Digital Transformation in Process Industries
Digital Transformation in Process Industries
Digital Transformation in Process Industries
in Process Industries
A Journey Towards
Autonomous Operations
EBOOK-DXPC-012021
Table of Contents
04 1 ― INTRODUCTION
04 1.1 Drivers for digital transformation
06 1.2 Benefits of digital transformation
06 1.3 DX - A strategic imperative linked to survival
08 2 ― W H AT I S D I G I TA L T R A N S F O R M AT I O N ( D X ) ?
08 2.1 Digitalization isn’t new
09 2.2 Some things are new
14 2.3 Digital Transformation as a Journey
15 3 ― B U S I N E S S M O D E L A N D S T R AT E G Y
16 3.1 Three common business strategies
20 3.2 Sustainability
22 4 ― IT/OT CONVERGENCE
23 4.1 IT/OT in Manufacturing
25 4.2 Making IT/OT Convergence Work
27 5 ― M A K I N G I N D U S T R I A L A U T O M AT I O N S M A R T
28 5.1 Sensors
29 5.2 Automation Networks
30 5.3 Control and Automation
32 5.4 Process and Asset Data
34 5.5 Applications and Services
35 5.6 Enterprise Integration
36 6 ― D I G I TA L I Z E E V E R Y W H E R E I N O P E R AT I O N S
37 6.1 Asset/Facility Lifecycle
38 6.2 Value Chain
39 6.3 Production and Manufacturing
40 6.4 Human Reliability and Domain Knowledge
41 6.5 Health, Safety, Security, and Environment (HSSE) and Cyber Security
43 7 ― T H E R O L E O F L E A D E R S H I P A N D B U S I N E S S C U LT U R E
44 7.1 Culture
44 7.2 Leadership
45 7.3 New Opportunities
46 8 ― W H E R E S H O U L D W E S TA R T ?
54 C ONC LU SION
55 A P P E N D I X I ― S M A R T M A N U FA C T U R I N G R E F E R E N C E A R C H I T E C T U R E
Foreword
To business leaders and heads of operations, engineering,
and IT functions in process industries: you are in a world
of accelerating change driven by market and technology
conditions. It is causing drastic change in the business
environment. Your future will be decided by your ability
to respond to market conditions using technology.
Fortunately, a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to transform
your organizations is upon you. It is called Digital
Transformation.
Introduction
Digital Transformation: Why Now?
C HA P T E R 1 INTRODUCTION 4
MARKET AND TECHNOLOGY DRIVERS FOR DX
IT AND OT CONVERGENCE
IT-OT business alignment becomes a two-
SAFETY, QUALITY, AND ENVIRONMENTAL way street.
REGULATIONS
Digital technologies are set to transform
the global energy system in the coming
decades, making it more connected, CONSUMER TECHNOLOGIES
reliable, and sustainable. Consumer experiences and technologies
raise customer expectations.
SPEED IS IMPORTANT
Avoid becoming digital prey: “It is no longer
the big beating the small, but the fast CUSTOMER INSIGHTS
beating the slow.” (Eric Pearson, CIO of the Front office technologies provide real-time
InterContinental Hotel Group). customer insights and forecasts to drive
operations.
C HA P T E R 1 INTRODUCTION 5
1.2 BENEFITS OF DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION
BENEFITS OF DX
AGILE RESPONSE TO MARKET CHANGES
A clear view to financial, asset, and production
data across the value chain speeds up
decision making and time to benefit.
REMOTE AND AUTONOMOUS OPERATIONS
Empower your facility to run, learn, adapt
and thrive in tomorrow’s environment.
A CULTURE OF INNOVATION
Digital transformation generates
enthusiasm and inspires product and service
development. Employees feel empowered
through education.
INCREASED INTERNAL COLLABORATION
Collaboration improves between business
functions to unlock greater business value
and efficiency.
With the constant evolution of digital technologies, new opportunities are arising for those
who are actively embracing and participating in DX. Everyone must examine their unique
organizational contributions, knowledge, and skills and then connect those strengths to the
DX process.
