ess #$ #o d s" p! ne #he e/"ess .e *unru! ness3 0#ildheit1 o( human na#ure, #he *w !d, un"ons#ra ned propens #$ #o ns s# s#u66orn!$ on one-s own w !!, "os# wha# # ma$3 0% &e' 2444) F>15 Ge#, #h s *unru! ness3 "anno# 6e e7ua#ed w #h #he 6ru#e rea! #$ o( an ma! e/ s#en"e 0"on#rar$ #o s#andard read n,s15 % &e' 7uo#es <an# h mse!() The !o.e o( (reedom s na#ura!!$ so s#ron, n man, #ha# when on"e he has ,rown a""us#omed #o (reedom, he w !! sa"r ( "e e.er$#h n, (or #s sa'e5555 Hw n, #o h s na#ura! !o.e o( (reedom, # s ne"essar$ #ha# man shou!d ha.e h s na#ura! rou,hness smoo#hed downI w #h an ma!s, #he r ns# n"# renders #h s unne"essar$5 0<an# 1944) D-5I % &e' 2444) F>1 Aor % &e', #h s demons#ra#es #ha# #he en ,ma o( #he emer,en"e o( su69e"# . #$ n 2erman Idea! sm "anno# 6e redu"ed #o a mere d "ho#om$ 6e#ween nature and culture as ( n order #o "on(orm #o #he s$m6o! " !aw o( our own ma' n,, we mus# ( rs# #ame #he 6! nd, e,o# s# "a! p!easure-see' n, pr n" p!es o( our an ma! na#ure5 The se!(-"rea# .e, on#o!o, "a!!$ au#onomous m ! eu o( "u!#ure s on!$ poss 6!e #hrou,h a pr or, n( n #e!$ un"on#a na6!e (reedom wh "h a"#s as #he *.an sh n, med a#or3 6e#ween 6ru#e an ma! rea! #$ and s#ru"#ured human so" opo! # "a! e/ s#en"e5 The passa,e #o "u!#ure does no# "ons s# n an o.er"om n, or su6! ma# on o( an ma! s# " needs, 6u# ra#her #hrou,h a d s" p! n n, o( an e/"ess .e *unru! ness3 #ha# mar's human na#ure5 % &e' ! n's #h s #o #he Car#es an ,ap 6e#ween man and na#ure 6e"ause # names an n#r ns " break or breach (rom #he order o( pos # .e 6e n, #ha# se#s #he s#a,e (or #he cogito-s au#onom$ and #o #he 6 r#h p!a"e o( ps$"hoana!$s s5 Todestrieb 6e"omes a s$non$m (or #he #rans"enden#a! su69e"# 6$ , . n, e/press on #o #he pre-su69e"# .e "ond # ons o( #he poss 6 ! #$ o( (reedom as some ' nd o( . o!en# *d s#ur6an"e3 n na#ure #ha# ser.es as #s on#o,ene# " 6as s5 @u# man$ 7ues# ons rema n unso!.ed n <an#) ?h$ does #he #rans"enden#a! spon#ane #$ #se!( de.e!op: ?ha# s #s e/a"# re!a# on #o #he *unru! ness3 a# #he "ore o( our 6e n, wh "h appears #o !o, "a!!$ pre"ede #: Inso(ar as

#rans"enden#a! spon#ane #$ s re!a#ed #o #he s$n#he# " powers o( #he ma, na# on and #o *unru! ness,3 wha# s #he re!a# onsh p 6e#ween #hem: ? #h n #he #ra9e"#or$ o( modern ph !osoph$, #he nher #ors o( #he !e,a"$ o( #he "r # "a! s$s#em a!! a,ree #ha# # s w #h <an# #ha# we see #he first #ru!$ pene#ra# n, a""oun# o( #he essen"e o( human (reedom5 Jos#-<an#, a!! o( #he mmed a#e represen#a# .es o( pos#-<an# an 2erman Idea! sm a,ree #ha# #here s no ,o n, 6a"') #h s wou!d 6e #o , .e up on #he n#u # on o( rredu" 6!e human (reedom5 In #he mmed a#e a(#erma#h o( #rans"enden#a! dea! sm, howe.er, #here s an am6 ,u #$ as #o how #o pro"eed5 No# "on#en# w #h A "h#e-s own response #o #he d !emma 6e"ause # on!$ n#ens ( es #he pro6!ema# " 6$ ma' n, na#ure a mere pos # o( #he a6so!u#e su69e"#, S"he!! n, and +e,e! a##emp# #o , .e an a""oun# o( #he birthplace o( #he *I3 as causa sui5 ?ha# s ne"essar$ (or S"he!! n, s a #heore# "a! pro9e"# wh "h a##emp#s #o supp!emen# #he au# s# " A "h#ean su69e"# w #h an a""oun# o( #he mmanen# ,enes s o( su69e"# . #$ ou# o( a "rea# .e, un"ons" ous na#ure, wh "h wou!d mp! "a#e an e!a6ora# on o( #he n#erpene#ra# on and u!# ma#e den# #$ o( #he #wo5 . In # a!!$ sa# s( ed w #h S"he!! n,-s response #o #he dead!o"' o( A "h#ean dea! sm,. +e,e! !a#er 6rea's (rom wha# he re(ers #o as an *o69e"# .e dea! sm,3 a mere rea"# onar$ (orm o( dea! sm5 @u# what e/a"#!$, #hen, dr .es +e,e! #o par# wa$s (rom S"he!! n, and de.e!op h s own answer #o #he en ,ma o( #he su69e"#: And, more mpor#an#!$, wh$ s #h s 9un"#ure mpor#an# (or unders#and n, % &e'-s d a!e"# "a! ma#er a! sm: % &e' re(uses #he *"onser.a# .e3 n#erpre#a# on o( +e,e!, *#he s#andard "! "hK a""ord n, #o wh "h 2erman Idea! sm p!eads #he -pan-!o, " s#- redu"# on o( a!! rea! #$ #o #he produ"# o( #he se!(med a# on o( #he No# on3 0% &e' 2444) 5515 Th s #e/#6oo' read n, o( 2erman Idea! sm ,oes a,a ns# wha# % &e'-s ho!ds #o 6e rea!!$ a# s#a'e n #he #rad # on5 I# !e.e!s o(( #he rad "a!ness o( +e,e!-s #h n' n, 6$ ma' n, # !oo' ! 'e ano#her "!ass "a! me#aph$s "a! s$s#em5 Th s 6e"omes more o6. ous when we #a'e n#o a""oun# #he re!a# on o( pos#-"r # "a! ph !osoph$ #o Sp no8a5 Amon,s# o#her #h n,s, Sp no8 s# " me#aph$s "s represen#s an a. d a##emp# #o re#h n' #he Car#es an on#o!o, "a! sp! ## n, o( m nd and ma##er 6$ re"on"e . n, #he .er$ no# on o( su6s#an"e so #ha# #he #wo "a#e,or es no !on,er represen# a s"h sma# " sp! # 6u# are su6suma6!e under a s n,!e, un ( ed su6s#ra#e5 The$ are a ' nd o( ep s#em " para!!a/ sh (# 6e#ween #wo d ((eren# !o, "a! moda! # es o( an a!!-persuas .e wea.e wh "h en"ompasses a!! #h n,s w #h n #s . #a! e66 and (!ow5 Th s means #ha# humans are s# !! (ree, 6u# on!$ nso(ar as #he$ par# " pa#e w #h n #he se!(-a"#ua! 8 n, mo.emen# o( su6s#an"e 02od, na#ure1 as causa sui) #he apparen# au#onomous essen"e o( su69e"# . #$ s mere!$ an ep phenomenon, a (a!se appearan"e, o( #he . #a! (!u/ o( a more pr mord a! ! (e-(or"e #ha# runs #hrou,h and s mu!#aneous!$ s #he un .erse5 And a!#hou,h 6o#h S"he!! n, and +e,e! !oo' up #o Sp no8a as #he ep #ome o( a ph !osopher, #he$ see some#h n, (undamen#a!!$ nsu(( " en# n Sp no8a-s "an"e!a# on o( "on"re#e human (reedom 6$ #s su6m ss on #o #he oneness, un #$ and harmon$ o( su6s#an"e5. The pro6!em s #ha# (reedom s not "ompa# 6!e w #h su6s#an"e qua de.our n, #o#a! #$5 +ow, #hen, are we #o #h n' su6s#an"e and su69e"#Ls$s#em and (reedom ( we are #o re#a n #he spon#ane #$ a##es#ed 6$ <an# a! .e: Aor % &e', *B#Che passa,e (rom #he Sp no8an

