Geometric Form Measurements Roundness Straightness Cylindricity Flatness, Etc
Geometric Form Measurements Roundness Straightness Cylindricity Flatness, Etc
Geometric Form Measurements Roundness Straightness Cylindricity Flatness, Etc
Dimensional Metrology
Geometric relationships
Parallel, perpendicular, etc.
Concentric, runout, etc.
Controlled surface texture
Straightness Specification
COMPARATORS
Comparators are one form of linear measurement device which is quick and more
convenient for checking large number of identical dimensions. Comparators normally
will not show the actual dimensions of the work piece. They will be shown only the
deviation in size. i.e. During the measurement a comparator is able to give the deviation
of the dimension from the set dimension. This cannot be used as an absolute measuring
device but can only compare two dimensions. Comparators are designed in several
types to meet various conditions. Comparators of every type incorporate some kind of
magnifying device. The magnifying device magnifies how much dimension deviates,
plus or minus, from the standard size.
The comparators are classified according to the principles used for obtaining
magnification. The common types are:
1) Mechanical comparators
2) Electrical comparators
3) Optical comparators
4) Pneumatic comparators
MECHANICAL COMPARATORS
The method for magnifying the small stylus movement in all the mechanical
comparators is by means of levers, gear trains or combination of these. They are
available of different make and each has it's own characteristic. The various types of
mechanical comparators are dial indicator, rack and pinion, sigma comparator,
Johansson mikrokator.
1. Dial indicator
Experimental setup
The whole setup consists of
worktable, dial indicator and vertical post.
The dial indicator is fitted to vertical post by
on adjusting screw as shown in fig. The
vertical post is fitted on the work table; the
top surface of the worktable is finely
finished. The dial gauge can be adjusted
vertically and locked in position by a screw.
Procedure
Let us assume that the required height of the component is 32.5mm. Initially
this height is built up with slip gauges. The slip gauge blocks are placed under the stem
of the dial gauge. The pointer in the dial gauge is adjusted to zero. The slip gauges are
removed.
Now the component to be checked is introduced under the stem of the dial
gauge. If there is any deviation in the height of the component, it will be indicated
by the pointer.
Mechanism
The stem has rack teeth. A set of gears engage with the rack. The pointer is
connected to a small pinion. The small pinion is independently hinged. I.e. it is not
connected to the stern. The vertical movement of the stem is transmitted to the pointer
through a set of gears. A spring gives a constant downward pressure to the stem.
In this type of comparator, the linear movement of the plunger is specified by means of
read mechanism. The mechanism of this type is illustrated in fig. A spring-loaded
pointer is pivoted. Initially, the comparator is set with the help of a known dimension
eg. Set of slip gauges as
Advantages
It is usually robust, compact and easy to handle.
It has very simple mechanism and is cheaper when compared to other types.
Disadvantages
Accuracy of the comparator mainly depends on the accuracy of the rack and pinion
arrangement. Any slackness will reduce accuracy.
It has more moving parts and hence friction is more and accuracy is less.
The range of the instrument is limited since pointer is moving over a fixed scale.
Johansson Mikrokator :
Principle:
It works on the principle of a Button spring, spinning on a loop of string like in the
case of Childrens toys.
Construction:
When the plunger moves by a small distance in upward direction the bell crank
lever turns to the right hand side. This exerts a force on the twisted strip and it causes a change
in its length by making it further twist or untwist. Hence the pointer at the centre rotates by
some amount. Magnification up to 5000X can be obtained by this comparator
These are unaffected by variations due to external source of energy such air, electricity etc.
Disadvantages:
Range is limited as the pointer moves over a fixed scale.
Pointer scale system used can cause parallax error.
There are number of moving parts which create problems due to friction, and ultimately the
accuracy is less.The instrument may become sensitive to vibration due to high inertia.
Principle:
Construction:
The movement of the plunger is magnified by the mechanical system using a pivoted lever. From
the Figure the mechanical magnification = x2 / x1. High optical magnification is possible with a
small movement of the mirror. The important factor is that the mirror used is of front reflection
type only.
The back reflection type mirror will give two reflected images as shown in Figure, hence the
exact reflected image cannot be identified.
Advantages:
These Comparators are almost weightless and have less number of moving parts, due to
this there is less wear and hence lessfriction.70
Higher range even at high magnification is possible as the scale moves past the index.
The scale can be made to move past a datum line and without having any parallax
errors.
They are used to magnify parts of very small size and of complex configuration such as
intricate grooves, radii or steps.
