Title: Minimum Requirements On Welding From Supplier and Sub-Supplier
Title: Minimum Requirements On Welding From Supplier and Sub-Supplier
Title: Minimum Requirements On Welding From Supplier and Sub-Supplier
Technical Quality
Sulzer Pumps
Page:
Title: Minimum requirements on welding from supplier and sub-supplier
1 of 10
1.0 Scope
1.1 To establish the minimum Sulzer Pumps Equipment requirements for Weld Procedure Specifications,
Weld Procedure Qualification Record, Welder Qualification and other weld related information’s. This
regulation does not seek to limit the degree of testing carried out during procedure qualification,
welder qualification or production, welder qualification or production welding, only to ensure a global
minimum supplier standard.
1.2 This specification applies to all welded fabrication and foundry-level casting repairs for Sulzer. This
includes, but is not limited to, the welding of pump casings, piping, vessels, castings, wear rings and
baseplates. These requirements apply to welding performed by contractors, fabricators, foundries,
and their sub-suppliers. Responsibility for implementation at Sub-suppliers is laying within the
Supplier who receive the Sulzer Purchase Order
1.3 The supplier shall refer to supporting documentation such as e.g. (PS) Purchasing Specification, (PO)
Purchase order, (ITP) Inspection Test Plan, (SQS) Sulzer quality Standards and / or others for
additional requirements.
1.4 Job-specific requirements may take precedence over or add to the requirements of this document. In
the event that requirements appear to conflict, the more stringent requirements shall prevail and any
conflict or question shall be brought to the attention of Sulzer.
1.5 Any required deviation to this document shall be submitted to Sulzer for review and approval.
1.6 All relevant construction codes must be adhered to with all welded items. The requirements in this
document are in addition to the code requirements. The code shall be always of latest edition unless
otherwise specified.
1.7 At any time a welding related document may be reviewed by Sulzer for compliance with contract
specifications and engineering requirements. Welder qualification (WPQ) , Weld procedures (WPS)
and or Procedure qualification records (PQR`s)or any other such as (PWHT procedures) or others not
named here, which do not meet contract specifications or engineering requirements may be rejected
at any time.
1.8 Welding of certain items is not addressed by this specification. This items include:
1.8.1 Specific noncritical, non-structural items including guards, fans, clamps, oil-retaining shields and non-
structural stands.
1.8.2 All relevant construction codes must be adhered to with these items.
3.0 References
3.1 All standards, codes and norms refer to the last published edition and addenda, which has to be
adopted if customer is not requiring a former version.
ASME BPVC IX American society of mechanical engineers Boiler and pressure vessel
code (Section: 9 “Welding and brazing qualifications”)
ASME BPVC II-C Specification for welding rods, electrodes and filler metals.
ASME BPVC VIII American society of mechanical engineers Boiler and pressure vessel
code (Section: 8“Rules of construction for pressure vessels”)
EN ISO 15614-1 Specification and qualification of welding procedures for metallic
materials - Welding procedure test - Part 1: Arc and gas welding of
steels and arc welding of nickel and nickel alloys
EN ISO 9606-1 to 4 Qualification testing of welders (Fusion welding)
NORSOK M-601 Welding and Inspection of Piping
ASTM A 488 Standard practices for steel castings, welding, qualification of
procedures and qualification
AWS D1.1 Structural welding code “steel”
ASME B 31.3 American society of mechanical engineers (Process piping)
ASME B 31.1 American society of mechanical engineers (Power piping)
EN ISO 5817 Welding - Fusion-welded joints in steel, nickel, titanium and their
alloys (beam welding excluded) - Quality levels for imperfections
SQS 0006 Handling of stainless steel
SQS 0007 Guideline for welding duplex materials
SQS 0008 Welding of martensitic stainless steels
4.0 Responsibility
4.1 Responsibility for compliance with this specification shall be defined within each supplier and or sub-
supplier site. Each supplier shall define implementation of these requirements in a written procedure
which shall define who in the organization is responsible for conducting, evaluating and approving
weld tests as well as responsibilities for records and communication towards Sulzer. One designated
point of contact at the supplier is preferred.
5.3 The necessary WPS for the job must be present in the shop at the time of welding and be understood
in fully by the welder and or welding operator.
5.4 The only option to use pre-qualified WPS is if the requirements from AWS D 1.1 or the EN ISO 1090
is implemented and documented in fully. The use of pre-qualified procedures shall be approved in
writing by Sulzer prior to the commencement of welding. The welder qualification must be in
accordance to ASME BPVC IX or EN ISO 9606. The AWS D1.1 only if applicable.
5.5 At any time a weld procedure may be reviewed by Sulzer for compliance with contract specifications
and engineering requirements. Weld procedures or PQRs which do not meet contract specifications
or engineering requirements may be rejected at any time.
7.3 Welder qualification shall be done in a position that reflects the position of the daily work. The best
proof for skill is a welder qualification in ASME 6G but shall only be requested if applicable in
production.
7.4 All welding activities including preparations like tack welding, fabrication and repair work shall be
done by qualified welders only with the aid of a WPS. This also applies to tack welds which will be
removed before the completion of the weld.
7.5 A welder continuity log must be established in accordance to applied code or standard. The log must
be up to date at any time.