Hne qua #he neu#ra! med umL"on#a ner o( #s modes and Bs "C #he Hne-s nheren# ,ap s #he .er$ passa,e (rom Su6s#an"e #o Su69e"#3 0% &e' 24496) D215 The mmed a#e pro6!ema# " n #he a(#erma#h o( #he "r # "a! s$s#em s #ha# #he <an# an a(( rma# on o( #rans"enden#a! (reedom mus# 6e ,rounded n an on#o!o, "a! ed ( "e #ha# "an r .a! Sp no8 sm5 +e,e! rema ns unsa# s( ed w #h #he resu!#s o( #he ear!$ S"he!! n, and mus# ha.e, a# some !e.e!, mp! " #!$ re"o,n 8ed #ha# S"he!! n, m ssed #he #rue rad "a!ness o( <an# an (reedom and #s mp! "a# ons5 Conse7uen#!$, +e,e! #r es #o sa.e #he 6rea'#hrou,h o( #he "r # "a! s$s#em 6$ #h n' n, su6s#an"e as su69e"#, 6$ #h n' n, how #he order o( 6e n, exists n #he mode o( su69e"# . #$, ns#ead o( mere!$ #$ n, #wo seem n,!$ d ((eren# $e# "omp!emen#ar$ areas o( #hou,h# #o,e#her n a pre"ar ous un #$5 The #as' #o 6e done s #o (u!!$ a"#ua! 8e #he pr mord a! ns ,h# o( #he cogito 6$ ns# #u# n, #he #rans"enden#a! *I3 and #he schism # e.o'es d re"#!$ n#o #he A6so!u#e5 The ,oa! o( % &e'-s +e,e! s #o 6a!an"e Sp no8a and <an# 6$ "rea# n, a me#aph$s "a! s$s#em #ha# possibli$es #he rup#ure n 6e n, #ha# s (reedom5 The pro6!em s #o e/p! "a#e how a #ru!$ e/ s# n, (ree su69e"# "an emer,e (rom w #h n #he n#erna! me"han "s o( su6s#an"e5 I( human (reedom s irreducibly se!(-re(!e/ .e # "anno# 6e unders#ood n #erms o( #he mmanen# pu!sa# on o( #he a6so!u#e5 Read n, #he +e,e! an response #o S"he!! n, #hrou,h ps$"hoana!$s s, % &e' su,,es#s #ha# wha# pro.o'es #he mmanen# mo.emen# (rom #rans"enden#a! ph !osoph$ #o +e,e! an su6s#an"e as su69e"# s a re"o,n # on o( an rre.o"a6!e 0on#o!o, "a!1 d s#ur6an"e o( na#ure a# #he (ounda# ona! 6as s o( #he cogito m ssed n S"he!! n,-s ear!$ %aturphilosophie5 Aor % &e', #he #rue 6rea'#hrou,h #ha# we see n <an# an dea! sm, wh "h ,e#s rad "a! 8ed and made e/p! " # (or #he ( rs# # me n +e,e!, s #he pro"!ama# on o( #rans"enden#a! (reedom as Todestrieb, as an e/"ess o( 6e n, #ha# 6rea's (rom a!! e/#erna!!$ , .en !aws5 ?e arr .e a# a "ond # ona!) I( (reedom e/ s#s, su6s#an"e "anno# 6e a!!5 Su6s#an"e-s au#od srup# on s #he "ond # on o( #he poss 6 ! #$ o( #he su69e"#5 ?ha# n#r ,ues % &e' n +e,e!-s ar# "u!a# on o( #he su69e"# as ne,a# . #$ s how # ! n's up w #h #he <an# an peda,o, "a! "on"ep#s su"h as *unru! ness3 and *d a6o! " e. !53 Inso(ar as #hese nd "a#e, (or % &e', #ha# #he 8ero-!e.e! o( human su69e"# . #$ s n some sense non&natural, # shows #ha#, ( we (o!!ow #he n#erna! "rundlogik o( 2erman Idea! sm, .ar ous +e,e! an des"r p# ons o( sp r # n "on"ep#s su"h as #he *n ,h# o( #he wor!d3 and *#arr$ n, w #h #he ne,a# .e3 are an e!a6ora# on o( #he su69e"#-s on#o!o, "o-(ounda# ona! 6as s n a d srup# on (rom #he "!osed-" r"u #r$ o( #he homoeos#a# " !aws o( na#ure as a!read$ h n#ed a# n <an#5 ?ha# #h s means s #ha# pr or #o #he se!(!e, s!a# .e !aws o( pra"# "a! reason and #he s$n#hes s o( ma, na# on #ha# "ons# #u#es #he un #$ o( phenomena! rea! #$, we mus# pos # some ' nd o( on#o!o, "a! (ren8$ #ha# represen#s a sa.a,e tearing apart o( #he mmanen# (!ow o( . #a! 6e n,5 @e(ore #he smoo#h (a6r " o( e/per en"e #here s *#he a"# . #$ o( d srup# n, #he "on# nu #$ o( #he ner# a o( #he pre-s$m6o! " -na#ura!- Rea!I3. #he pr mord a! unru! ness o( #he human or,an sm s no#h n, o#her #han a !o, "a! moda! #$ o( #rans"enden#a! ma, na# on, #s mos# or , nar$ e/press on5

II5 The Insu(( " en"$ o( #he +e,e! an Jh !osoph$ o( Na#ure +e,e! s #hus #he ( rs# #o ma'e #he "ru" a! s#ep #owards e!a6ora# n, #he #rue on#o,ene# " ,round o( #he su69e"#5 + s a""oun# o( ne,a# . #$ rad "a! 8es #he 6rea'#hrou,h o( #rans"enden#a! sm 6$ show n, how su69e"#, as #he n ,h# o( #he wor!d, *des ,na#es #he - mper(e"# on- o( Su6s#an"e, #he nheren# ,ap, se!(-de(erra!, d s#an"e-(rom- #se!(, wh "h (ore.er pre.en#s Su6s#an"e (rom (u!!$ rea! 8 n, #se!(, (rom 6e"om n, -(u!!$ #se!(-3 0% &e' 2448) 715 +owe.er, w #h n % &e'-s #e/#s one #h n, s "!ear) e.en ( #he no# on o( ne,a# . #$ n +e,e! s an a##emp# #o draw ou# #he on#o!o, "a! mp! "a# ons o( <an# an unru! ness, # #se!( res#s u!# ma#e!$ nsu(( " en# #o a"#ua! 8e #he (u!! "ore o( #he "rundlogik o( 2erman Idea! sm5 ? #h n +e,e!-s ma#ure !o, ", % &e' sees a #urn n, awa$ (rom #he #rue on#o!o, "a! e((e"#s o( su69e"# . #$ a!read$ ar# "u!a#ed n #he ear!$ Realphilosophie and e.en #he Phenomenology, a mo.e wh "h opens up #he spa"e (or #he r "u!m na# on n #he !a#e S"he!! n,5 M$ a m n #h s se"# on s #o show e/a"#!$ how % &e'-s ph !osoph$ s rad "a!!$ dependen# upon S"he!! n, an on#o!o,$ n order #o ar# "u!a#e #he no# on o( me#aph$s "a! 6rea'down so "ru" a! #o h s read n, o( 2erman Idea! sm, and #here6$ es#a6! sh #he o(#en ne,!e"#ed p!a"e o( S"he!! n, n % &e'-s #h n' n,5 The n ,h# o( #he wor!d s mere!$ a ' nd o( des"r p# on, a hapha8ard ,!an"e n#o #he d sarra$ and pandemon um #ha# pre"edes #he #rans"enden#a! re"ons# #u# on o( rea! #$ n#o a 0re!a# .e!$1 un ( ed (a6r " o( e/per en"e5 I# does no# #se!( e/p!a n #he pr mord a! momen# o( w #hdrawa! (rom "omp!e#e mmers on n #he pos # .e order o( 6e n, #ha# s ,na!s #he 6 r#h o( rredu" 6!e su69e"# . #$5 In order #o "omprehend #h s mo.emen#, we mus# ( rs# p!un,e n#o #he mmanen# pu!sa# on o( #he . #a! e66 and (!ow o( 6e n, #se!( n order #o see how # se#s #he s#a,e (or #he su69e"#, a mo.emen# wh "h % &e' e/p! " #!$ sa$s s mos# a"u#e!$ de.e!oped n S"he!! n,) <an# was #he ( rs# #o de#e"# #h s "ra"' n #he on#o!o, "a! ed ( "e o( rea! #$) ( 0wha# we e/per en"e as1 *o69e"# .e rea! #$3 s no# s mp!$ , .en *ou# #here,3 wa # n, #o 6e per"e .ed 6$ #he su69e"#, 6u# a ar# ( " a! "ompos #e "ons# #u#ed #hrou,h #he su69e"#-s a"# .e par# " pa# on E #ha# s, #hrou,h #he a"# o( #rans"enden#a! s$n#hes s E #hen #he 7ues# on "rops up sooner or !a#er) wha# s #he s#a#us o( #he un"ann$ ; #ha# precedes #he #rans"enden#a!!$ "ons# #u#ed rea! #$: A5 ?5 J5 S"he!! n, ,a.e #he mos# de#a !ed a""oun# o( #h s ; n h s no# on o( #he 2round o( E/ s#en"e E o( #ha# wh "h * n 2od + mse!( s no# $e# 2od)3 #he *d . ne madness,3 #he o6s"ure pre-on#o!o, "a! doma n o( *dr .es,3 #he pre-!o, "a! Rea! #ha# (ore.er rema ns #he e!us .e 2round o( Reason5 0% &e' 2444) 551

@u#, ( #h s 7ues# on o( #he emergence o( appearan"e (rom #he pre-s$m6o! " Rea! s a Hegelian pro9e"#, wh$ doesn-# % &e' re!$ on, (or e/amp!e, #he +e,e! an ph !osoph$ o( na#ure n order #o e/pound #: Jo n# n, #o wha# he #a'es as an am6 ,u #$ #ha# pers s#s w #h n +e,e!-s a""oun# o( #he d a!e"# "a! mo.emen# (rom se!(-"on#a ned No# on #o na#ure and #hen #o sp r # n h s ma#ure !o, ",

