Val KFC
Val KFC
Val KFC
S0294008
S0063015
First page no
number
Contents
The Final Report of Service Marketing .............................................................................................. 1
Subject: Service in KFC, Chuanghua .................................................................................................. 1
Contents ............................................................................................................................................ 2
Company Introduction ...................................................................................................................... 3
History: ...................................................................................................................................... 3
4p: ............................................................................................................................................. 3
Product: ..................................................................................................................................... 3
Price: ......................................................................................................................................... 4
Promotion: ................................................................................................................................ 4
Place: ......................................................................................................................................... 4
Motivation ......................................................................................................................................... 5
Method ............................................................................................................................................. 5
Questionnaire ........................................................................................................................... 5
Statistical Analysis ............................................................................................................. 5
Mystery Shopping ................................................................................................................... 12
Our observation ...................................................................................................................... 14
Conclusion ....................................................................................................................................... 16
Service Blueprint ............................................................................................................................. 16
Standards and Failure Points .................................................................................................. 22
Possible Ways to Redesign the Service ................................................................................... 22
Based on The Blueprint ................................................................................................... 22
Based on Our Observation .............................................................................................. 24
Limitations....................................................................................................................................... 24
References....................................................................................................................................... 25
Appendix ......................................................................................................................................... 26
Questionnaire.................................................................................................................................. 26
The Original One ..................................................................................................................... 26
Redesigned Version ................................................................................................................. 28
Standardization Handbookselected ................................................................................... 29
Company Introduction
History:
Kentucky Fried Chicken (KFC) is a fast food restaurant which founded in 1930 North
Corbin, Kentucky, United States, is a subsidiary of Yum! Brands Inc.
The company specializes in fried chicken, and expanded its menu to offer other products
such as burgers and French fries, as well as desserts and soft drinks.
KFC was one of the first fast food chains to expand internationally, and in 1987 became
the first Western restaurant chain to open in China, and the country is now the company's
most profitable market.
Taiwans first KFC outlet was opened in 1985. It was initially a joint venture between KFC
and Uni-President Enterprises Corporation, until Jardine Matheson replaced
Uni-President because of the poorly performing in 2010.
4p:
Compare KFC in Taiwan and the mainland basic on 4p:
product
China
Taiwan
Localization,
product diversification
combinative diversification
price
cheaper
More expensive
Promotion
micro-film
power of celebrity
Business cooperation
Bed public image
Innovative slogans
Gimmick
Good public image
Place
Some city
Product:
In addition to basic meals, China and Taiwan all provide special product.
China:
The products are more tend to Chinese traditional flavor, like gruel, soup and rice meals;
the taste is more salty and spicy; local drinks like soy milk are provided; they even have
pearl milk tea.
KFC really implement the globalization strategic in China.
Localization surely
China has large population, and many of they follow the traditional, so the products are
more diverse and localized.
Also, China is very wide, so the delivery server only receives in some areas.
3
Taiwan:
There has Chinese meal like gruel, but most products are innovated basic on Western
food like sandwich, Roast chicken and so on, It also launch different flavors egg tart and
special meal regularly and gradually increase roasted food for the increasing awareness
in health.
The different combinations of combo() are more than China.
This may because that most Taiwanese prefer western flavor, and are more fickle(
).
Price:
Because of our limitations we could not make a comparison in prices between that in
Taiwan and Mainland China. And these are some of the possible reasons.
1. The prices of ingredients in different areas are different. For example, vegetables
are more accessible in Mainland China than in Taiwan.
2. People in different regions have various purchasing ability. That might depend on
their average income level and their perception of how much they are willing to pay
to eat KFC.
Promotion:
Same:
1. Tend to use infamous young actors in their TV advertisement, for attracting young
customers.
2. All provide coupon on the official website.
3. Have promotional period
4. Launch the iOS APP for delivery ordering
One thing we want to emphasize is that although the overall promotion strategies are
similar in Mainland China and Taiwan, they are carried out in different ways based on the
certain cultural background.
