Solar Cells Research Paper
Solar Cells Research Paper
Solar Cells Research Paper
Currently 86% of the world’s energy comes from fossil fuels, which pollute the environment in
all phases of their lifecycles, from resource recovery to refinement processes to their final
consumption as fuel (Allen 2010). The combustion of hydrocarbons necessarily releases carbon
dioxide, the most prevalent of the set of greenhouse gases that have been determined to
contribute to global climate change (IPCC 2007). The use of coal, America’s leading source of
electric power (Allen 2010), is particularly deleterious to the environment; in addition to
contributing to greenhouse gas emissions, coal has been implicated in the annual global release
of tens of thousands of tons of radioactive isotopes into the atmosphere (Gabbard 1993). Almost
all power plants consume large amounts of fresh water from lakes and rivers to cool their heat-
intensive generators, a resource cost that is often overlooked when considering the impacts of
energy production (Smith et al. 2005).
Solar energy currently accounts for less than 0.1% of all American energy production (Allen
2010). While the sun’s energy is free, efficient solar energy devices are expensive; production
requires the investment of large capital costs, making it the most expensive source of energy on
the basis of cost per kilowatt-hour (Patel 2005). Therefore, without large government subsidies,
tax incentives, and/or carbon taxes, the market will continue to prefer less expensive—but more
environmentally harmful—traditional fossil fuels. Additionally, the availability of solar energy is
strongly a function of season, time of day, climate, and geography, so the electric grid and
transportation infrastructure must be adapted to allow for a higher degree of intermittency if solar
power is ever to supply a major portion of national and international energy demand.
If these problems of production and implementation are overcome, solar energy has the potential
to provide a potent alternative energy source and decrease humanity’s dependence on traditional
energy sources. Moving away from the use of hydrocarbon and nuclear fuels reduces the
emissions of harmful substances into all environmental media, while simultaneously providing a
more sustainable source of energy. The problems associated with fossil fuels are of growing
international concern when faced with the possibilities of global climate change and decreasing
supplies of fresh, unpolluted water. The depletion of the planet’s available deposits of fossil fuels
and nuclear fuel material is inevitable if no viable alternative source is found. If successful, solar
energy would be able to postpone, or even prevent, the exhaustion of these resources.
This report discusses two aspects of solar energy production: technology and implementation.
The section on technology provides details on currently available technology, focusing on the
variety of photovoltaic options and ending with a brief discussion of thermal solar systems, and
then discusses possible future technologies that are in development. The section on
Justin Chandler, Ariel Williams 2
implementation outlines the problems that have inhibited the widespread utilization of solar
energy, proposed solutions, and government and corporate programs to develop this technology
into an economically viable energy source.
Our discussion is focused primarily on integration efforts in the United States, with the exception
of our discussion on thermal solar energy storage, which uses a Spanish facility as a model.
While Europe leads the world in solar energy production (Patel 2005), the governmental policies
that have driven these endeavors are too numerous and variable to discuss in any depth in this
report.
In our discussions that follow, we mark words with asterisks to indicate that they are defined in
the glossary on page 14.
TECHNOLOGY
Solar energy production methods implement either thermal or photovoltaic processes.
In thermal solar energy generation, the device is constructed such that the electrons flow equally
in all directions, producing no net electric current; the electrons simply emit their acquired
energy in the form of heat. This heat is captured by a storage medium such as water, concrete, or
molten salt that transfers energy to a closed loop of water, generating steam to power a turbine.
1. High efficiency: the ratio of electricity produced to incident light for the standard
sunlight spectrum
2. Low band gap: the amount of energy required to excite an electron from its ambient
condition in the valence band* to an energetic condition in the conduction band*.
Lowering the band gap increases the portion of the spectrum that can be absorbed and
converted to electricity.
Current Technologies
Below we discuss a variety of solar energy generation technologies, starting with photovoltaic
devices and ending with a brief discussion on thermal solar systems.
Justin Chandler, Ariel Williams 4
Silicon Wafers
Most silicon wafer cells exactly follow the standard structure in Figure 1. The general method of
production is relatively straightforward: a silicon wafer is first doped throughout with p-type
impurities using standard ion implantation techniques followed by implanting a thin layer on the
surface with an excess of n-type impurities. Aluminum and silicon intermix at temperatures
above 450˚C, so the wafer can be mounted to the aluminum back contact by heating to such a
temperature (Patel 2005). Below we discuss the two main varieties of silicon wafer solar cell
technology.
Heterojunctions
A heterojunction is a device that interfaces two or more dissimilar semiconductors having unique
band gaps. When stimulated by light, electric fields are generated, causing charge carriers to
become mobile and electric current to flow. There are a variety of photovoltaic devices that
implement this architecture, and we discuss the most common varieties below. Figure 2 shows
the general structures of the three types of heterojunction devices we discuss, where the bottom
grey layer represents the conducting metal on which the active layer is mounted, the blue
represents the material that donates electrons, and the pink represents the material that accepts
electrons.