C HA P T E R 1 INTRODUCTION 6
FROM INDUSTRIAL AUTOMATION
TO INDUSTRIAL AUTONOMY (IA2IA)
Through co -innovation,
Yokogawa creates new value with INDUSTRIAL
our clients for a brighter future. AUTONOMY
SEMI AUTONOMOUS
DX Applied to SMART
Production and
Manufacturing MANUFACTURING
AUTOMATED
as autonomous robots, additive manufacturing, artificial intelligence, augmented reality and 5G will
allow for increased levels of automation, remote and unmanned operations. Putting humans out of
harm’s way, a facility might entirely automate operations, maintenance, and incident management.
Yokogawa believes for many end users, to achieve their smart manufacturing goals, autonomous
operations is the destination. Autonomous Operations can be defined as assets and operations
that have human like learning and adaptive capabilities that allow it to respond without operator
interaction to situations within a secure bounded domain that were not pre-programmed or
anticipated in the design and is responsible for all safety-critical functions. IA2IA is what Yokogawa
C HA P T E R 1 INTRODUCTION 7
C HA P T E R 2
What is
Digital Transformation (DX)?
DX is a journey towards autonomous operations
While Digital Transformation (DX) means different things to different people, its concept
can become a mantra for earning relevance and establishing leadership in a digital
economy. Rather than react to change or be disrupted by it, forward-looking companies
are investing in DX to adapt and outperform peers.
DX is the novel use of digital technology to accelerate your company’s business strategy,
not technology for technology’s sake. Whereas digitization is the act of converting
information into a digital format, digitalization and DX involve business and workflow
changes, enterprise operations and business transformation. DX is all about reorienting the
business performance of an enterprise, by appropriate use of digital technologies.
Process industry veterans may observe that the concept of applying digital technologies
to improve operational excellence isn’t new. Since the 80’s, process industries have
embraced digital technology to better understand and manage resources, improve
safety, and increase efficiencies. In fact, the field of Industrial Automation (IA) has given
rise to this third industrial revolution for nearly half a century.
INDUSTRY 4.0
INDUSTRY 1.0
industrial production
Mechanical
combined with
production with modern information
water and steam and communication
power technology
It is a strange and remarkable phenomenon that, in our personal lives, we are now deeply
connected to physical and virtual worlds that are both global and intimate. The experience is
undoubtedly human, allowing us to find friends, share ideas, conduct commerce, and delight
in moments of genuine engagement. The future is already here, enabled by technological
transformations in how we communicate, connect, and decide. From shopping, banking,
and real estate to entertainment, travel, and mobility, our personal lives and customer
experiences have been completely transformed through the application of IT.
IT mega trends have driven massive growth in computing power, storage, bandwidth, and
information. In this environment, the network effect—a phenomenon whereby a product,
service, or platform gains additional value as more people use it—has enabled the open
sharing of ideas and development tools and an agile approach to exponentially accelerate
the effects of software development, algorithms, and new business models. Indeed,
7 of the 10 largest companies in the world today, based on market capitalization, are
fundamentally IT companies.
IT MEGA TRENDS
CLOUD
Cloud
Open
Architecture
The cloud is at the heart of IT transformation. It has practically eliminated the need for
on-premise IT data centers, server co-location, and traditional in-house IT resources.
The cloud has achieved this through virtual provisioning and access to computing
infrastructure—computing power, storage, and bandwidth. Software-configured servers,
storage, networking, and middleware have enabled companies to focus on the application
layer, where domain knowledge and core competencies are implemented into code.
In a cloud environment, large amounts of data are ingested across multiple sources and
are available to support insightful decision making and application interoperability. The
industrial automation architecture is evolving its technology stack towards a model that
resembles IoT while retaining the needs of industrial operations. Delivering new levels
of connectivity without compromising safety requires a domain-aware approach to
equipment, assets, data, and application integration.
The cloud is already the infrastructure of choice for most business applications, especially
outside the energy and chemical sector. However, it remains unexploited for most
operational applications. The reason is that most valuable operational applications rely on
a continuous feed of plant data which means they can never be isolated from the plant in
a way that say an HR performance management system or capital budgeting system can.