Disadvantages:
They have their own built in illuminating device which tends to heat the instrument.
Projection type instruments occupy large space and they are expensive.
When the scale is projected on a screen, then it is essential to take the instrument to a
dark room in order to take the readings easily.
Sigma Comparator:
The plunger is attached to a bar which is supported between the bending plates at the
top and bottom portion as shown in Figure
The bar is restricted to move in the vertical direction. A knife edge is fixed to the bar.
The knife edge is attached to the sapphire plate which is attached to the moving block.
The knife edge extorts a force on the moving block through sapphire plate. Moving
block is attached to the fixed block with the help of crossed strips as shown in Figure
(b). When the force is applied on the moving block, it will give an angular deflection. A
Y-arm which is attached to the moving block transmits the rotary motion to the driving
drum of radius r. This deflects the pointer and then the reading is noted.
L = Length of y-arm
ELECTRICAL COMPARATOR:
1) Transducer
3) Amplifier
Transducer
An iron armature is provided in between two coils held by a lea spring at one end.
The other end is supported against a plunger. The two coils act as two arms of an A.C.
wheat stone bridge circuit.
Amplifier
The amplifier is nothing but a device which amplifies the give input signal
frequency into magnified output
Working principle
If the armature is centrally located between the coils, the inductance of both coils
will be equal but in opposite direction with the sign change. Due to this, the bridge circuit
of A.C. wheat stone bridge is balanced. Therefore, the meter will read zero value. But
practically, it is not possible. In real cases, the armature may be lifted up or lowered
down by the plunger during the measurement. This would upset the balance of the wheat
stone bridge circuit. Due to this effect, the change in current or potential will be induced
correspondingly. On that time, the meter will indicate some value as displacement. This
indicated value may be either for larger or smaller components. As this induced current is
too small, it should be suitably amplified before being displayed in the meter.
Checking of accuracy
To check the accuracy of a given specimen or work, first a standard specimen is placed
under the plunger. After this, the resistance of wheat stone bridge is adjusted so that the
scale reading shows zero. Then the specimen is removed. Now, the work is introduced
under the plunger. If height variation of work presents, it will move the plunger up or
down. The corresponding movement of the plunger is first amplified by the amplifier
then it is transmitted to the meter to show the variations. The least count of this electrical
comparator is 0.001mm (one micron).
ELECTRONIC COMPARATOR
Construction details
i. Transducer
ii. Oscillator
iii. Amplifier
iv. Demodulator
v. Meter
(i) Transducer
(ii) Oscillator
The oscillator which receives electrical signal from the transducer and raises the
amplitude of frequency wave by adding carrier frequency called as modulation.
(iii) Amplifier
(iv) Demodulator
Demodulator is nothing but a device which cuts off external carrier wave
frequency. i.e. It converts the modulated wave into original wave as electrical signal.
(v) Meter
This is nothing but a display device from which the output can be obtained as a
linear measurement.
Principle of operation
Two or more magnifications are provided in the same instrument to use various ranges.
SINE BAR
Sine bars are always used along with slip gauges as a device for the measurement
of angles very precisely. They are used to
2) Locate the work piece to a given angle with very high precision.
Generally, sine bars are made from high carbon, high chromium, and corrosion
resistant steel. These materials are highly hardened, ground and stabilized. In sine bars,
two cylinders of equal diameter are attached at lie ends with its axes are mutually parallel
to each other. They are also at equal distance from the upper surface of the sine bar
mostly the distance between the axes of two cylinders is 100mm, 200mm or
300mm. The working surfaces of the rollers are finished to 0.2m R value. The
cylindrical holes are provided to reduce the weight of the sine bar.
1) Before checking the unknown angle of the specimen, first the angle (0) of given
specimen is found approximately by bevel protractor.
BEVEL PROTRACTORS
2) Universal protractor
3) Optical protractor
Working principle
attached to the circular plate containing Vernier scale. The main scale is graduated in
degrees from 0 to 90 in both the directions. The adjustable can be made to rotate freely
about the center of the main scale and it can be locked at any position. For measuring
acute angle, a special attachment is provided. The base plate is made fiat for measuring
angles and can be moved throughout its length. The ends of the blade are beveled at
angles of 45 and 60. The main scale is graduated as one main scale division is 1 and
Vernier is graduated into 12 divisions on each side of zero. Therefore the least count is
calculated as
AUTO- COLLIMATOR
Basic principle
0. Then the parallel beam is deflected twice the angle and is brought to focus in the
same plane as the light source.