Multijunction Cells
All of the photovoltaic technologies that we have discussed so far have incorporated materials in
a way that gives the devices at most only two band gaps. Any incident photons that have
energies below the lowest band gap of a device will not be converted to electricity, but will
instead be reflected, transmitted, or absorbed as heat.
energy electrons that are collected by the fluorinated tin oxide (SnO2:F) layer and sent to the (-)
terminal. The hole-transport material (HTM) is a polymer or an electrolyte* solution coated onto
the titanium oxide layer that carries holes* generated by the dye to a platinum wire mesh (Pt)
that carries them to the (+) terminal. The HTM also serves to return the electrons to the absorbed
dye to be re-excited (Shin et al. 2006).
Thermal solar energy systems have an advantage over photovoltaics—they can produce
electricity during the nighttime. During the daytime, excess thermal energy can be collected and
stored in the form of high-pressure steam or molten salts. Sandia National Laboratory (2008)
Justin Chandler, Ariel Williams 7
reported a solar-to-grid conversion efficiency of 31.25% for a single-dish system, a new record
in thermal solar energy production.
Photovoltaic Windows
Desilvestro and Hebting (2009) propose the application of semitransparent DSSCs to produce
photovoltaic windows. If inexpensive DSSCs are developed, then they are particularly suited to
such an application due to their ability to absorb light coming from all directions, unlike solar
cells mounted on layers of opaque crystalline silicon. If the absorption profile of the DSSC is
largely in the ultraviolet band of the sunlight spectrum, then a reasonable amount of energy can
be produced without decreasing the transparency of the window. And if the device partially
absorbs in the visible spectrum it could provide a useful replacement for tinted windows that
produces energy instead of wasting it reflection or heat losses.
IMPLEMENTATION
As of 2008, the rate of American solar energy production reached 8,775 MW, 792 MW of which
was grid-connected photovoltaic power. While solar energy currently accounts for less than
Justin Chandler, Ariel Williams 8
0.1% of energy production, the SEIA estimates that domestic photovoltaic production increased
by approximately 65% in 2008, making it the nation’s fastest growing energy source (SEIA
2009). Currently only 6.1% of American energy demand is met by renewable energy sources,
less than 1% of which coming from solar sources, being dominated instead by corn ethanol and
wind. (See Figure A-1 for a breakdown of energy sources and demand sectors.)
Below we discuss the challenges of utilizing solar as a major component of America’s energy
production portfolio, as well as solutions that have been offered to facilitate its incorporation into
the electric grid and transportation sector. We then discuss some examples of programs and
funding by government and the private sector to assist individuals and corporations in the
installation of solar generation capacity.
Challenges
Below we discuss the challenges that have been cited most often as barriers to the future
widespread implementation of solar energy.
Table 1: Generation, Investment, and External Costs for Large Scale Technologies in the U.S. (Patel 2005)
Societal and
Generation Cost
Technology Investment Cost ($/W) Environmental Costs
(cents/KWh)
(cents/kWh)
Coal, thermal 3–5 1.0–1.5 2.0–15
Nuclear 3–8 1.2–2.0 0.2–0.6
Gas combined cycle 3–5 0.5–0.7 1.0–4.0
Small hydro 5–10 0.8–1.2 –
Biomass, thermal 4–10 1.5–2.5 –
Wind 3–5 0.8–1.5 0.05–0.25
Solar, PV 20–35 6.0–8.0 0.05–0.25
Solar, thermal 15–30 4.0–6.0 –
Justin Chandler, Ariel Williams 9
If the renewable component of the electric grid exceeds 10 to 15%, backup power is
required to provide electricity when the wind speed slows or when cloudy conditions
exist. The cost of this backup power creates a very large economic barrier to the large-
scale use of renewable electricity production.
Deregulation of the electrical utility industry and mergers of major providers have resulted in a
decrease of excess infrastructure in order to decrease operation costs. However, this additional
infrastructure once served as a useful buffer that helped to prevent widespread blackouts that can
result from a variety of power flow issues (Amin et al. 2005). Given these considerations, the
nation’s electrical distribution grid must be improved and problems with energy storage must be
overcome before solar energy can provide a major portion of American demand for electricity.
Increased use of battery-powered automotive travel would place additional strain on an energy
grid powered by a significant solar component. Most hybrid owners charge their cars in the
evening and though the night, when solar energy in unavailable for collection. Therefore,
demand must be met through other means.
Solutions
Below we discuss some of the solutions that have been offered to help solve the problems that
we discuss above.
Storage
One solution to the problems of portability for the transportation section and intermittent
availability of sunlight is to collect an excess amount of energy during the day, convert to
electricity only the portion that is demanded, and store the remainder for electrical generation
during the night and cloudy days. A variety of methods have been proposed, some of which we
discuss below.