This is partially addressed with ‘edge devices’ living in the ‘fog’ between the real world of
the plant and the virtual world of the cloud to bridge the gap, but there is still a potential
pathway for a ‘bad actor’ to reach the plant even through an edge device.
The term cloud is a generic reference to accessing data and applications over the
internet instead of on your local machine, and includes infrastructure providers
such as such as Microsoft Azure, Amazon Web Services (AWS), or Google Cloud
Provider (GCP)
“ “
COVID-19 comparison
Doreen Bogdan-Martin, Director, ITU BDT. Steve Jobs, late chairman of Apple (1997)
Along with exponential increases in connectivity and devices, there has been a
corresponding increase in data volume. IDC predicts that the collective sum of the world’s
data will grow from 33 zettabytes in 2018 to a 175ZB by 2025, an increased annual growth
rate of 61 percent.
According to Gartner, fewer than 50% of documented corporate strategies mention data
and analytics as fundamental components of enterprise value delivery. But at the same
time, data and analytics are the key in an organization’s digitization and transformation
efforts.
New tools and mechanisms have been created to analyze, visualize, and interpret this
enormous volume of data. New data management and analysis methods have emerged
for storing, searching, and accessing structured and unstructured data. The computational
power associated with advances in analytics has accelerated the changes in most
industries, and early adopters include search engines, social media, and retail.
Many manufacturers have some big data analytics applications in place. However, they are often
only providing old answers to old questions, such as how to reduce downtime by 4% to decrease
costs by 2%. True DX with big data analytics will create new answers to new questions. For example,
plant managers can use massive volumes of data to address business problems that they would not
have been able to tackle before, and of which they might not even have been aware.
IIoT ANALYTICS
Analytics Simulation, AI
Figure: LNS Research - Big Data and Analytics vs. Machine Learning Analytics.
“
[the] best at designing the experience
The Internet and the cloud have significantly changed how application developers
approach projects, collaborate on them, and architect their software. It also spawned
the rise of DevOps (a set of practices that combines software development (Dev) and IT
operations (Ops) to shorten the systems development life cycle and provide continuous
delivery with high software quality) and processes to deploy, manage, and terminate those
software applications through their lifecycle.
Achieving new connectivity levels in the process industry also requires automation
suppliers and end users to challenge the conventional approach of proprietary
technologies and project delivery models. This shift is evident through open industry
initiatives, such as Industry 4.0, NAMUR Open Architecture (NOA), and the Open Process
Automation Forum (OPAF).
A new architecture allows for flexible, open connectivity, and deep integration among
layers to achieve an interconnected and integrated outcome. A converged IT/OT approach
is also referred to as IIoT, Industry 4.0, or Smart Manufacturing.
Digital Transformation
Reference IT/OT Architecture
An IT/OT architecture enables data collection and integration, along with
advanced analytics solutions for deriving value from the data, to solve your
problems within and beyond plants and enterprises.
SEE APPENDIX 1
Digital transformation is not something that can be accomplished overnight. MIT Sloan
Management Review sees it as a journey, a progression comprised of three phases.
The first phase—where most companies make errors that greatly impede their efforts—is
the fundamental change from analog to digital, or “digitization.” Many organizations fall
prey to the temptation to quickly acquire and incorporate new technologies, viewing them
as panaceas and not as essential elements in a long-term strategy. The truth is that the
process is much more complex and layered, and it requires careful planning.
The next phase is the digitalization of industries: the act of making processes more
automated through the use of digital.
The final phase in this framework is digital transformation, which occurs when new digital
business models and processes restructure economies. Societies also evolve as people
integrate the technologies into their lives and habits. Digital transformation is a systems-
level transition that alters behaviors on a large scale.
“
platform is meaningless. A digital initiative should always be
linked to a business process, and your company’s business
strategy should define how it delivers value to customers and
through what distinctive competence or discipline. In short:
an understanding of your company’s business objectives and
strategy is needed to frame the approach.
In their book, The Discipline of Market Leaders, Treacy and Wiersema argue that, nowadays
companies cannot succeed by trying to be all things to all people. Instead, each firm must
find a unique value that it alone can deliver to a chosen market. If a company tries to pursue
all of these business strategies, it will likely end up offering mediocre products for mediocre
prices. Instead, Treacy and Wiersema suggest three value disciplines that can shape every
plan and decision: operational excellence, product leadership, and customer intimacy.