% &e' su,,es#s #ha# +e,e! was una6!e #o 6r n, n#o "on"ep#ua! (u!!ness #he ,round6rea' n, rea! 8a# on #ha# he was on #he .er,e o( ar# "u!a# n,5. ?ha# s !e(# as de s, s#r "#!$ spea' n,, #he n ,h# o( #he wor!d #ha# h s ear! er Realphilosophie had un"o.ered5 In #he !a#er wor's, # s un"er#a n how #h s rad "a! se!(-re!a# n, ne,a# . #$, #h s momen# o( rredu" 6!e on#o!o, "a! 6rea'down, #ru!$ ( #s n5 Ins#ead o( #he pre"ar ous, ne.er-#o-6e-"omp!e#e *re"on" ! a# on3 6e#ween na#ure and ( n #e sp r # as we see n #he Realphilosophie 0due #o #he a6$ssa! .o d o( #he su69e"#1, "u!#ure #se!( 6e"omes a "!osed " r"u #, a "omp!e#e re#urn o( #he Idea #o #se!( ou# o( #s se!(-ou#s dedness n na#ure, wh "h "omp!e#e!$ does awa$ w #h #he *ps$"ho# "3 "on#ra"# on n#o Se!(5 The *here shoo#s a 6!ood$ head, #here ano#her ,hos#!$ appar # on3 d sappears5 Aor % &e', #here are #hus #wo (orms o( +e,e! an d a!e"# "s) e #her we ha.e #he per(e"# d a!e"# "a! triad o( #he ma#ure s$s#em 0=o, " E Na#ure E Sp r #1, or a non-"!osed quadruple wh "h s ,na!s #he se!(-"o!!apse o( d a!e"# "a! !o, " #se!( o( #he Realphilosophie 0=o, " E Na#ure E ( n #e Sp r # E o69e"# .eLna#ura! 8ed Sp r #15 / The d ((eren"e 6e#ween #rad # ona! a""oun#s o( A6so!u#e Idea! sm and #he 7uadrup!e d a!e"# " o( #he Realphilosophie demons#ra#e #he na#ure o( d a!e"# "a! !o, " he wan#s #o de(end as #he "rundlogik a# wor' w #h n 2erman Idea! sm and de.e!op n h s own para!!a/ on#o!o,$5 ?hereas #he (ormer "an 6e unders#ood as a ser es o( upward mo. n, sp ra!s where ea"h new #urn "omp!e#e!$ en"ompasses #he pre. ous so #ha# e.en#ua!!$ we ha.e a "omp!e#e!$ en"!osed, or,an " #o#a! #$, #he .er$ se!(-un(o!d n, opera# on o( #he !a#er pre"!udes #he poss 6 ! #$ o( su"h a se!(-#o#a! 8 n, a"# . #$5 The passa,e (rom na#ure #o "u!#ure does no# re.ea! a s#ru,,!e o( #ransmu#a# on, 6u# an rre.o"a6!e s#ands# !! n #he hear# o( 6e n, #ha# "anno# 6e sursumed5 I# s (rom #h s ne,a# . #$ #ha# #he pro"ess o( su69e"# .a# on 0"u!#ure1 emer,es, a!!ow n, na#ure and "u!#ure #o se!(-a"#ua! 8e n so!a# on #o one ano#her 6u# a# #he same # me *! n'ed3 #o,e#her #hrou,h #he a6$ssa! .o d o( su69e"# . #$, #ha# wh "h n( n #e!$ *pro#rudes3 ou# o( 6o#h5 +ere we ha.e a r "h a""oun# o( #he emergence o( au#onomous 8ones o( a"# . #$ wh "h rema n rredu" 6!e #o a!#hou,h s mu!#aneous!$ dependen# on #he pre"eden# !e.e!s wh "h "ons# #u#e #he r ,ene# " ,round5 ?ha# one w !! no# "e here s #he n#r ns "a!!$ Schellingian "hara"#er o( #h s d s# n"# on5/ ?hereas ma#ure +e,e! (a!!s n#o #he #rap o( a "omp!e#e #r ad " !o, ", # s #he !a#e S"he!! n, who, a##emp# n, #o presen# a !o, "a! s$s#em #ha# wou!d 6e a6!e #o "om6a# wha# he per"e .ed as #he horr ($ n, *pan-!o, " sm3 o( +e,e! an d a!e"# "s, s a"#ua!!$ a rad "a! 8a# on, a completion, o( #he nheren# "rundlogik o( 2erman Idea! sm5 Th s su,,es#s no# on!$ #ha# % &e' s re#roa"# .e!$ unpa"' n, a !a#en#, 6u# "o.ered up po#en# a!, n +e,e!-s #e/# #hrou,h S"he!! n,, 6u# a!so #ha# #he ,erm o( #he !a##er-s !a#e ph !osoph$ s a!read$ !o"a#ed w #h n +e,e!-s ear!$ Realphilosophie, draw n, a "ons s#en# h s#or "a! #ra9e"#or$ (rom #he 6e, nn n, #o #he end o( 2erman Idea! sm5 In order #o s #ua#e ourse!.es more ( rm!$ w #h n #he d a!e"# "a! rad "a!ness o( S"he!! n,-s 'reiheitsschrift and #eltalter, we "an use #he pro6!em o( e. ! as an en#r$ po n#5 S"he!! n,- 6as " #hes s s #ha#, a!#hou,h +e,e! an =o, " "an e/press no# ona! ne"ess #$ 0wha# some#h n, dea!!$ s1,

# u!# ma#e!$ (a !s #o ,rasp #he fact o( 6e n,, #he pr mord a! 6as s o( #s raw rea! #$ n (reedom, some#h n, wh "h (ore.er e!udes #he se!(-med a# on o( "on"ep#ua! #$5 ?hereas (or +e,e! e. ! 6e"omes mere!$ a sursumed momen# n #he se!(-de.e!opmen# o( #he 2ood, a ne"essar$ phase (or #s es#a6! shmen#, (or S"he!! n, e. ! rema ns a# #s .er$ "ore arational, non&logical5 There s some#h n, rredu" 6!e a6ou# #he "ho "e (or e. ! wh "h ne"essar !$ e!udes our "on"ep#s, some#h n, nsurmoun#a6!e a6ou# #he unru! ness o( a sou! #ha# ns s#s on #ha# wh "h # wan#s and w !! sa"r ( "e wha#e.er # "an n order #o a"h e.e #5 E. ! s #he "apa" #$ #o sa$ *No3 w #h #he (u!! 'now!ed,e o( #he mp! "a# ons o( one-s a"# on5 As soon as e. ! s unders#ood and "on"ep#ua! 8ed, # (a !s #o 6e e!il ( # 6e"omes, ra#her, m s,u ded ,ood n #he J!a#on " sense #ha# no one does wron, w !! n,!$5 +en"e S"he!! n,-s ar# "u!a# on o( (reedom as #he poss 6 ! #$ (or ,ood and e. !5 I# o( #se!( 'nows no order, no ra# ona! #$) #here s some#h n, mad a6ou# a (ree a"#5 Tha# s #o sa$, nso(ar as #he a"# #se!( s "on"erned, 6o#h #he moda! # es o( ,ood and e. ! as e/press ons o( (reedom are formally identical nso(ar as #he$ n.o!.e #he "ho "e o( a se# o( .a!ues without any guarantee and without any external determination5 ?ha# #h s su,,es#s s #ha# e. ! s #se!( a# #he "ore o( e.er$ ,ood a"#) n order (or an a"# #o 6e #ru!$ ,ood and au#hen# "a!!$ (ree a# #he same # me, # mus# *pass3 #hrou,h e. !, d s" p! ne #, and use # as #he #amed "rund (or #s own e/pans .e power5/ In #h s sense, #he S"he!! n, an (reedom s an e/p! " # re#h n' n, o( #he <an# an no# on o( d a6o! " e. ! and #s "oe7ua! "on"ep# o( #he or , na! *unna#ura!3 unru! ness) # #r es #o de.e!op a ph !osoph "a!, on#o-!o, " "on"ep# where6$ rad "a! spon#ane #$ o( human pra"# "a! a"# . #$ s rredu" 6!e #o no# ona! ne"ess #$ and es"apes our "omp!e#e "on"ep#ua! 8a# on5 I# s an nd . s 6!e rema nder, #he * n"omprehens 6!e 6as s o( rea! #$,3 m ss n, n ma#ure +e,e! an d a!e"# "s5/ I# s #h s "on. "# on o( #he rredu" 6 ! #$ o( (ree de" s on #ha# !eads S"he!! n, n#o #he a6$ssa! !a6$r n#hs o( se!(-e/p!ora# on #ha# "ons# #u#e #he "on"ep#ua! (a6r " o( #he #eltalter, (o!!ow n, <an#-s n#u # ons n h s peda,o, "a! wr # n,s5 Aor % &e', #here(ore, # s no# an a"" den# #ha# S"he!! n,-s own des"r p# ons o( #he .or#e/ o( Triebe wh "h pre"ede #he spo'en ?ord are remar'a6!$ s m !ar n sp r # #o +e,e!-s des"r p# ons o( #he n ,h# o( #he wor!d) 6o#h are dr .en 6$ an a##emp# #o , .e a ph !osoph "a!!$ ade7ua#e 6edro"' #o (reedom, #he !a#en# "rundlogik o( 2erman Idea! sm5 ?ha# n#eres#s % &e', #here(ore, s how S"he!! n, dras# "a!!$ ad.an"es #he des"r p# ons n #he #rad # on o( #he e!us .e ;, #he je ne sais quoi, wh "h haun#s #rans"enden#a!!$ "ons# #u#ed rea! #$ 6$ "omp!e# n, p!un, n, n#o #he au#od srup# .e !o, " o( #he pre-s$m6o! " Rea! n a wa$ unpre"eden#ed 6$ an$ ph !osopher 6e(ore h m5 S"he!! n, demons#ra#es a remar'a6!e ns ,h# n#o #he mmanen#, #hr . n, (or"es o( #he e/#ra-Lpre-s$m6o! ", ma#er a! Rea!, #he e!us .e, o6s"ure phase o( dar'ness #ha# pre"edes and "ons# #u#es #he 6 r#h o( #he ! ,h# o( "ons" ousness5 @u# wha# n#r ,ues % &e' s #he rad "a!ness, #he dep#h, o( h s materialist response #o +e,e!, wh "h s# !! rema ns mmersed n #he (a6r " o( #rans"enden#a! dea! sm5 I( we super mpose on#o #he S"he!! n,-s ,roundLe/ s#en"e d s# n"# on #he