Place:
China:
Distributed in 450 cities in China
Taiwan:
In every cities in the island of Taiwan
4
Motivation
Creating blueprint
etc. all part of the
objectives
Method
Questionnaire
We made this questionnaire according to the internet in the midterm project. But we refine
Ok
it based on the information offered in our text book.(Service Marketing Valarie A. Zeithaml,
Mary Jo Betner & Dwayne D. Gremler, 6th edition) And we also referred to The Service
Encounter: Diagnosing Favorable and Unfavorable Incidents written by Mary Jo Bitner, Bernard
H. Booms, & Mary Stanfield Tetreault.
And we collected 50 valid questionnaires. Could say more about where from.
Statistical Analysis
1. Demographic Variables
1.1 Gender
We have got 36 valid questionnaires from mainland China. And there were 7 males
and 29 females. While in Taiwan we have received 50 questionnaires, 22 of which
were done by males and the others were by females.
1.2 Age
Region
Age
Under 20
21~30
31~40
Mainland
China
32
Taiwan
38
In Total
41
41
45
Numer of Interviewees
40
35
30
25
Under 20
20
21~30
15
31~40
10
5
0
Mainland China
Taiwan
In Total
Region
Mainland China
Student
29(80.6%)
Industry
Business
You need to be
more analytical
Taiwan
rather than
just
describing the data
40(80%)
i.e., what should
I
know or
5(10%)
understand from
1(2%)
these numbers?0
Service Industry
4(11.1%)
Military or Education
1(2.8%)
3(2%)
IT
1(2.8%)
Other
1(2.8%)
1(2%)
1.4Frequency
Percentage
70
60
50
40
Mainland
China
30
Taiwan
20
10
0
KFC
McDonald's MOSS/DISCO
Subway
Other
Aspects
Region
Mainland China
Taiwan
63.9
68
reasonable price
25
sales promotion
2.8
12
attitude
2.8
10
convenience
5.6
In this part we coul draw a conclusion that people think higly of the ood quality in both
areas, the percentge of which excesses to 60 per cent. People in Mainland China think
highly of reasonable price(25% interviewees chose it) while people in Taiwan think sales
promotion is another significant aspect besides food quality (12% people chose it).
Sales promotion and attitude are the last things come into peoples mind in Mainland
China. But in Taiwan people do not think too much of convenience.
standards we listed. We trasfer the data into a line chart in order to make the comparison.
The standards are: 1. Qverwrap 2. Quantity of food 3. Food types4. Package
5. Attitude6. Advertisement 7. Sales promotion 8. Price
9. Eating enviornment 10. Speed of preparing foods.
4.5
Average Scores
4
3.5
3
2.5
Mainland China
Start the
numbering at say 2
with greater
intervals to make
your data say
more.
2
1.5
1
0.5
Taiwan
0
1
10
Different Standards
Mainland
China
Taiwan
1. Which one to
have a party
2. Using
Internet
ordered
food
3. Score todays
eating
experience
Valid
34
35
35
Invalid
Choice
KFC
NO
3.84
Valid
35
34
33
Invalid
15
16
17
Choice
McDonalds
NO
3.81
In Part 3 we asked the interviewees three questions. And each qusestion was made up
by a closed question and an open one. First question is Which one do you prefer to
have a party in? KFC or McDonalds? And why? . The second question is Have you
ever ordered KFC foods via the Internet or phone calls? If yes, how was their service? If
not, then why? And the third question is Score KFCs performance according to your
experience in KFC today (from 1 to 5) please. If there is something you could think about
that KFC can improve (any aspect)?
As it can be seen from the table, many interviewees missed to answer these three
question. Hence, we get our result from those valid questionnaires.
In Mainland China, interviewees reported that they would like to have parties in KFC
while in Taiwan people prefer McDonalds. Almost no people interviewed have any
Internet ordering experience. And as the well-know Chinese way, people scored their
instant experience around 3.