LEADERSHIP VALUE
RODUCT
BEST P
THRESHOLD VALUE
PRODUCT
LEADERSHIP
PRODUCT
ERENTIATIO
IFF N
D
NESS
O P E R AP E T
IVE R
CO M
NS M E
ON
O P E CELL
O STO
MA ER
EX
TI E
BES
U TI
CY
N NA C UP
O
TI O M
RA EN
CE L
TT
OL
S
TI
RE
IN S T
O CE
LS
OT
A
CU
N
L
AL
TA
TO
CO
ST
S
T
BE
Value Disciplines Model (source: Treacy M. and Wiersema F. (1995). The Discipline of Market Leaders)
Operational Excellence
In the operational excellence value discipline, companies are highly asset intensive and have
made large capital investments to support operations. They are characterized by high volume,
low margin business models. Hence, production is viewed as the primary constraint to growth
or profitability. An operational excellence strategy aims to drive down costs and risks while
achieving maximum productivity and operating flexibility.
79%
OPERATIONS LEADERS IN PETROCHEMICALS AND OIL &
GAS, OVER
While a small plant may view operational excellence in terms of consistently generating
export quality products, expanding plant capacity, or expanding regional and global
business, a digitally innovative company may consider operational excellence to involve
taking steps toward remote, unmanned, or even fully autonomous operations.
● Flexibility & agility in production ● Regulatory framework issues ● Demands for high-level of
for adopting digitalization safety standards
● Supply chain resilience
● Cyber security challenges ● Under-utilized sensor data
● Reduced time to market
● System reliability issues ● Machine uptime
● CAPEX & OPEX reduction
● Resistance to adopt digital ● Lack of skilled manpower
● Better and more consistent
solutions
quality ● Fragmented digital landscape:
● Low energy efficiency mining companies are looking
● Safer and more sustainable
for holistic solutions.
processes
Product leadership is about consistently striving to provide In some industries, such as air gas
customers with leading-edge products or useful new delivery, turbines, and compressors,
applications of existing products or services. Some process vendor-managed inventory is already
industries, such as specialty chemicals and pharmaceuticals, a reality, and real-time monitoring,
focus on a product leadership strategy in which Research & analytics, shared data, and supply
Development (R&D) and a rigorous product management chain automation enable new and
approach can reduce time to market and command a price higher value services.
premium for innovative products and services.
“
fostering health. cloud-based applications
and services to improve
Saskia Steinacker, Global head for digital transformation, Bayer catalyst yield, run-length,
and selectivity. A shared data
Customer intimacy historian and process simulator
based on first principles could
Meanwhile, a company that delivers value via customer
provide model-centric technical
intimacy builds bonds with customers that are like
support, troubleshooting, and
those between good neighbors. Such companies do optimization at the right time,
not deliver what the market wants but what a specific delivering superior scheduling,
customer wants. In energy and chemicals, a company’s planning, end-use performance,
operations may exist largely to serve the next step in and differentiation through
the value chain. However, some energy, feedstock, and customer intimacy. Similarly,
specialty chemical companies are increasingly exploring a specialty chemical company
how to increase their customer intimacy and product that supplies chemicals to the
leadership, leveraging deep integration and insights pulp and paper industry could
across customer data and the value chain. dynamically adjust their batch
process to prevent foaming.
Developing a deeper connection to your customer’s
consumption patterns and needs can create a
competitive advantage in terms of your ability to deliver
the right products in the right ways.
Digital technologies are not only transforming markets and creating new paradigms
of doing business, but are also providing organizations with solutions to sustainability
challenges. Therefore, sustainability is an overarching value discipline or business model.
S
Y
U
T
ST
LI
BI
AI
NA
NA
TAI
BIL
SUS
ITY
SUSTA
I N A BILITY
Many companies are actively integrating sustainability principles into their businesses
decisions. They are pursuing goals that go far beyond delivering economic value and the
reputation management- concerns they may have had in the past. There is an increased
focus on broad, long-term goals of saving energy, developing green products, and
retaining and motivating employees, which help them capture value through growth and
return on capital.