rea!0 #$1L dea!0 #$1 d s# n"# on #ha# s opera# .e w #h n modern ph !osoph$ (rom Mes"ar#es onward, we per"e .e a nuan"e n #he on#o!o, 8a# onL,round n, o( #he su69e"# . #$) #he split announ"ed 6e#ween m nd and ma##er, wh "h ma'es #hem non-re"on" !a6!e #o one ano#her, occurs )within* or )on the side of* the material Real through a schismatic rupture+ The s#andard de6a#e 6e#ween dea! sm and ma#er a! sm s #hus sp! # on #s head) dea! sm pos #s an dea! E.en# wh "h "anno# 6e a""oun#ed (or n #erms o( #s ma#er a! 0pre1"ond # ons, wh !e #he ma#er a! s# wa,er s #ha# we can ,e# *6eh nd3 #he e.en# and e/p!ore how E.en# e/p!odes ou# o( #he ,ap nLo( #he order o( @e n,5 The ( rs# #o (ormu!a#e #h s #as' was S"he!! n,, who, n h s #eltalter (ra,men#s, ou#! ned #he dar' #err #or$ o( #he -preh s#or$ o( =o,os,- o( wha# had #o o""ur n preon#o!o, "a! pro#orea! #$ so #ha# openness o( =o,os and #empora! #$ "ou!d #a'e p!a"e5 0% &e' 24496) 1>>1

So how, #hen, do #he pu!sa# ons o( pure, raw ma#er a! #$ open up un#o #he rredu" 6!e e.en# o( #he dea!: A!#hou,h % &e'-s own des"r p# ons n The ndi!isible Remainder and *The A6$ss o( Areedom3 o( #he passa,e (rom #he ro#ar$ mo.emen# o( Triebe #o a su69e"# #ha# s non-"o n" den# w #h #s ma#er a! "rund (o"us on #he (ound n, ,es#ure o( su69e"# . #$ as a ( a#, #h s s no# enou,h5 The 7ues# on s how #he d-! 'e pu!sa# on o( #he dr .es grounds #he se!(-pos # n, a"# o( #he de" s on5 As Adr an Johns#on ma'es as#on sh n,!$ "!ear, e.en ( #he se!(-pos # n, a"# o( #he su69e"# is a ,round!ess a"# *ana!o,ous #o #he "u## n, o( #he 2ord an 'no#3 0% &e' 2447) 1F1, S"he!! n, sear"hes (or a wa$ #o ns"r 6e #he .er$ "ond # on o( #he poss 6 ! #$ o( #he a"# #se!( w #h n #he ma#er a! pa!p #a# ons o( na#ure n wor's (or #he mos# par# no# d s"ussed 6$ % &e'5/ In #h s sense, % &e'-s own a""oun# s d ssa# s($ n, 6e"ause # (a !s #o show n de#a ! how #he dr .es, o( #hemse!.es, shor# " r"u #5 As Johns#on po n#s ou#, w #h n #he S"he!! n, an on#o,ene# " narra# .e, #he se!(-pos # n, o( #he su69e"# s ( rs# poss 6! 8ed 6$ #he emer,en"e o( desire w #h n 6e n,5 Mes re mar's #he ( rs# 9un"#ure o( some ' nd o( mmanen# 6!o"'a,e n #he hear# o( 6! nd ne"ess #$ wh "h o6(us"a#es #he au#oma# " os" !!a# on o( dr .es 6$ sha##er n, #he r pure mmanen"e5 In p!a"e o( a smoo#h, de#erm ned re!a# on #o #he en. ronmen# who!!$ pro,rammed 6$ ns# n"#s 0#he "o n" den"e o( nnenwelt and ,ussenwelt #hrou,h an prede#erm ned se# o( 6 o!o, "a! s"hema#a #ha# hardw re #he or,an sm n#o #s surround n,s1, we ,e# a de,ree o( ! 6era# on (rom #he .ar ous sense da#um o( per"ep# on5 Mes re n #s S"he!! n, an mode s #hus an n#ermed ar$ s#a,e 6e#ween ns# n"# and dr .e w #h n #he on#o,enes s o( #he #rans"enden#a! *I53 The % &e' anL+e,e! an n ,h# o( #he wor!d emer,es as #he non"ons" ous dr .es o( na#ure (or #he ( rs# # me ! 6era#e #hemse!.es (rom #he 6! nd ne"ess #$ o( 6e n, #hrou,h an mmanen#!$ ,enera#ed pandemon um w #h n #he "orpo-Rea! o( #he 6od$5 Jroper!$ spea' n,, des re s an mpasse w #h n #he on#o!o, "a! ! (e o( su6s#an"e E *BsC n"e #here s "onse7uen#!$ an unrem ## n, ur,e

#o 6e and s n"e # "anno# 6e, # "omes #o a s#ands# !! n des re, as an unrem ## n, s#r . n,, an e#erna!!$ nsa# a6!e o6sess on w #h @e n,3 0S"he!! n, 2444a) 211 E wh "h pre.en#s # (rom de.our n,, encompassing, a!!, 6e"ause #he or,an sm now o6e$s #s own nonna#ura! !o, "5 +ere, #he ana!o,ue w #h #he 6od$ s use(u!5 A!#hou,h #he 6 o!o, "a! un #$ o( #he "orpo-Rea! "an as#ound us w #h #s or,an " d$nam sm, #he .er$ aw n, (or"e o( #h s se!(-or,an 8 n, #o#a! #$ "an "as# a shadow o.er #s dar' under6e!!$5 Th s a (a"# o(#en 6e#ra$ed 6$ #he m nd!ess pro! (era# on o( "an"erous #umours, mus"u!ar d$s#roph$ and men#a! !!nesses "aused 6$ pure or,an " d$s(un"# on5 The !aws #ha# norma!!$ re,u!a#e and sus#a n #he 6od$ "an, o( #hemse!.es, mmanen#!$ shor# " r"u #5 = 'e an !!ness or d sease w #h n S"he!! n, an !o, ", des re does no# s#and (or a pos # .e on#o!o, "a! un #$ n an$ wa$ (or % &e', 6u#, ra#her an n#erna! s"ram6! n, o( #he " r"u #r$ o( a s$s#em #ha# does no# (o!!ow #s supposed pa#h w #h n #he who!e and ns#ead s#u66orn!$ asser#s #s own Se!( a# a!! "os#s E e.en #s own down(a!! 6$ "u## n, awa$ #he ! (e-s#ream #ha# 'eeps # n 6e n,5/ . As #he (or"e o( des re s ra sed #o a h ,her de,ree o( dea! #$, ma##er en#ers n#o a se!(!a"era# n, ra,e 0sich selbst $erei-ende #ut1 ! 'e a "an"er-r dden, d sease-s#r "'en 6od$, how! n, under #s own ou#-o(-"on#ro! ener,$5 Mes re a . o!en# se!(-des#ru"# .e man a #ha# tears apart #he smoo#h (a6r " o( #he wor!d5 Th s s wh$ % &e' ( nds S"he!! n,-s *?a,ner an3 . s on o( 2od s so #err ($ n,5 I# represen#s a na#ure wh "h, #hrou,h #he (u!! amp! ( "a# on o( des re n#o Todestrieb, 6e"omes denaturali$ed5/. The pr mord a! unru! ness o( human na#ure and #s "oe7ua! #erm d a6o! "a! e. ! are #here(ore s$non$mous w #h #h s ,ro#es7ue e/"ess o( ! (e #ha# we w #ness n #he 6rea'down o( #he "orpo-Rea! n # mes o( !!nessI or, as Johns#on sa$s, *B#Che surp!us o( au#onom$ s made poss 6!e 6$ #he de( " # o( he#eronom$5 Areedom emer,es (rom #he d$s(un"# on n, o( de#erm n sm3 0Johns#on 2444) 11D15 The (reedom o( #he su69e"# s no# a pos # .e "hara"#er s# " or a##r 6u#e) # s #he (a !ure o( au#oa"#ua! 8a# on o( essen"e, #s na6 ! #$ #o "on#a n #se!( w #h n #s own prese# !o, s# "s, *a ma!(un"# on o( e.o!u# on,3 *a sna, n #he 6 o!o, "a! wea.e3 0% &e' N Ma!$ 244D) 5915/. Mes re, #hus, nd "a#es a 6e, nn n, o( 6e n,-s on#o!o, "a! passa,e #hrou,h madness5 % &e'-s ar,umen# s #ha# #h s ps$"ho# " au#od srup# on o( #he Rea! s a necessary #heore# "a! pos # ( (ree e/per en"e s #o 6e poss 6!e ns#ead o( a 6! nd e/per en# a! .o d) *BwCe "anno# pass d re"#!$ (rom na#ure #o "u!#ure5 Some#h n, ,oes #err 6!$ wron, n na#ure) na#ure produ"es an unna#ura! mons#ros #$ and I "!a m #ha# # s n order #o "ope w #h, #o domes# "a#e, #h s mons#ros #$ #ha# we s$m6o! 8e3 0% &e' N Ma!$ 244D) >D->515/. I# s on!$ #hrou,h a rad "a! en,a,emen# w #h S"he!! n, an on#o!o,$, howe.er, #ha# % &e' s a6!e #o (u!!$ ar# "u!a#e #he dea o( a 7uadrup!e d a!e"# " o( non-re"on" !a6 ! #$ and "!a m #ha# # s#ands as #he "u!m na# on o( #he "rundlogik nheren# #o #he en# re 2erman Idea! s# #rad # on5 @u#, ma##ers 6e"ome more "omp! "a#e as we sha!! see n #he ne/# se"# on, nso(ar as % &e' s on!$ a6!e #o appropr a#e #h s "a#e,or$ o( *me#aph$s "a! "o!!apse3 #hrou,h e/pos n, and e/"a.a# n, a +e,e! an !o, " o( ne,a# . #$ #ha# he sees h dden w #h n #he 2nd dra(# o( #he #eltalter+