3.2 PZB Model Analysis
3.2.1 Basic Data Analysis
Both
Taiwan
McDonald's
Mainland China
KFC
10
15
20
25
30
Atmosphere
10
8
cheap
service
6
4
2
KFC
0
sales promotion
McDonald's
personal
preference
dilicious
Figure7Reasons that choose the certain restaurant to have parties in Mainland China
personal
preference
3
2
1
KFC
0
various types
dilicious
cheap
McDonald's
sales promotion
10
From the charts above, it seems that KFC in Mainland China wins a better reputation
than in Taiwan since most interviewees in Mainland China reported prefer KFC to have
parties while in Taiwan people like McDonalds more.
In spite of that, the standards people hold to choose a party place are different slightly in
two regions. In Mainland China, people think the flavor of the foods, atmosphere and
personal preference are important. But in Taiwan, people also think highly of the distance
between home and the restaurant and the price.
What is more, McDonalds beats KFC in the dimensions of distance, food flavor price
undoubtedly. And it suggests that KFC have to take some action in these aspects at least.
3.2.2
PZB Model
It is useful using the Gaps Model to assess KFCs service strategy. But because of our
limitations, we could not contact the manager of KFC currently. As a result, we could only
focus on Gap 2 (the service design and standard gap) and Gap 5 (customer gap).
Gap 2: the Service Design and Standards Gap
This gap is about poor service design, absence of customer-driven standards and
inappropriate evidence and servicescape. And it can be assessed by the following audit:
1= poor
10= excellent
Systematic Service Design
Final Project
How well are new service defined for customers and employees?
Final Project
quality goals?
Appropriate Physical Evidence and Servicescape
11
7
4
We have searched for the standards made by KFC. And this is what we found:
C Cleanliness
H Hospitality
A Accuracy
Maintenance
P
quality
Product
S Speed
To sum up all the information we have, including information we got from the
questionnaires. We could find that KFCs standards meet customers needs. But KFC has
not got an ideal score neither in Mainland China nor Taiwan. Thus, we claim that there is
something wrong when putting standards into actions.
In conclusion, gap 2 is somehow existing.
Gap 5: Customer Gap
We can judge this gap using these two statements:
How well does the company understand customer expectation of service quality?
How well does the company understand customer perception of service?
According to the standards made by KFC we infer that KFC understand customers
exception well. But thinking of the moderate scores given by customers, we think they fail
to understand customers perception of service so that they do not do the exact
improvement.
To conclude, gap 5 exists as well.
Mystery Shopping
We have been to the KFC in Chuanghua twice. The first time was for the midterm
research and the other was for the final project.
We intended to experience as customers in order to get the most direct and first-hand
information. And that will help us to figure out the exact problems existing in Chuanghua
KFC.
12
Service Cycle
Ordered
my meal
Finish
the meal
My meal was
out of stock,so I
had to wait for a
while. :(
They soon
cleaned it
up. :)
I called a
waiter for
help.
After finding
the seat, I
suddenly drop
my drink. :(
For
compensated,
they give me a
little cup of
cola. :)
About ten
minutes later,
my order
finally
come. :[
13
They promised
me that they
would
immediately
make it.
I still felt
impatient and
disappoint
especially when
other customers
got their meal. :(
Our observation
We made a assessment table according to the research on Service Quality Dimensions in
Add reference here
Chinese Culture and observed these dimensions in these three areas. Here are the
- good idea.
results.
location
Taipei
Changhua
China
position
Next to McDonald's
Across
McDonalds
Product(sa
me)
Bigger
Fresh
Smaller
Fresh
Normal
Fresh
environment
Clean
Bigger
Lighter
Well Decorating
Clean
Smaller
Monotonous( )
Decorating
Clean
Big
Light
Poor Decorating
Noisy
Crowded
Prompt
faster
slower
faster
Sincere
Not all
sincere
waiters
from
are
Next to McDonald's
facilities
Clean
Nice maintenance
Clean bathroom but
without disabled toilets.