2050
(Three Goals)
net-zero emissions well-being circular economy
MID-TERM TARGETS Avoiding CO2 emissions Creating safety and health value Improving resource efficiency
to be achieved by
Target: 1 billion tons Target: 1 trillion yen Target: 1 trillion yen
2030 (cumulative from FY2018 to FY2030) (by FY2030) (by FY2030)
Related SDGs
IT/OT Convergence
From the Automation Pyramid to
the IIoT Technology Stack
A key pillar of digitalization and digital transformation lies in your ability to infuse
information technology (IT) into your company’s operations and operational
technology (OT), and the integration of your business and production environments.
In the past, IT and OT could function independently. OT kept the plant running, and
IT managed business applications from the front office. OT systems were standalone
or used a proprietary platform and communications. Gradually, OT sustems migrated
to running on common IT operation systems. Nowadays, thanks to the 4th industrial
revolution —including the new IT trends described in chapter 2—the previously separate
domains of OT and IT are increasingly merging. Analysts have called this the IT/OT
convergence.
C HA P T E R 4 IT/OT CONVERGENCE 22
4.1 IT/OT IN MANUFACTURING IT/OT CONVERGENCE
CHALLENGES
IT and OT have different backgrounds, but their conjoined
applicability arises from the Industrial Internet of Things
(IIoT).
ORGANIZATIONAL SILOS
OT in manufacturing includes the hardware and Given the breadth of OT in
manufacturing, the machines,
software systems, such as DCS, SIS, PLCs, SCADA, and
devices, and control mechanisms
MES that safeguard and control processes in a plant of modern factories often
environment. operate in relative isolation and
communicate using a variety of
niche protocols. This creates silos,
Manufacturing has been quick to embrace production
communication difficulties, and
technologies, and OT systems can be extremely blind spots in processes.
sophisticated. However, OT systems are not always
networked or incorporated into a broader enterprise
system for reasons related to safety.
IT AND OT SKILLS
IT/OT convergence is changing
In contrast, IT in manufacturing refers to the the way manufacturers work
informational infrastructure in a given operation, and the skills that workers need.
Increasingly, engineers need to
encompassing the network architecture and all of
perform work that is traditionally
the hardware and software components necessary done by software developers,
for processing and storing information. IT includes systems integrators, and network
specialists.
hardware, such as laptops and servers; software,
including enterprise software, such as ERPs; office
productivity programs; and other business-related
tools. CYBER SECURITY
The presence of IP-connected
In the process industry, IT/OT convergence reduce devices, cloud platforms and
open and agile provisioning in
the distance between the systems that control
OT networks introduces new
manufacturing processes and those that control data vulnerabilities and will contribute
storage, communications, and computing. to an increase in number and
variety of cyber threats targeting
“
OT systems.
“
approach to legacy system
culture of the organization modernization. Are problems
caused by technology,
Kristian Steenstrup, analyst and Gartner Fellow architecture or the functionality of
the application?
C HA P T E R 4 IT/OT CONVERGENCE 23
New service models
Even though IT/OT convergence introduces new challenges for manufacturing companies,
it is far outweighed by the DX benefits of potential new business models and digital
services, such as Everything-as-a-Service (XaaS). Examples of XaaS include the “all-you-
can-eat” music and video streaming models, ridesharing services, redefining the tools and
services in Fin(ance)Tech, Mar(keting)Tech, and H(uman)R(esources)Tech.
The IT/OT convergence also offers out-of-the-box integration solutions for plant
automation, asset management, and manufacturing execution systems (MES). This is a
game-changer for business, since it can potentially enable new levels of autonomy and
subscription and outcome-oriented business models. Furthermore, companies who act first
often enjoy a significant market share advantage as their value rises in proportion to the
user base and speed of adoption.
C HA P T E R 4 IT/OT CONVERGENCE 24
4.2 MAKING IT/OT CONVERGENCE WORK
In the DX industry arbitrage approach, we look to early adopter industries for IT and
organizational best practices while keeping the focus on what you know best: your
business. Hence, this approach involves a partner who understands your operational
processes, is fluent in IT and OT, and works with you to innovate in the areas you identify.