10

III5 The Res#!essness o( #he Ne,a# .e Th s se"# on w !! demons#ra#e #ha#, a!#hou,h % &e' depends upon S"he!! n,-s on#o!o,$ #o e/p! "a#e #he emer,en"e o( #he su69e"#, +e,e! s omn presen# n % &e'-s read n,5 ?e w !! see #ha#, s n"e S"he!! n,-s own a""oun# o( #he !o, " o( #he "rund has #heosoph " #enden" es #ha# are n "on#rad "# on w #h wha# % &e' #a'es #o 6e #he (ound n, n#u # ons ,u d n, 2erman Idea! sm, he s on!$ a6!e #o e/#ra"# a "ons s#en# me#aps$"ho!o,$ (rom S"he!! n, nso(ar as he "an *(orma! 8e3 or *pur ($3 #s "on#en#5 Jer"e . n, a s#r "#!$ Hegelian s#ru"#ure o( se!(-re!a# n, ne,a# . #$ n #he e/pos # on o( (reedom n #he 2nd dra(# o( #he #eltalter #ha# opens up un#o an den# ( "a# on o( "rund and e/ s#en"e #ha# s m ss n, n #he o#hers, % &e' n#erna!!$ re"ons#ru"#s #he en# re "on"ep#ua! s#ru"#ure o( S"he!! n,-s on#o!o,$ #hrou,h +e,e! an d a!e"# "s and ps$"hoana!$s s5 The ssue a# hand s (ur#her "omp! "a#ed 6$ % &e'-s d . s on o( S"he!! n,-s ph !osoph$ n#o #hree d s# n"# and rre"on" !a6!e s#a,es, wh "h he ( nds re(!e"#ed n #hree e/ s#en# dra(#s o( #he #eltalter5/. S"he!! n,1 s !ar,e!$ "o- n" den#a! w #h h s 7uas -Sp no8 s# " ph !osoph$ o( A6so!u#e Ind ((eren"e, where (reedom s "omp!e#e!$ su6sumed under #he pos # .e order o( 6e n,5 In #he 1s# dra(# #h s s seen w #h #he e/p! "a# on o( (reedom as a !o, "a! mode o( ne"ess #$ w #h n #he nner ar# "u!a# on o( su6s#an"e5 In S"he!! n,2 o( #he 2nd dra(# o( #he #eltalter and #he 'reiheitsschrift, we see an n#eres# n, #w s# n #erms o( how #he "on#ra"# on o( ma#er a! 6e n, #se!( s made poss 6!e5 @$ "on"e . n, #he a"# o( "on#ra"# on #se!( as u!# ma#e!$ (ree and se!(-pos # n,, here S"he!! n, s a6!e #o #h n' #he w !!-#o-"on#ra"# on 0#he No1 and #he w !!-#o-e/pans on 0#he Ges1 as den# "a! and #here(ore internal #o #he d$nam " o( (reedom, wh "h ma'es h s #h n' n, approa"h #ha# o( +e,e!-s 0and, "onse7uen#!$, #he "rundlogik o( 2erman Idea! sm15 Aor % &e', #h s 6r e( per od o( 6rea'#hrou,h was 7u "'!$ !e(# 6eh nd 6$ S"he!! n,F o( #he ph !osoph$ o( m$#ho!o,$ and re.e!a# on5 +ere we see a re#urn #o pre-modern *essen# a! sm,3 wh "h he "!a ms we a!read$ see h n#ed a# n #he Frd dra(# o( #he #eltalter, n wh "h S"he!! n, pos #s an ano#her pr n" p!e o( s$n#hes s external to #he mo.emen# o( "on#ra"# on and e/pans on w #h n wh "h (reedom and de#erm n sm are ,rounded as oppos #es5 @e"ause o( #hese #enden" es, wh "h e/p!a n O 8e' 7ua! ( es S"he!! n, as #he (a#her o( *New A,e o6s"uran# sm3 9us# as mu"h as he s #he (a#her o( "on#emporar$ ph !osoph$ o( ( n #ude, mmed a#e!$ a(#er h s pro.o"a# .e read n, o( S"he!! n, n #he ( rs# "hap#er o( #he ndi!isible Remainder, % &e' 7u "'!$ "han,es #one and ar,ues (or #he suprema"$ o( +e,e! an d a!e"# "s o.er S"he!! n, an !o, "5 A!#hou,h "ons s#en# w #h h s n#erpre#a# on o( S"he!! n,, # s s mu!#aneous!$ am6 ,uous nso(ar as % &e' does no# d s# n,u sh which S"he!! n, he s ar,u n, a,a ns# or 9us# ($ how he s a6!e #o read #he 2nd dra(# o( #he #eltalter as a rad "a! and ephemera! rup#ure #ha# *,oes (ar#hes# n #he d re"# on o( Areedom3 0% &e' 2447) F815 S n"e #he on!$ poss 6!e wa$ (or (reedom #o e/ s# (or % &e' s #hrou,h #he no# on o( #he rre.o"a6!e "aus# " "o!!apse o( #he on#o!o, "a!, how s % &e' a6!e #o re#r e.e #h s (rom #he 2nd dra(# w #hou# (a!! n, n#o #he p #(a!!s o( S"he!! n,-s #h n' n,: The answer s #ha# n #he 2nd dra(# % &e' sees a d s# n"# .e!$ Hegelian s#ru"#ure #ha#

11

ena6!es h m #o de.e!op a me#aps$"ho!o, "a! read n, o( #he #e/# #ha# pre.en#s #s under!$ n, on#o!o,$ (rom su""um6 n, #o ph !osoph "a! "omm #men#s #ha# #urn awa$ (rom #he "rundlogik o( 2erman Idea! sm5 The "!a m s #ha#, a(#er #he rad "a! on#o!o,$ o( (reedom #ha# he had de.e!oped n #he 2nd dra(#, S"he!! n, mmed a#e!$ re"o !s (rom #he mp! "a# ons o( h s ph !osoph$ #hrou,h pos # n, a (our#h pr n" p!e o( med #a# on wh "h ena6!es #he neu#ra! "oe/ s#en"e o( "rund and e/ s#en"e #hrou,h ,round n, #hem w #h n #he .ngrund+ +ere, ns#ead o( announ" n, #he rad "a! rup#ure o( 6e n,, #he no#-a!! o( su6s#an"e, (reedom s a mere re#urn #o #he a6$ssa! or , n o( a!! rea! #$5 @$ d sp!a$ n, #he s#ru"#ure o( a #heosoph " 7ua#ern #$, #he Frd dra(# and !a#er #e/#s o( S"he!! n, are a re#urn #o a (orm o( do,ma# " me#aph$s "s, an na6 ! #$ #o ho!d un#o #he #ru#h o( rredu" 6!e (reedom5 @u# nso(ar as #he 2nd dra(# d sp!a$s (reedom as a ' nd o( se!(-pos # n, a"# . #$ wh "h den# ( es "rund 0#he w !!-#o-"on#ra"# on, #he No1 and e/ s#en"e 0#he w !!-#o-e/pans on, #he Ges1, % &e' sees #he poss 6 ! #$ #o *(orma! 8e3 #s "on#en# 6$ *pur ($ n,3 # o( a!! e/#raneous #heosoph " "omm #men# #hrou,h #he rea"#ua! 8a# on o( #h s +e,e! an d a!e"# "a! #enden"$5 % &e' s a6!e #o 9us# ($ #h s mo.e nso(ar as he reads #he s# !!-6orn dra(#s o( #he #eltalter as a m$#h n #he (orm o( #he =a"an an !ame!!a, e/p!a n n, #ha# *#he need (or #he (orm o( m$#h "a! narra# .e ar ses when one endea.ours #o 6rea' #he " r"!e o( #he s$m6o! " order and #o , .e an a""oun# o( # s ,enes s 0-or , ns-1 (rom #he Rea!3 0% &e' 2447) 915 ? #h n #he s# !!-6orn dra(#s #he #eltalter, S"he!! n, d . des #he passa,e (rom #he e#erna! Jas# 0Rea!1 #o #he Jresen# 0S$m6o! "1 n#o #hree d s# n"# s#a,es5/ / In #he a6so!u#e 6e, nn n, pr or #o 2od-s "on#ra"# on o( ma#er a! 6e n, and #he 6! nd, annu!ar ro#a# on o( dr .es, #here s a 9o$ous no#h n,ness, a pure po#en# a! #$ #ha# e/ s#s n # me!ess, ne/haus# 6!e rap#ure5 ?ha# s o( u#mos# mpor#an"e here s #he rre"on" !a6!e "on#ras# 6e#ween #h s s#a,e and #he ne/#) #he 9o$ous .o d o( d . ne non6e n, s *6rea"hed3 6$ #he "on#ra"# on o( ( n #ude and #he n( n #e se!(-d remp# on o( per(e"# on #ha# # en#a !s5 Th s sunder n, o( hea.en!$ s$mme#r$ s #hus s#ru"#ura!!$ den# "a! #o #he d srup# on o( #he o"ean " un #$ o( "h !d and mo#her #ha# supposed!$ pre"edes #he Hed pus "omp!e/, #he smoo#h, p!a" d (un"# on n, o( na#ure, wh "h s s'ewered 6$ #he ad.en# o( human su69e"# . #$5 A(#er #he "on#ra"# on o( ma#er a! 6e n,, we ha.e wha# % &e' "a!!s *S"he!! n,-s ,rand ose -?a,ner an- . s on o( 2od3 0% &e' 2447) 2D15 ? #h n S"he!! n, an "osmo,on$, #h s s so *#err ($ n,3 6e"ause, ns#ead o( #he end!ess 9o$ o( d . ne e#ern #$, we ha.e a 2od as su69e"# who ( nds + mse!( un(ree and "au,h# w #h n #he se!(-!a"era# n, ra,e o( ma##er5 In #erms o( a me#aps$"ho!o,$, # "an 6e read as a m$#hopoe# " des"r p# on o( #he on#o!o, "a! shor# " r"u # w #h n #he 6! nd ro#a# on o( Triebe wh "h o""urs 6e(ore #he erup# on o( (u!!-(!ed,ed su69e"# . #$5 A na!!$, we ha.e 2od who s a6!e #o spea' #he ?ord and #hus o.er"ome #he dead!o"' #ha# he (ound h mse!( !od,ed w #h n 6$ 6e"om n, a (u!!-(!ed,ed su69e"#5 E9e"# n, #he ma#er a! #$ he had "on#ra"#ed, he 6es#ows upon # an ndependen# e/ s#en"e and 6e"omes 2od #he Crea#or5 Me#aps$"ho!o, "a!!$, n #he ?ord we see #he un"ons" ous /ntscheiduing wh "h separa#es "rund and e/ s#en"e (or #he ( rs# # me5 The S$m6o! " erup#s as an a##emp# #o d s" p! ne #he unru! ness o(