A new facility in Spain was launched in 2007 that stores excess collected energy in the form of
molten salt, allowing it to generate electricity in the dark for as long as fifteen hours, due to salt’s
high heat capacity. Such a large storage time is a powerful solution to intermittency. It is the
first of its kind in the world, but if it is shown to be successful in the long term, then it is possible
that companies in other countries will construct similar systems (Martin 2007).
Batteries
Today’s batteries suffer from low storage density, making them inconvenient for use in the
transportation sector (Agrawal 2007). And even the largest battery in the world, employed in
Alaska for emergency power, is only capable of storing enough energy to serve a small city of
12,000 people for 7 minutes (Telegraph 2003).
However, recent research by MIT professor Donald Sadoway indicates the feasibility of a large-
scale liquid-metal battery system that can be used to store excess grid energy. It operates at
temperatures high enough to maintain the molten state of its constituent metals (currently
Justin Chandler, Ariel Williams 11
confidential), which Sadoway claims can be implemented without the need for external heating,
due to the high currents that would flow through the device. While it is not intended for portable
applications, we imagine that it would be helpful in the widespread implementation of
photovoltaic energy since it could provide a previously unavailable capacity for large-scale
energy storage (MIT News Office 2009).
Hydrogen
Compressed and liquefied hydrogen offer alternatives to battery storage as media to increase the
portability of solar energy for the transportation sector. Electrical power generated by solar
methods can be used to split water into hydrogen and oxygen gases, which are then separated.
Hydrogen is stored in a compressed state, or cooled to the extremely low temperatures (-
253°C or -423°F) required to liquefy it. Liquid hydrogen has a storage density comparable to
that of gasoline, making it a much more convenient energy storage medium than batteries.
However, the realization of a solar-powered hydrogen economy will require an improved
hydrogen distribution infrastructure and technological improvements in fuel cells to increase
efficiency and decrease associated capital investment costs (Forsberg 2006).
In a proposed Unified Smart Grid system, the existing regional grids of the North American
Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC), which we map in Figure A-3, are increasingly
interconnected and improved with automated power flow infrastructure. Such an interconnected
system would serve the purpose of managing the risks associated with intermittent energy
sources; while it is somewhat probable that, at any given time, some regions will suffer from
decreased solar energy production as a result of cloud cover, it is highly improbable that the
entire national will simultaneously be suffering from such a problem. Expanding the lateral area
of the Smart Grid to cover the entire nation would also increase the number of hours of the day
that the national grid receives solar energy inputs, increasing the flexibility of America’s solar
resources (Amin et al. 2005, Patel 2005).
Justin Chandler, Ariel Williams 12
Corporations
Below we provide two examples of corporations that are investing in and/or providing funding to
projects to help make solar power more accessible to the public.
Justin Chandler, Ariel Williams 13
BP Solar
BP Solar has partnered with Home Depot to provide all devices and services necessary to equip a
home or business with solar panels. BP Solar offers consultations and quotes, provides
installation services, and performs check-ups six months after the initial installation. BP Solar
also offers lease agreements in which its installs the panels and provides any necessary
maintenance on the system for a monthly fee, effectively eliminating the upfront capital costs
associated with solar power. Such available arrangements will likely encourage households and
businesses to install photovoltaic solar power systems (BP Solar 2009).
Google.org
In 2007 Google.org, Google’s philanthropic arm, initiated the largest solar panel installation in
the United States at their headquarters in California (see Figure A-4). Also in 2007, Google
launched the RechargeIT program to research electric and hybrid vehicles, important
components for realizing a solar-powered transportation sector. The first round of testing
concluded that these types of cars get approximately 90 mpg, with carbon dioxide emissions that
are 65% less than standard petroleum-powered vehicles. In addition to funding its own research,
Google.org issued $10 million in grants to assist external research and development of plug-in
vehicles, storage technologies, and other renewable energy applications (Google.org 2007).
CONCLUSION
Given the continuing increase in energy demand and decreasing fossil fuel reserves, solar energy
will likely serve a greater role in satisfying American energy demand. It is likely that ongoing
efforts in research and development will continue to increase the economic viability of solar
energy generation. Once the capital investment costs become sufficiently low, it is reasonable to
expect an explosion in solar cell manufacture to meet a high demand for inexpensive energy.
Anticipating this increase in intermittently available energy, and given the funding from the
Federal Government for this purpose, it is likely that electrical providers will upgrade the
infrastructure of the electrical distribution grid. Such improvements will increase the reliability
of the grid.
Solar energy is currently the fastest-growing source of energy production, and its growth rate
only shows signs of increasing. In the coming decades, if the necessary innovations take place, it
will likely begin to replace traditional fuel sources and have an important place in America’s
green revolution.