READ MORE
C HA P T E R 4 IT/OT CONVERGENCE 25
ENVISION A DIGITAL ENTERPRISE
As IT/OT convergence makes its way across all corporate functions, companies envision a
digital enterprise in which digitalization and automation empower every human at every
level in the organization with situational awareness to view the right information at the
right time and support decision making.
DIGITAL ENTERPRISE
Sales
Finance
INDUSTRIAL CLOUD SOLUTIONS ERP CLOUD SOLUTIONS FRONT OFFICE CLOUD SOLUTIONS
The companies behind consumer IoT applications that combine smart devices with cloud-
based apps have often successfully incorporated an IoT technology stack. This pillared and
open but interconnected architecture is used in the design of IoT products, such as smart
speakers, smart appliances, health and wellness devices, and thermostats. Key amongst
other factors that define the success of digital transformation, is the digital enterprise
architecture that captures the techology stack and its interplay with existing systems and
business processes.
C HA P T E R 4 IT/OT CONVERGENCE 26
C HA P T E R 5
Making Industrial
Automation Smart
The impact of DX on operational technologies
The world of industrial automation (IA) has always centered on cost reduction, improved
productivity, safety, efficiency, and uptime. These elements are now being driven and
accelerated by DX. The global process industry is becoming more connected, networked,
and integrated. For IA this has led to a shift from the traditional ISA-95 automation Purdue
model to a cloud-based digital platform, or the IIoT technology stack. The ISA-95 model, or
automation pyramid, is a layered approach in which one layer is integrated with the next. It
is designed with on-premise production (on a private local area network), operations, and
software in mind. The tip of the pyramid, representing enterprise software integration, was
often aspirational.
Virtualization technologies are now blurring the distinctions between the top three levels and
enabling the migration, engineering and development of software applications in the cloud.
New applications for real-time optimization, edge analytics, machine learning (ML), AI, and
new sensors create opportunities for innovation and automation across the layers. But it also
puts new requirements on integration architecture.
Management Level
ERP ■ From on-premise to Cloud Asset &
Industrial Quality
Enterprise IT
Maintenance Cloud & Yield
IT
Planning Level ED
GE
MES / MOM
■ Non-critical Apps on the Cloud C LO U D
■ Critical Apps on the Edge EDGE ON PREMISE
Supervisory Level E Systems
SCADA, APC G
ED
OT
Control Level
■ Evolution of Edge
DCS / PLC
■ Intelligent Devices
Field Level
Sensors, Actuators,
Hardware OT SYSTEMS IT SYSTEMS
Figure: The shift from the ISA-95 (Purdue) model to an IIoT technology stack model
C LOUD
technology convergences and advances in
miniaturization. Today, a wealth of sensing
technologies are being used to measure,
analyze, or regulate process liquids and
gases, temperature, pressure, flow, level, EDGE
and electrical parameters. They all have Systems
become big sources of IIoT data.
O N- PREM IS E S
OT Data IT Data
Sensing devices are the foundation of an IT/ (secure) (secure)
OT platform and reflect a plant operation’s
vital signs because sensor data is used
to inform and drive plant operational
performance. A successful digital journey
rests on the quality and reliability of OT SYSTEMS IT SYSTEMS
measured data, making suppliers with high
Figure: Wireless sensors measure and transmit the
instrument accuracy and stability well suited
information either to the edge equipment or directly to
to IIoT applications. the sensor cloud using various protocols like ISA100, LoRa,
Sigfox and other wireless protocols.
LESS THAN 5%
OF A MANUFACTURING PLANT’S GENERATED DATA IS PUT TO
GOOD USE, THERE IS A HUGE OPPORTUNITY FOR FIRMS TO REAP
NEW REWARDS THROUGH DIGITIZED SENSORS.
When a facility is automated, an automation network should offer smart, secure wireless
connectivity. Eliminating costly cabling enables the easy reconfiguration of production
lines for an agile factory. This flexible approach to manufacturing helps meet customer
demand for a variety of products. It has the benefits of cellular security for data and device
integrity and an open platform for applications and services for factory developers, device
manufacturers, and original equipment manufacturers (OEMs).