Clean
Washroom is a little
dirty
and
without
disabled toilets.
Professional
ism
Understanding
the Understanding
product
product
Willing to give more
information (Not actively
provide
sauces
for
environmentally friendly)
the
Comfortable
ness
Accomplish
Chin-chieh
Accomplish
14
Accomplish
Not all waiters
Chin-chieh
are
Active
service
introduce
actively
Respect
Very politely
Very politely
Crisis
handling
1.
1. A customer before
me dropped the drink
at second floor; they
cleaned it up
immediately, and
provide her a new one.
added other
dimensions, too.
the
meals
introduce the
actively
Provide
alternatives
meals
the
Good detail
3.1Analysis:
Satisfying part:
1. Fresh food
2. Dining environment and facilities are clean
3. All waiters know their products well and react politely
Good summary
4. Make customers feel comfortable
5. Active service
6. Having a certain capacity of Crisis handling
Dissatisfying part:
1. Products sizes are very different
2. Some waiters attitude and speed
3. The Cleanliness of washroom
4. Doesnt have disability toilet
--We can tell that neither product nor service of KFC keep in the same quality level.
15
Conclusion
From what we have got we draw a conclusion that Chuanghua KFCs service quality falls
behind those in Taipei and Jinan. Thus in the final project we are going to find out the
exact failure points in service aspect in Chuanghua KFC.
Ok
Service Blueprint
A service blueprint is a picture or map that portrays the customer experience and the
service system, so that the different people involved in providing the service can
understand it objectively, regardless of their roles or their individual points of
view.(Service Marketing, 6th edition,). According to the definition of service blueprint, we
Normally names
take use of the feature of blueprint as the method to point out the failure points in
and date
Chuanghua KFC.
And the ordering process was:
1.
Welcome customers
2. Order the meal
3. Provide advice
4. Repeat the ordering
5. Complete the meal
6. Check the meal
7. Deliver the meal
8. Blessing customers have a wonderful meal
We drew the service blueprint according to our own experience.(SEE the basic one
in P17, and see a more detailed one in P18~21).
16
Could add
standards up here.
These seem to be
your boxes (white
ones).
17
18
19
As standards,
though, what do
these mean?
20
What is the
standard?
e.g., in McDonalds
cleaning is
continious
21
Our Observations
Failure Points
The process of
cleaning.(Daily routine)
Responsiveness(Willingness
to help customers)
it immediately
without question =
a standard.
Service delivery
And according to this, we pick the deficiencies in human resource policies as the
most obvious failure point. And we have out some possible solutions to refine the
system.
23
In this kind of
report keep it more
specific to the
issues that you are
dealing with.
Limitations
1. We can only requested friends in China help us doing the research, so it may
lacks some realism.
2. Because of the difference in standard, social affect and other factors, the
answers on the questionnaire written by Taiwanese and Chinese cant really
compare, its hard for us to accurate judge the quality of service.
24
3. There were many foreigners in the restaurant but we didnt prepare the English
version, the data might be incomplete.
4. Although we have talked with one employee in KFC and got some useful
information, the more detailed information and standards are confidential and
we did not have access to it.
References
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
6TH EDITION
http://www.kfcclub.com.tw/News/Detail56.html
http://www.wretch.cc/blog/amena750804/36015343
http://www.managertoday.com.tw/?p=706
http://www.bnext.com.tw/article/view/id/6532
http://www.104.com.tw/jobbank/custjob/index.php?r=cust&j=383a4225385c3f6
852423c1d1d1d1d5f2443a363189j56&jobsource=cj2008
7. http://wiki.mbalib.com/wiki/%E8%82%AF%E5%BE%B7%E5%9F%BA%E5%85%AC
%E5%8F%B8
8. http://imc123.net/?p=1036
25
Appendix
Questionnaire
The Original One
Dear interviewees!
First of all, thank you for your time to fill this questionnaire about the service level of KFC.