WORKING OF AUTO-COLLIMATOR:
1. Micrometer microscope.
3. Collimating lens.
lamp, rays of light diverging from the intersection point reach the objective lens via beam
splitter. From objective, the light rays are projected as a parallel rays to the reflector.
A flat reflector placed in front of the objective and exactly normal to the
optical axis reflects the parallel rays of light back along their original paths. They are then
brought to the target graticule and exactly coincide with its intersection. A portion of the
returned light passes through the beam splitter and is visible through the eyepiece. If the
reflector is tilted through a small angle, the reflected beam will be changed its path at
twice the angle. It can also be brought to target graticule but linearly displaced from the
actual target by the amount 2 x f. linear displacement of the graticule image in the plane
tilted angle of eyepiece is directly proportional to the reflector. This can be measured by
optical micrometer. The photoelectric auto- collimator is particularly suitable for
calibrating polygons, for checking angular indexing and for checking small linear
displacements.
APPLICATIONS OF AUTO-COLLIMATOR
ANGLE DEKKOR
another datum scale fixed across the center of screen. The reflected image of the
illuminated scale is received at right angle to the fixed scale as shown in fig. Thus the
changes in angular position of the reflector in two planes are indicated by changes in the
point of intersection of the two scales. One division on the scale is calibrated to read 1
minute.
An optical flat is a disc of stress-free glass, or quartz. One or both faces of the disc are ground,
lapped and polished to a degree of flatness not normally countered on an engineering surface. For
engineering purposes, the optical flat may be considered as a reference of flatness, and used as
such for comparing engineering surfaces. Optical flats vary in size from 25 mm diameter to about
300 mm diameter, the thickness being about 50 mm for the largest. In all cases, they are
relatively rigid and stress-free discs which, used and stored correctly, will retain their flatness and
therefore effectiveness almost indefinitely.
If an optical flat is laid (not wrung) on to a nominally flat reflecting surface, it will not form
an intimate contact, but will lie at some angle , as in Fig. 2.6, in which is greatly exaggerated.
A wedge-shaped air cushion may be formed between the surfaces.
Faculty of Mechanical Engineering Page 30
Unit II MEASURING INSTRUMENTS
Fig. Formation of interference fringes on a flat surface viewed under an optical flat in a
parallel beam of monochromatic light.
If this arrangement is now placed in the path of a parallel beam of monochromatic light, we
can consider S as the source of one wave of the incident beam. Ignoring any refractive effects
due to the light passing through media, glass, and air, of differing densities, it is seen that the
wave from S is partially reflected at a and partially transmitted across the air gap, to be
reflected at b, a point on the work surface. The two reflected components are collected and
recombined by the eye, having travelled paths whose lengths differ by an amount abc.
If abc = /2 where = wavelength of source, then the conditions for complete interference
have been satisfied, i.e. the ray from S has been split into two components, and recombined; also,
the path lengths of the components differ by an odd number (one) of half wavelengths.
If the surface is flat, then at right-angles to the plane of the paper it will be parallel to the
optical flat, and these conditions will be satisfied in a straight line across the surface. Thus a
straight dark line, or interference fringe, will be seen.
Further along the surface and due to angle , the ray leaving S will similarly split into two
components whose path lengths differ by an amount def.
If def=3 /2, the next odd number of half wavelengths, interference will again occur and a
similar fringe will be seen.
At an intermediate point, the path difference will be an even number of half wavelengths, the
two components will be in phase, and a light band will be seen at this point.
Thus, a surface will be crossed by a pattern of alternate light and dark bands, which will
be straight, for the case of a flat surface, as in Fig. 2.7. A deviation from straightness would be a
measure of the error in flatness of the surface in a plane parallel to the apex of the angle .
Referring again to Fig. 2.6, it is seen that if is small (which it must be),
a b = b c= /4 de=ef= 3 /4
The change in separation between the optical flat and the surface is the difference between ab
and de (or bc and ef).
de-ab = 3 /4 - /4 = /2
Thus the change in separation between the surface and the optical flat is equal to one half
wavelength between similar points on similar adjacent fringes.
Note that if is increased the fringes are brought closer together, and if is reduced, i.e. the
surfaces become more nearly parallel, the fringe spacing increases. The possible practical
variation in is very small, since if the surfaces are too closely together ('wrung' together), no air
gap exists, and no fringes are observable, and if is too large the fringes are so closely spaced as
to be indistinguishable, and an observable pattern is not maintained.