Fieldbuses, or industrial control networks, are dedicated networks designed for mission-
critical control and sensing functions. Originating from analog 4-20mA, fieldbuses have
been superseded by digital protocols such as HART, Profibus, FOUNDATION Fieldbus,
ISA100, and Wireless HART. The choice of automation network depends on the engineering
trade-offs between design, implementation, and maintenance.
Unlike consumer IoT applications, there is a considerable case for maintaining the role of
the automation network for process industries. Given the need to protect human life, plant
assets, and the environment, automation networks provide a critical layer of protection
from IT systems and enterprise applications. Today’s integrated solutions deploy gateways,
firewalls, and other devices that connect disparate networks and translate communications
protocols and data types.
Network Edge
an automation network.
Data Instructions
Edge computing is done at or near the data
source instead of relying on the cloud/data center
to do all the work. The edge controller is often NETWORK EDGE
the secure end point for all plant floor systems. LOCAL CONTROL
It places emphasis on bringing computation and
data storage closer to the sensor with a subset
Inputs Outputs
of the data sent to the cloud for centralized
analysis. Like digital fieldbuses, IIoT can be used
for remote diagnostics, asset management,
predictive maintenance, and safety monitoring.
Operations Technology (OT)
For decades, industrial control systems have played an important role in industrial
automation, allowing process manufacturers to collect, process, and act on data from the
production floor. But DX promises to bring a new era in industrial automation. In this era,
machines will be able to execute complex control functions with self-learning capabilities and
minimal operator interventions. This will allow process manufacturers to reduce accidents
and production downtime tied to human error and achieve optimal plant operation.
DX-driven need for greater system openness, connectivity, and security are likely to continue
shaping future DCS and SCADA developments. SCADA systems already play a critical role
in ensuring the efficient operation of all automation components. They take information
from the plant floor and make it actionable across the digital enterprise. They also power
the IIoT, helping ensure the proper communication of digital information. This enables the
information to do its work in a digitalized industrial organization. And by providing powerful
visualization, SCADA systems work hand in glove with other manufacturing applications
to provide transparency, increase productivity, and achieve digitalization. Consequently, a
SCADA system is a core component in realizing the digital journey to Industry 4.0.
With greater system connectivity, integrated operations centers (IOCs), and dynamic
operator guidance made possible with high-quality alarm systems, process manufacturers
will be able to achieve new levels of system optimization and safety.
MES applications track the transformation of raw materials into physical goods during
the production process and track how physical properties get converted into dollars
and cents. Traditionally, MES resides in the ISA95 automation pyramid between the
enterprise resource planning (ERP) and process control levels. But new technology
enabling direct connectivity from applications, such as MES, to sensor and enterprise
data in the organization. New algorithms and protocols are improving real-time data
flows on the plant floor and optimizing the production process. These improvements
can most easily be made when these applications are based in the cloud allowing data
of AI including the use of graph databases and knowledge graphs and blockchain can
Today, IIoT and Industry 4.0 offer tremendous promise in consolidating the traditional
control hierarchy while applying large-scale cloud-based computing to industrial processes.
The vision of application integration from the control room to the boardroom is brought
dramatically closer to reality with DX. As part of DX, DCS and SCADA systems should
also support web services, IIoT and cloud-based connectivity such as Open Platform
Communications United Architecture (OPC UA) or Message Queuing Telemetry Transport
(MQTT), and IT connectivity like Simple Network Management Protocol (SNMP) or Internet
Control Message Protocol (ICMP) to monitor IT assets.
Client PC Tablet
Plant Asset Human Interface Engineering Plant Information
management Station Station management
Terminal
Server Real Time
Control Network
Unified
Gateway
Gateway Station
Earlier Generation
System
Operator Other IT
Station SCADA Historian
ERP HR Systems
Multi-site
Control
Network
DCS/PLC/RTU OT Data IT Data
(secure) (secure)
CRM SCM PLM
Field IIoT Network EDGE
Network Systems
IT Systems
(Hybrid)
OT Systems
Figure: In an Industrial Cloud paradigm, the Edge represents processing and computing close to
the data source and is regarded as the confluence of OT & IT.