12

#he ma#er a! o( #he pre. ous s#a,e #ha# !a"'s an$ se!(-or,an 8 n, s"hema#a5 Aor % &e', howe.er, #he ps$"hoana!$# "a! pro6!em s #ha# #he s#ru"#ure o( #he n.es# ,a# on has #he (undamen#a! s#ru"#ure o( (an#as$5// In #he ar# "u!a# on o( #he a6so!u#e 6e, nn n,, we nser# ourse!.es as a pure ,a8e n#o #he pre-s$m6o! " Rea!, 9us# as ( we were #o ma, ne ourse!.es as a spe"#a#or n our (unera!s wa#"h n, our (r ends rea"# #o our dea#h5 I( #he n#rospe"# .e ana!$s s wh "h !eads #o #he d s"uss on o( #he 9o$ous no#h n,ness s mere!$ a ma, nar$ (a!s ( "a# on, how "an % &e' re!$ on # #o propound h s own a""oun# o( "rundlogik o( 2erman Idea! sm as so "ru" a! (or h s para!!a/ on#o!o,$: The pro6!em wh "h % &e' (a"es s one o( #he p #(a!!s o( #he Rea! n#o wh "h S"he!! n, (e!!) 6e"ause we "an on!$ re#roa"# .e!$ pos # #he ma#er a! or , n o( su69e"# . #$ (rom w #h n #he S$m6o! " and #he Ima, nar$, #he des"r p# ons o( #he #h s na#a!, a6$ssa! dar'ness "an ser.e as a mere s"reen upon wh "h we pro9e"# (an#asma# " supp!emen#s5 The r s' s #ha# ( our n.es# ,a# on opera#es only on #he !e.e! o( phenomeno!o, "a! se!(-ana!$s s # 9eopard 8es ha. n, a!! o( #s s ,n ( "an"e a6o! shed #hrou,h a redu"# on #o #he nar" ss s# " or6 # o( #he Ima, nar$5 % &e' needs #o p er"e #hrou,h #he ps$"hoana!$# "a! super( " a! #$ o( S"he!! n,-s des"r p# ons o( #he passa,e (rom #he Jas# #o #he Jresen# 6$ remo. n, #h s e!emen# o( #he Ima, nar$ n order #o arr .e a# #s !a#en# !o, "a! 'erne!5 Inso(ar as % &e' sees #ra"es o( +e,e! an !o, " n #he 2nd dra(#-s des"r p# on o( (reedom, he "!a ms #he pr mord a! 8ero-!e.e! (a"# n #he passa,e (rom #he Jas# #o #he Jresen# has #o 6e #he se"ond s#a,e, #he se!(-!a"era# n, ra,e o( ma##er5 The 9o$ous no#h n,ness, wh "h "orresponds #o #he e#erna! "a!m o( #he pure mmanen"e o( su6s#an"e #ha# pre"edes #he on#o!o, "a! unru! ness n #he dead!o"' o( dr .es and #he s#ru,,!e #o spea' #he word, "an 6e redu"ed #o (undamen#a! (an#as$ o( #he e,o5 The "!a m s #ha# one "anno# draw a me#aph$s "a! d s# n"# on 6e#ween su6s#an"e as a no#h n,ness #ha# re9o "es n #he o"ean " 6! ss o( non-e/per en"e and #he unru!$ 6as s o( human su69e"# . #$ wh "h *d srup#s3 #h s un #$5 I( we super mpose S"he!! n,-s #hree s#a,es un#o #he +e,e! an d a!e"# ", wh "h s 9us# ( ed #hrou,h #he e7ua# on o( #he w !!-#o-"on#ra"# on 0#he No, #he w !! o( #he "rund1 w #h #he w !!-#o-e/pans on 0#he Ges, (ree e/ s#en"e1, we ,e# #he a !o, "a! mo.emen# (rom mmed a"$ 0Rea!1 P ne,a# on 0unru! ness1 P ne,a# on o( ne,a# on 0S$m6o! "1 where n #he se"ond mo.emen# s ns"r 6ed w #h n #he ( rs#, wh "h on!$ 6e"omes e/p! " # n #he #h rd, n #he same wa$ #ha# "orresponds w #h % &e' nser# on o( dea! #$ within rea! #$ as #s e/# ma#e ,erm as #he #ru#h o( S"he!! n,-s !o, " o( #he "rund5 Aor % &e', #h s d a!e"# "a! ma#er a! s# !o, " #ha# we see premon # ons o( n #he 2nd dra(# a!!ows us #o add pre" s on #o #he 2erman Idea! s# a##emp# #o #h n' su6s#an"e as su69e"#5 The mode! o( #he on#o,ene# " 6as s o( su69e"# . #$ as a "on#ra"# on o( a d sease w #h n #he . #a! (o!d o( 6e n, needs #o 6e "!ar ( ed, nso(ar as #here was ne.er a per(e"# 6a!an"e #ha# #he ha$w re o( human unru! ness des#ro$s5 Th s s e/a"#!$ wh$ % &e' pro"!a ms #he super or #$ o( +e,e! an !o, " and d sm sses S"he!! n,-s no# on o( a6so!u#e nd ((eren"e) #he (ormer does no# need #o pos # a (an#as$ o( or , na! hea!#h 6e"ause # "an e/p!a n e.er$#h n, #hrou,h #he res#!essness o( ne,a# . #$ wh "h has #he