7.6 A written examination for welders on the theory, safety, and processes for welding is recommended.
The so called “job knowledge test” shall be done whenever a new welder qualification takes place or
at least every second year.
7.7 If a job knowledge test program is not available at a supplier site, the current applied training content
and frequency of trainings take place shall be presented to gain understanding and trust in the
qualification and skill of the welders.
7.8 A welder maintenance log documenting continuity of welder qualification shall be maintained in
accordance to the standard applied.
7.9 Independent of the applied standard and or code. It is recommended to renew the welder qualification
every 5 Years latest. This applies independently of the welder maintenance log status.
7.10 The vendor will immediately remove any welder or welding operator from work on Sulzer’s
components when, in the opinion of Sulzer, the welder does not possess the required competency or
attention to produce sound welds.
8.3 All PWHT equipment inclusive recording systems and related sensors must be regularly calibrated.
8.4 All closed heating chambers (e.g. furnace) require a temperature uniformity calibration. In accordance
to ASTM A991.
8.5 Any required NDE, including hardness testing, shall be carried out after final PWHT (if PWHT is
required). At suppliers option, for internal purposes, suppliers may choose to perform additional NDE
prior to PWHT, in order to identify defects before PWHT.
11.1.4 The storage and handling of filler materials and its conditions. Furthermore handling of flux and flux
coated or cored filler materials with parameters for storage and re-drying.
15.2.3.1 Heat input for DSS shall not exceed 2,50 kJ/mm (55 kj / in).
15.2.3.2 Heat input for SDSS shall not exceed 1,5 kJ/mm (37 kj / in).
15.2.4 Prequalification of DSS and SDSS weld procedures per AWS D1.1 is not allowed. DSS and SDSS
weld procedures require testing per the requirements of Table 1 of this document.
15.2.5 PQRs done on SDSS allow the welding of DSS, with an appropriate filler metal adjustment. PQRs
done on DSS allow the welding of DSS but not SDSS. Unless stated otherwise by other related
document.
15.2.6 Sulzer recommendation is not to use FCAW wire larger than 0.045” (1.2 mm) for DSS or SDSS.
Unless the related PQR values are achieved as described in Table 1.
16 General notes.
16.1 All certification and delivery advice documentation shall include the Sulzer Purchase Order number,
line item number and material number.
16.2 All documentation shall be provided on or prior to delivery of the material.
16.3 Acceptance of the material shall be on satisfactory compliance to the Purchase Order requirements.
16.4 All standards and Sulzer documents referenced shall be current issues unless stated otherwise.
16.5 Failure to comply with the above requirements could result in rejection or delayed payment of
invoices.
17 Sulzer attitude
17.1 This document has been established to provide minimum requirements on welded components for
Sulzer. If you have a need for further information or on clarification of technical details, please do not
hesitate to get in contact with the responsible Sulzer representative.
17.2 Our all future relies on the quality of the components and equipment we deliver our customer today.
Do not assume, know, clarify and help us to exceed our customer’s expectation and convince him
about our products by deliver what we promise and more, but never less.
Intergranular corrosion
LP or MP Examination
ASME IX / EN 15614 /
RT or UT Examination
Macro-examination
Micrographic-
Impact Tests
Ferrite count
ASTM A262
examination
Hardness
Test
test
Carbon Steel ● ● ● ○
Note 1, 7, 8
Low Temperature Carbon
Steel ● ● ● ● ●
Note 7, 8
2.5% Cr Steel ● ● ● ○
Note 7, 8
12% Cr Steel ● ● ● ●
Note 7, 8
304 / 304L ● ● ● ○
Note 2, 7, 8
316 / 316L ● ● ● ○ ○ ○
Note 1, 7, 8
22% Cr Duplex ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Notes 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8
25% Cr Duplex ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Notes 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9
CuNi ● ● ●
Note 7, 8
6Mo ● ● ●
Note 7, 8
● Mandatory Requirement.
○ Optional Requirement
Note 1 - Hardness testing shall be carried out where compliance with NACE is required.
Note 2 - For cryogenic service impacts shall be carried out at -196°C (-321°F)
Note 3 - Max. hardness 28 HRC (22% Cr) and 32 HRC (25% Cr)
Note 4 – ASTM G48 shall be at 25°C (77°F) for 24 hours.
Accept: No pitting, 4.0 g/m2 (0.00082 lb/ft2) max. weight loss
Note 5 - Impact tests required at -46°C (-51°F). Accept 45J (single reading 35J) minimum
(Except for 3A and 1B material no Impact testing is required)
Note 6 - Ferrite balance shall be in the range of 35-65% for weld metal and HEZ heat effected zone.
Note 7 - Where a test is not defined in the table, or where it is not defined either as mandatory or optional, then that
test may be carried out at the discretion of the site performing the qualification.
Note 8 – Whenever a new PQR is performed the specimen shall be longer than needed for additional testing with
values different from what we qualify. It is best practice to do the WPQR with a test specimen of extended size in
order to have sufficient material left for further tests. This PQR specimen’s shall be stored properly and stamped for
easy identification as well as from 3rd party inspector if applicable
Note 9- ASTM G48 shall be at: 40°C (104°F) for 24 hours if in the as welded condition.. 50°C (122°F) for 24 hours if
PWHT is applied. Accept: No pitting, 4.0 g/m2 (0.00082 lb/ft2) max. weight loss