Justin Chandler, Ariel Williams 14
GLOSSARY
Band gap: in photovoltaics and semiconductors, the lowest amount of energy a particle of light
(see photon) must have in order to excite an electron in a specified material. In this context,
every material has one band gap that is determined by its identity.
Conjugated: A chain of carbons bound with alternating double bonds, resulting in an extended
area in which electrons are free to move
Dope: to deposit an electrically active impurity (referred to as a dopant) into an otherwise pure
material
Hole: The lack of an electron in a bond. It exhibits behavior that can be characterized as though
it were a positively charged particle.
Photon: The oscillating ―particle‖ that is the elementary constituent of light. It can be thought of
as a packet of electromagnetic energy, the amount of which is determined by the frequency of its
oscillations.
Storage density: maximum amount of energy that can be stored in a medium per unit mass of
that medium
APPENDIX
Figure A-1: Energy Sources and Demand Sector (Allen Lecture 2010)
Figure A-4: Aerial View of Solar Installations at Google Headquarters in Mountain View, CA.
Justin Chandler, Ariel Williams 17
REFERENCES
Agrawal, R., Singh, N., Ribeiro, F., Delgass, W. 2007. Sustainable fuel for transportation sector.
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. 104 (2):
4828–4833.
Amin, S.M., Wollenberg, B.F. 2005. Toward a Smart Grid. IEEE Power and Energy Magazine.
3 (5): 34–38.
Desilvestro, H., Hebting, Y. 2009. Ruthenium-Based Dyes for Dye Solar Cells. Sigma-Aldrich
Materials Science. http://www.sigmaaldrich.com/materials-science/organic-electronics/dye-
solar-cells.html (Accessed April 2, 2010).
EERE (Department of Energy: Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy). 2010. Solar Energy
Technologies Program Newsletter.
http://www1.eere.energy.gov/solar/pdfs/solar_newsletter_2010_qtr1.pdf (Accessed April 20,
2010).
Google.org. 2007. Google.org to fund more than $10 million to accelerate plug-in hybrid and
vehicle-to-grid technology. http://www.google.com/intl/en/press/pressrel/rechargeit
_20070618.html. (Accessed April 8, 2010).
IPCC (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change), 2007: Climate Change 2007: The Physical
Science Basis. Contribution of Working Group I to the Fourth Assessment Report of the
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. ed. Solomon, S., Qin, D., Manning, M. Chen, Z.,
Kadixy, LTD. 2010. http://www.kaxidy.com/Solar/amorphous-cell.html (Accessed April 5,
2010).
Marquis, M., Averyt, K.B., Tignor, M., Miller, H.L. New York City: Cambridge University
Press.
Martin, Solar Tres. J.C. NREL CSP Technology Workshop – Denver, 7 March 2007.
http://www.nrel.gov/csp/troughnet/pdfs/2007/martin_solar_tres.pdf (Accessed April 18, 2010).
Mayer, A.C., Scully, S.R., Hardin, B.E., Rowell, M.W., McGehee, M.D. 2007. Polymer-Based
Solar Cells. Materials Today. 10 (11): 28–33.
Patel, M.R. 2005. Wind and Solar Power Systems: Design, Analysis, and Operation. Chaps. 1, 8,
9. CRC Press.
Justin Chandler, Ariel Williams 19
Sandia National Laboratories. 2008. Sandia, Stirling Energy Systems set new world record for
solar-to-grid conversion efficiency.
http://www.sandia.gov/news/resources/releases/2008/solargrid.html (Accessed April 18, 2010).
SEIA (Solar Energy Industries Association). 2009. U.S. Solar Industry Year in Review.
http://www.seia.org/galleries/pdf/2008_Year_in_Review-small.pdf (Accessed April 15, 2010).
Shin, W.S., Kim, S.C., Lee, S.J., Jeon, H.S., Kim, M.K., Naidu, B.V.K., Jin, S.H., Lee, J.K., Lee,
J.W., Gal, Y.S. 2006. Synthesis and Photovoltaic Properties of a Low-Band-Gap Polymer
Consisting of Alternating Thiophene and Benzothiadiazole Derivatives for Bulk-Heterojunction
and Dye-Sensitized Solar Cells. J. Polym. Sci., Part A: Polym. Chem. 45 (8): 1394–1402.
Smith, J.M., Van Ness, H.C., Abbott, M.M. 2005. The Steam Power Plant. In Introduction to
Chemical Engineering Thermodynamics, 7th, ed. Smith, J.M., Van Ness, H.C., Abbott, M.M.
Chap. 8, 296–302. New York City: McGraw-Hill.
Telegraph. Aug 28, 2003. Conway, E. World’s Biggest Battery Switched on in Alaska.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/3312118/Worlds-biggest-battery-switched-on-in-
Alaska.html (Accessed April 22, 2010).