13

po#en# a! #o produ"e some#h n, rredu" 6!$ d ((eren# and opera# .e!$ new5 The dea o( na#ure or su6s#an"e as a harmon ous "rund, a #ran7u ! os" !!a# on o( (or"es "au,h# w #h n a 6! nd ne"ess #$, s a (an#as$) #he 6e, nn n, s no# a so! d, ner# dens #$, 6u# a see#h n, mass o( he#ero,eneous ma##er !a"' n, s$mme#r$5 I( #he human su69e"# s n some manner an rre.o"a6!e 6!o"'a,e n #he . #a! (o!d o( 6e n,, # mus# represen# an amp! ( "a# on o( an a!read$ e/ s# n, po#en# a! #$ n na#ure5 ?e "an see #h s n .ar ous (orms E de(ormed an ma!s, de,enera# .e d seases, . ruses, na#ura! d sas#ers, a!! o( wh "h po n# #o wa$s n wh "h #he or , nar$ *harmon$3 o( #he wor!d s pred "a#ed upon d sorder, erup# .e d sarra$, #he na6 ! #$ #o sus#a n #se!( n per(e"# s$mme#r$5 +owe.er, #h s !a"' s no# a de(e"#) # s #he mo#or o( d a!e"# "a! "han,e, nuan"eI # s produ"# .e5 +ere, one mus# #h n' o( #he (undamen#a! presuppos # on o( S"he!! n, an ph !osoph$) *?ere #he ( rs# na#ure n harmon$ w #h #se!(, # wou!d rema n so5 I# wou!d 6e "ons#an#!$ Hne and wou!d ne.er 6e"ome Two5 I# wou!d 6e an e#erna! r , d #$ w #hou# pro,ress3 0S"he!! n, 2444a) 21915 % &e' #hus re"on"ep#ua! 8es and mod ( es S"he!! n,-s des"r p# ons o( #he Jas# as #ha# e!us .e ; #ha# (ore.er haun#s and pre"edes "ons" ousness 6$ mod ($ n, #s !o, "a! "ore5 Th s has n#eres# n, mp! "a# ons5 A rs#, we mus# remem6er #ha# a# #he !e.e! o( !o, " S"he!! n,-s m$#hopoe# " narra# .e o( #he Jas# does no# pr mord a!!$ presen# a chronology o( #he A6so!u#e5 The *s#a,es3 S"he!! n, re(ers #o are !o, "a! and or,an 8ed a""ord n, #o pr or #$5 Conse7uen#!$, #here s no sense n wh "h #he 9o$ous no#h n,ness #empora!!$ precedes #he su69e"# "au,h# n #he se!(-!a"era# n, ra,e o( ma##er5 Ge#, nso(ar as (reedom exists, #he a6$ss o( (reedom as pure po#en# a! #$ E a (reedom wh "h s no# $e# pos #ed E must 6e sa d #o !o, "a!!$ pre"ede #he ro#a# on o( dr .es #ha# "ons# #u#es ma#er a! 6e n,5 % &e' (o!!ows #he ar,umen# #hus (ar, 6u# #hen ma'es a "ru" a! mod ( "a# on5 Inso(ar as #he #h rd e!emen# E #he /ntscheidung E demons#ra#es no# ona! se!(-re(!e/ . #$, # re#roa"# .e!$ institutes itself a# #he 6e, nn n, o( #he en# re pro"ess #hrou,h #he parado/ "a! "ausa! #$ o( Areud an %achtr0glichkeit1=a"an an apr2s&coup5 Areedom s no# n d re"# "on#a"# w #h #he .nground as #ha# wh "h neu#ra!!$ ,rounds #he "on(! "# o( #he po!ar pr n" p!es, nor s # a resur,en"e o( #he pr mord a! A6$ss o( Areedom now n a h ,her e/ponen#) # presen#s #he s#ru"#ure o( a ne,a# on o( a ne,a# on, # s #he se"ond usurp n, #he pos # on o( #he ( rs# and #hus ns# #u# n, a mere (orma! re"on( ,ura# on o( #he s#ru"#ure o( #he who!e5 % &e'-s read n, #r es #o (ore"!ose #he poss 6 ! #$ o( a #heosoph " 7uar#ern #$ (rom w #h n S"he!! n,-s #e/# and #here6$ re#r e.e a #e/#ua! poss 6 ! #$ #ha# we ha.e !ar,e!$ !os# . ew o( due #o #he *re,ress .e3 #enden" es w #h n #he !a#e S"he!! n,-s #h n' n,, a poss 6 ! #$ #ha# es#a6! shes S"he!! n, as #he summ # o( #he "rundlogik o( 2erman Idea! sm 6$ show n, how # s h s on#o!o,$, and no# +e,e!-s, wh "h mus# ade7ua#e!$ "ome #o #erms w #h #he rad "a! n"omp!e# on o( rea! #$ h n#ed a# n <an# an unru! ness, #hrou,h #he e/press on o( #he !o, " o( #he no#-a!!5 There s, #here(ore, a""ord n, #o % &e', a #ru#h h dden n S"he!! n,-s des"r p# on o( #he passa,e (rom 9o$ous no#h n,ness #o #he a!!-"onsum n, ra,e o( #he un(ree su69e"#5 Inso(ar as #here s no separa# on 6e#ween su6s#an"e and su69e"#, #he des"r p# on o( #he 9o$ous no#h n,ness o( non-

14

e/per en"e and #he n( n #e ne,a# . #$ o( Todestrieb are, n essen"e, #wo s des o( #he same "o n5 The passa,e (rom one #o #he o#her s on!$ a !o, "a! "on.ers on5// The u!# ma#e parado/ o( #he sh (# (rom #he 9o$ous no#h n,ness o( e#ern #$ 0wh "h S"he!! n, re(ers #o n #he 'reiheitsschrift as #he .ngrund, #he Qn,rounded// 1 #o #he Triebe o( #he "rund, wh "h ser.es as #he s#epp n, s#one #o (u!!(!ed,ed (reedom, (reedom as #he pred "a#e o( a su69e"#, s #ha# there is no mo!ement at all ( "rund is always&already the .ngrund3 the )closed* circle of nature is always already the scene of 4possible full emergence of5 freedom5// The .ngrund s no# a (our#h pr n" p!e wh "h e/ s#s pr or #o "rund and e/ s#en"e as #ha# wh "h un ( es #hem #o,e#her as mu#ua! pa rs, 6u# #he rad "a! se!(re!a# n, ne,a# . #$ a# #he hear# o( #he human su69e"#, wh "h now, ns#ead o( 6e n, a s n,!e par# n #he #o#a! #$ o( ma#er a! 6e n,, pos #s #se!( as an ndependen# "en#re #ha# he,emon "a!!$ dom na#es #he who!e #o wh "h # 6e!on,ed5 The ! 6 d na! (ren8$ o( #he unru! ness o( human na#ure does no# mere!$ represen# a s n,!e "ase o( #he d seased 6rea'down o( #he on#o!o, "a!, 6u#, ra#her, #he na6 ! #$ o( su6s#an"e #o pos # #se!( as a!!5 The *,round (a !s #o ,round3 0Johns#on 2444) 9215 Na#ure was a!wa$s-a!read$ a s "'!$ "rea#ure, whose "o!!apse "o n" des w #h her "ond # ons o( 0 m1poss 6 ! #$5 I# s no# on!$ #ha# na#ure ne.er 'new a momen# o( e#erna! happ ness and 9o$, 6u# #ha# #he du!!, nar# "u!a#e pressure o( her own ,asp n, (or 6rea#h 0sp r #, we remem6er, "omes (rom #he =a# n spritus, *6rea#h,3 and s re!a#ed #o spirare, *#o 6rea#he31 pre"edes #he .er$ pos # . #$ o( her 6e n,5 Su6s#an"e "an on!$ be su6s#an"e E na#ure "an on!$ be na#ure E nso(ar as # s already n#erna!!$ #orn apar# 6$ a "ons# #u# .e momen# o( au#o!a"era# on #ha# s #he s #e o( sp r #Lsu69e"#5 Th s s wh$ #he passa,e s mere!$ a *!o, "a! "on.ers on3 E # mere!$ re7u res a "er#a n ,es#ure, an open n,, #o 6e 6rou,h# #o a new power, wh !e no#h n, "han,es a# #he !e.e! o( pos # .e 6e n,5 +ere we "!ear!$ see #he +e,e! an !o, " #ha# % &e' super mposes o.erLe/#ra"#s (rom S"he!! n, n #he 2nd dra(#) # s #he (a !ure o( #he ( rs# momen# 0#he se!(-pos # n, o( su6s#an"e1 wh "h !eads #o #he se"ond 0#he unru! ness o( human na#ure, #he un6eara6!e ns# n"#ua! shor# " r"u # o( Triebe1, and #he (a !ure o( #he se"ond !eads #o #he #h rd 0#he se!(-pos # n, o( #h s rup#ure n #he (o!d o( 6e n,, #s nser# n, #se!( n#o #he ( rs# pos # on15 The essen"e o( #he #h rd momen# s, #here(ore, #he ne,a# on o( #he pre. ous #wo, wh "h , .es # a no# ona! se!(-re!a# ona! #$5 Con"!us on ?ha# shou!d 6e "!ear a# #h s 9un"#ure s #he am6 ,uous na#ure o( #he S"he!! n,-+e,e! re!a# onsh p w #h n % &e'-s read n, o( 2erman Idea! sm5 S#ar# n, (rom h s "!a m #ha# #he (undamen#a! 6rea'#hrou,h announ"ed 6$ <an# an ph !osoph$ s #s acomism, #he rad "a! incompletion o( rea! #$ hera!ded 6$ #he dead!o"' o( (reedom, % &e' # me and # me a,a n asser#s #ha# # was Hegel who mos# rad "a!!$ 6rou,h# #h s #ru#h n#o "on"ep#ua! (u!!ness5 In #he wa'e o( #he "r # "a! s$s#em, +e,e! was a6!e #o supersede do,ma# " me#aph$s "s 6$ ma' n, an ep s#emo!o, "a! o6s#a"!e, *we "anno#

15

'now #he "osmos,3 n#o a pos # .e on#o!o, "a! "ond # on, *#here s no "osmos* 6$ ns"r 6 n, #he #rans"enden#a! su69e"# within #he (a6r " o( 6e n,5// . Ge#, wha# s o(#en m ss n, n h s own des"r p# ons o( #h s ma#er a! "on# n,en"$ mp! ed n wha# % &e' per"e .es #he "rundlogik o( 2erman Idea! sm s #he rremo.a6!e ro!e #ha# S"he!! n, p!a$s n h s own n#erpre#a# on o( #he "on"ep#ua! "ons#e!!a# on o( pos#-<an# an ph !osoph$5 I# s on!$ #hrou,h h s *rea"#ua! 8a# on3 o( S"he!! n, #hrou,h #he unpa"' n, o( a !a#en# +e,e! an !o, " #ha# ena6!es % &e' #o ar# "u!a#e #h s me#aph$s "s o( a *no#a!!,3 a d a!e"# "s o( non-re"on" !a# on, (rom #he 2erman Idea! s# #rad # on5 Ta' n, <an#-s des"r p# ons o( (reedom as a6so!u#e, 6o#h +e,e! and #he !a#e S"he!! n,, n #he r own wa$, #r$ #o de.e!op a #heor$ o( su6s#an"e as su69e"#, #o e/p!a n how #he ,ap #ha# separa#es us (rom #he "!osed "ausa! s$s#em o( na#ure "ou!d emer,e, 6u# ne #her on #he r own are su(( " en#5 ?h !e #he ma#ure +e,e! an !o, " 6a"'s awa$ (rom #he d a!e"# "a! mp! "a# ons o( #he rad "a! on#o!o,$ o( (reedom announ"ed 6$ #he #rans"enden#a! su69e"# a!read$ par# a!!$ de.e!oped n #s ear! er "on"ep# o( #he n ,h# o( #he wor!d, #he !a#e S"he!! n,, ha. n, (u!!$ ar# "u!a#ed #he !a"era# n, au#od srup# on o( su6s#an"e, n #he end sh es awa$ (rom #he horror o( se!(-re!a# n, ne,a# . #$ 6$ ha. n, re"ourse #o .ngrund5 The #rue "u!m na# on o( #he "rundlogik o( 2erman Idea! sm, as % &e' ar# "u!a#es and a##emp#s #o de.e!op # (ur#her n h s own para!!a/ on#o!o,$, "an on!$ 6e a h$6r d sm o( S"he!! n, an on#o!o,$ and +e,e! an !o, "5