In practice, it is unlikely that contact between the optical flat and the work surface will occur
at one point only as in Fig. 2.6. It is probable that contact would be made at a number of points,
or along one or a number of lines. Fig. 2.8 shows the pattern which would be observed if the
work surface were spherically convex. Contact is made at the central high point, resulting in a
fringe pattern of concentric circles. If now each adjacent fringe represents a change in elevation
of the work surface relative to the optical flat of /2, then
2 x n=Total change in elevation from point of contact to the outermost fringe. where =
wavelength of light used.
It is clear that the pattern observed when the surface is spherically convex will also be
observed when the surface is spherically concave. To distinguish between these two conditions
if, when the surface is spherically convex, one edge of the optical flat is lightly pressed, it will
rock on a new high spot and the centre of the fringe pattern will move as shown in Fig. 2.9, and
the outer fringes move closer together.
Also, when the surface is spherically concave, the flat rests on a line passing around the
surface, and if the edge of the optical flat is lightly pressed, the edge line does not move as the
pressure is varied. Alternatively, light pressure at the centre of the optical flat will cause it to
deflect slightly and become more nearly parallel with the concave surface, thus reducing the
number of fringes observed.
Commonly, optical flats are used in normal daylight, the spectrum of which has a wavelength
of approximately 05 m. Thus, each fringe interval corresponds to a change in elevation of the
surface of 025 m.
Suppose an optical flat to be laid on to a surface, and the resulting fringe pattern is that shown
in Fig. 2.10.
If the fringes curve towards the line of contact at A, the surface is convex, the opposite case
also applying.
Practice in the use of optical flats is essential to a true understanding of the patterns
produced, and at this point it may be appropriate to indicate the points to be observed in their
use.
Never `wring' an optical flat to a work surface. It should be laid on, so that the flat is not
distorted by tending to adapt itself to the contour of the work surface, thus pro - ducing a false
fringe pattern.
Never `wring' two optical flats together. Separation may be difficult and cause damage.
INTERFEROMETERS
Although optical flats can be used in either daylight, or, better, in a diffused source of near-
monochromatic light, e.g. a light box consisting of a sodium discharge lamp behind a yellow
filter, they suffer the following disadvantages for very precise work :
It is difficult to control the `lay' of the optical flat and thus orientate the fringes to the best
advantage.
The fringe pattern is not viewed from directly above and the resulting obliquity can cause
distortion and errors in viewing.
These problems are overcome by using optical instruments known as inter ferometers, two of
which will be discussed, one for measuring flatness and the other for determining the length
of slip and block gauges by direct reference to the wavelength of light.
This instrument, shown in diagrammatic form in Fig. 2.11, was designed by the National
Physical Laboratory and is manufactured commercially by Coventry Gauge and Tool Co.
Ltd., and Hilger and Watts Ltd.
It consists essentially of a mercury-vapour lamp whose radiations are passed through a green
filter, thus removing all other colours, and leaving a green monochromatic light whose
It should be noted that the optical flat is mounted on an adjustable tripod, independent of the
gauge base plate, so that its angle can be adjusted. Further, the gauge base plate is designed to
be rotated so that the fringes can be orientated to the best advantage.
An advantage of this instrument is that it can also be used for testing the parallelism between
gauge surfaces. Two methods are used:
When shorter gauges are used interference fringes are formed both on the gauge surface and
the base plate. As the gauge is wrung on to the base plate its underside is parallel with its base
plate. This means that if the gauge faces are parallel the fringes on the base plate should be
equally spaced, and parallel with the fringes on the gauge surface.
If the gauge being tested is more than 25 mm in length the fringe pattern on the base plate is
difficult to observe, but the base plate is rotary and its underside is lapped truly parallel with its
working surface. Therefore if a non-parallel gauge is viewed the angle it makes with the optical
flat will be as in Fig. 2.12 (a). If the table is turned through 180 the surface is now less parallel
with the optical flat, Fig. 2.12 (b), and a greater number of fringes is observed.
Consider a gauge which exhibits 10 fringes along its length in one position and 18 fringes in
the second position.
In Fig. 2.12 (a) the distance between the gauge and the optical flat has increased by a distance
1 , over the length of the gauge, and in the second position [Fig. 2.12 (b)], by a distance 2.
It has been shown that the distance between the gauge and the optical flat changes by /2
between adjacent interference fringes.
2 - 1=8 x /2
But due to the rotation through 180 there is a doubling effect. Therefore the error in
parallelism= (2 - 1) / 2 = (8 x /2) / 2 = 4 /2
Thus the gauge has an error in parallelism of 10 micro-meters over its length