Your cooperation is the key point to our research. There are no correct answers. Please
finish this questionnaire according to your personal point of view anonymously and your
answer will only be used to academic study and analyzing.
We really appreciate your help!
National Changhua University of Education
Department of Business Administration
Part 1. Basic Information
1. Gender male female
30 31
40 over 41
2. Age
under 20 21
3. Occupation
student industry business service industry military or education
Housewife IT freelance other __________
4. Living costs per month
6000 NT 6001
9000 NT
under 3000 NT 3001
12000 NT 12001
15000 NT over 15000
9001
5. Frequency of going to the fast food restaurants per month
15 times over 16 times
under 5times
6 10 times 11
6. The fast food restaurant you chose to go most frequently
KFC McDonalds MOSS Subway other_________
7. Your favorite fast food restaurant
KFC McDonalds MOSS Subway other_________
8. As a customer in a fast food restaurant which aspect do you think a lot of (only one
answer)
Quality of the food reasonable price sales promotion attitude
Convenience advertising other________
26
1 Very
bad
2 Bad
3
Average
4
Good
5 Very
good
Have you ever ordered KFC foods via the Internet or phone calls? If yes, how was
their service? If not, then why?
27
Redesigned Version
Dear interviewees!
First of all, thank you for your time to fill this questionnaire about the service level of KFC.
Your cooperation is the key point to our research. There are no correct answers. Please
finish this questionnaire according to your personal point of view anonymously and your
answer will only be used to academic study and analyzing.
We really appreciate your help!
National Changhua University of Education
Department of Business Administration
Part 1. Basic Information
4. Gender male female
30 31
40 over 41
5. Age
under 20 21
6. Occupation
student industry business service industry military or education
Housewife IT freelance other __________
4. Living costs per month
6000 NT 6001
9000 NT
under 3000 NT 3001
12000 NT 12001
15000 NT over 15000
9001
5. Frequency of going to the fast food restaurants per month
15 times over 16 times
under 5times
6 10 times 11
Part 2. Perception of Service
Please score the following statements according their importance in your judgments, and
1 is the least level while 7 accounts the most.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
28
1.
2.
3.
4.
selected
Standardization Handbook
Lobby
1.Preparations
1) Check for clean enough tools and locate them out of the customers sights, and
tools include (rags, press pound stick, broom, mop, mop buckets, glass cleaner, glass
blowing, trash bags, etc.)
2) Check the cleanness of toilets and doors;
3) Check whether the trash is full or not, and make sure there is no unpleasant smell;
4) Check that all devices are functioning and maintained excellently.
2. Routine
1 ) clean and wipe the tables , and arrange tables and chairs neatly ;
2 ) maintain floor clean , if it is spilled with drinks, clean it timely ;
3 ) make sure the rubbish in the dust bin is within a proper amount ;
29
4 ) when garbage bins holds up to its 2/3, pressure is required ,and when it is up to 3
/4, empty the bin and replace it using a new bags ;
5) timely check doors , windows and mirrors , and clean them if necessary ;
6 ) Once customers leave, clean the table immediately(start cleaning within 30s and
finish cleaning within 60s)
7 ) After cleaning , cleaning tools should be cleaned and returned to the specified
location ;
8 ) Once there is any questions ( customer complaints , equipment, etc. ) inside the
restaurant, the employees should immediately report it to the manager.
Caring for Customers
1) If the customer accidentally spills drinks, promptly notify the manager on duty ;
2) actively assist customers who need help;
3) when doing cleaning work, be careful not to influence the customer ;
4) when audio (air conditioning) is too large or too small, you should notify the
manager to adjust.
30
B
Are the ideas presented
clearly supported with
evidence and logical
argument?
Overall
impression (is it a
group
presentation
etc.?)
40%
30%
20%
10%
5%
5%
5%
5%
Page 1 of 1
D:\Teaching\NCUE\Service Management UG\admin\Presentations\Final\E AND J.docx