16

To an$one (am ! ar w #h pos#-<an# an 2erman Idea! sm, #he separa# on 6e#ween on#o!o,$ and !o, " #ha# I am here ma' n, w !! w #hou# dou6# appear du6 ous nso(ar as 6o#h are n#r "a#e!$ n#er#w ned w #h n #he #rad # on) Isn-# +e,e! an !o, " n some sense an on#o!o,$, and sn-# S"he!! n,-s "on"ep# o( #he me#aph$s "a! ,round o( rea! #$ a!so a !o, ": Moesn-# +e,e! ha.e su"h s#ar' "r # " sms o( (orma! sm: I mus# po n# ou# #ha# #h s s a mere!$ (un"# ona! d s# n"# on used n order draw ou# "er#a n "on# nu n, d (( "u!# es and unear#hed #e/#ua! poss 6 ! # es n 6o#h S"he!! n,-s and +e,e!-s #hou,h# #ha# % &e' draws upon and a##emp#s #o 6r n, (or#h5 H( "ourse, (or % &e', +e,e!-s !o, " s re.e!a#or$ o( #he hear# o( rea! #$ and S"he!! n,-s on#o!o,$ as he der .es # has a .er$ spe" ( " 0+e,e! an1 !o, "5 ?ha# w !! 6e"ome "!ear #hrou,hou# s wh$ I propose su"h a d s# n"# on) a""ord n, #o % &e', +e,e!-s ma#ure on#o!o,$ s n"ons s#en# w #h #s own d a!e"# "a! presuppos # ons, whereas S"he!! n,-s !o, " s a #urn n, awa$ (rom #he d a!e"# "a! rad "a!ness h s on#o!o, "a! a""oun# o( #he ,enes s o( #he su69e"#, and # s on!$ #hrou,h #he h$6r d sm o( #he a"h e.emen#s o( #he #wo #ha# % &e' mp! " #!$ "!a ms we "an arr .e a# #he h dden "rund4onto&5logik o( #he 2erman Idea! s# #rad # on5 ii Th s "ou!d 6e (ur#her e/p! "a#ed 6$ supp!emen# n, # w #h a num6er o( poss 6!e " #a# ons (rom Religion within the 6imits of Reason ,lone5 Aor e/amp!e, <an# 19>4) F45 iii S"he!! n, sa$s n h s 'reiheitschrift #ha# # s n dea! sm #ha# *we ha.e #o #han' (or #he ( rs# per(e"# "on"ep# o( (reedom3 0S"he!! n, 244F) 2F11 and s #ua#es #he #rue <an# an 6rea'#hrou,h n #he 7ritique of Practical Reason 0 6 d5 2F215 The same app! es #o % &e') *No wonder <an# s the ph !osopher o( (reedom) w #h h m, #he dead!o"' o( (reedom emer,es3 0% &e' 24496) 9D15 . S"he!! n, 2441) 2F25
i

. +e,e! 1977) 1DF N 1>85 . S"he!! n, 244F) 2F45 . % &e' 2444) FF5 . % &e' 2444) Chap#er 2, *The +e,e! an T "'! sh Su69e"#,3 se"# on*F, D, 5,3 n 79-8>5 / O 8e' 2444) 825
x The en# re#$ o( #he para!!a/ !o, " #ha# % &e' s a##emp# n, #o de.e!op as #he 6as s (or #he

reha6 ! #a# on o( d a!e"# "a! ma#er a! sm s, n e((e"#, an a##emp# #o 6r n, n#o "on"ep#ua! (u!!ness S"he!! n,-s !o, " o( #he "rund+ Aor a des"r p# on o( #he na#ure o( #h s !o, " as ena6! n, (reedom #hrou,h on#o!o, "a! dependen"e see S"he!! n, 244F) 2275 / S"he!! n, 2444a) 2175 / S"he!! n, 244F) 2F95
xiii Johns#on 2444) Chap#er 7, *Su6s#an"e A,a ns# I#se!() The M s#ur6 n, Ror#e/ o( Trieb+33 p5 84-925 xiv % &e' #a!'s o( Ja"7ues-A!a n M !!er-s remar's on unse##! n, ra# e/per men#s men# oned n one o(

=a"an-s unpu6! shed sem nars, where # s on!$ #hrou,h a ' nd o( neuro!o, "a! mu# !a# on #ha# a ra# "an 6e made #o 6eha.e ! 'e a human5 See % &e' 2447) 219-2245 /. % &e' 2447) 2D
xvi % &e' e.en ,oes so (ar as #o "ompare #h s "aus# " "o!!apse o( #he on#o!o, "a! #o #he a#ro" #$ o(

se/ua! a6use and #he horr ( " p "#ures o( "h !dren d$ n, (rom rad a# on e/posure n Cherno6$!5 See % &e' 24496) 7F5 xvii% &e' a!so de.e!ops #h s dea o( #he 6 r#h o( #he S$m6o! " as a need #o ,en#r ( "a# on o( #he Rea! #hrou,h h s read n, o( S"he!! n,) % &e' 2444) D>-D7 N % &e' 2448) F7-D>5 /. % &e' 2447) F5-F95
xix Ins#ead o( ou#! n n, #he n#erna! d ((eren"es #ha# o""ur w #h n #he #hree e/ s#en# dra(#s o( #he

#eltalter n #erms o( #he mo.emen# (rom Jas# #o Jresen#3 I w !! dea! w #h % &e'-s own e/e,es s wh "h "en#res on #he 2nd dra(#5 A "omp!e#e e/p! "a# on o( #he #hree dra(#s s ou#s de #he s"ope o( #h s ar# "!e5 // % &e' 2447) 225 // % &e' 2444) 2F5 // S"he!! n, 244F) 27>-2775 // Johns#on 2444) 925

// .% &e' 2444) 59->25

'or&s (ited
+e,e!, 25 ?5 A5 1977a5 The 8ifference 9etween 'ichte:s and Schelling:s System of Philosophy5 Trans5 +5 S5 +arr s N ?a!#er Cer(5 A!6an$) SQNG Jress, SSS5 197765 Phenomenology of Spirit5 Trans5 A5 R5 M !!er5 =ondon) H/(ord Qn .ers #$ Jress, 19775 SSS5 19955 6ectures on the History of Philosophy+ Trans5 @$ E5 S5 +a!dane N Aran"es +5 S mson5 Ro!5 F5 =ondon) Qn .ers #$ o( Ne6ras'a Jress5 Johns#on, Adr an5 24445 ;i<ek:s =ntology> , Transcendental ?aterialistic Theory of Subjecti!ity5 E.ans#on) Nor#hwes#ern Qn .ers #$ Jress, 24445 <an#, Immanue!5 19445 @ant on /ducation5 Trans5 Anne##e Chur#on5 @os#on) M5 C5 +ea#h N Co, 19445 SSS5 19>45 Religion within the 6imits of Reason ,lone5 Trans5 T5M5 2reene N +5+5 +udson5 New Gor') +arper N Row5 S"he!! n,, A5 ?5 R5 2444a5 The ,ges of the #orld> Third Version 4c+ ABAC55 Trans5 Jason M5 ? r#h5 A!6an$) SQNG Jress5 SSS5 24415 System of Transcendental dealism5 Trans5 Je#er +ea#h5 Char!o##es. !!e) Qn .ers #$ Jress o( R r, n a5 SSS5 244F5 TJh !osoph "a! In.es# ,a# ons n#o #he Essen"e o( +uman Areedom5T Trans5 Jr s" !!a +a$den-Ro$5 Philosophy of "erman dealism5 Ed5 Erns# @eh!er5 New Gor') Con# nuum5 217-28D5 % &e', S!a.o95 24445 The Ticklish Subject> The ,bsent 7entre of Political deology+ New Gor') Rerso5 SSS5 24475 The ndi!isible Remainder> =n Schelling and Related ?atters5 New Gor') Rerso5 SSS5 24485 *The A6$ss o( Areedom53 In The ,byss of 'reedom1The ,ges of the #orld5 Ann Ar6or) The MIT Jress5 SSS5 2449a5 *A "h#e-s =au,h#er53 In ?ythology3 ?adness and 6aughter> Subjecti!ity in "erman dealism5 New Gor') Con# nuum5 SSS5 244965 The Parallax View5 Cam6r d,e) The MIT Jress5 % &e', S!a.o9 N 2!$n Ma!$5 244D5 7on!ersations with ;i<ek+ Cam6r d,e) Jo! #$5