Through a plant’s operations, process and asset data are aggregated, cleaned, and
enriched by a process historian. Most operations have accumulated years of time series
data in various states of completeness; however, only a small portion is being used as a
basis for operational decisions. By processing, interpreting, and applying business logic to
the process and asset data, digital application and services are established.
Apps
Identity Management
Analytics
Analytics & Artificial Intelligence
Cyber Security
Eg. Enterprise data lake,
weather, market data
Data Enterprise Data Management & Orchestration
Curation
Enterprise Data Lake (OT+IT) Service
Providers
Data Eg. Data science &
Enablement Data Ingestion Data Preparation
visualization services
Cloud Infrastructure
Today’s historians and data lakes are being used to store ever-increasing amounts of
data originating from a much wider variety of sources, including control and monitoring,
laboratory information management, and asset management systems. They have the
potential to translate this into actionable insights to implement and improve equipment
diagnostics, maintenance, safety, alarms, production, performance, and other process
plant activities. However, if not managed well, most data lakes lack the essential features
that prevent your data lake from turning into a data swamp.
Historians are the critical point of integration between IT and OT, acting as an OT data
collector to distribute process and asset information throughout the enterprise in various
formats as needed.
petrochemicals industry)
Digital Transformation
Reference IT/OT Architecture
An IT/OT architecture enables data collection and integration, along with
advanced analytics solutions for deriving value from the data, to solve your
problems within and beyond plants and enterprises.
SEE APPENDIX 1
The application and service layer of a digital platform, as shown in the figure below,
processes, interprets, and applies business logic to the underlying process and asset
data. Automation vendors, historian suppliers, and system integrators have created a
wide variety of specialized software applications ranging from analytics, simulation, alarm
management, safety system monitoring, and asset management to mass balancing, off-
site management, and power and energy optimization.
CLOUD
Asset & Safety & Production Energy & Value Chain Quality & Yield
Maintenance Human Optimization Sustainability Optimization Apps
Apps Effectiveness Apps Apps Apps
Apps
Yokog awa A pp s
Apps or solutions are software programs that are built to solve specific business problems.
For example, asset management, production optimization, health and safety, and other
categories which appear in the layer above the apps of a technology stack or digital platform.
Cloud applications are built using different services, such as the data, enterprise data
management and orchestration, logic builder, and visualization available from the platform.
The plumbing on the platform encourages the different apps to connect with each other
and securely exchange or reuse data as needed. Once available on the platform, data
can be reused by other apps, thereby eliminating data duplication along the lifecycle. The
standard apps are configured for deployment using the logic and graphic builder functions.
The apps enable the realization of the vision of DX. In many cases, these app packages are
developed between a supplier and a user to solve specific problems and challenges and
then made into a universal solution available to other users.
Today, in pursuit of user convenience, ubiquitous access, and other IT/OT convergence
benefits, these software applications are being developed in and migrated to the cloud.
The full scope of a company’s enterprise software extends beyond operations and
manufacturing to supply chain, front office commercial systems, financial ERP systems, and
human resources (HR) systems. Simply put, enterprise integration used to be the ERP layer
of the ISA95 pyramid. Now, it can encompass all external integrations form the cloud to the
DX platform.
Integrating all of the above-mentioned systems enables the journey toward a digital
nirvana where companies can increasingly automate the supply chain, commercial
operations, engineering, asset management, and financials.
CLOUD
Technology
Stack
EDGE
Systems
OT Data IT Data
(secure) (secure)
Sales
Finance
Manufacturing
& Supply Chain
Service & Support
Spend Management
Site ‘A’
Site ‘B’ (Secure)
OT Data IT Data
Operator
(secure) (secure)
SCADA Historian Other IT
Station ERP HR Systems
Multi-site
Control OT Data
Network
DCS/PLC/RTU IT Data
(secure) (secure)
OT SYSTEMS IT SYSTEMS CRM SCM PLM
Field IIoT Network
Network
IT Systems
(Hybrid)
OT Systems ON-PREMISES
Digitalize Everywhere
in Operations
The impact of DX on business processes
Your vision of the business should be one of an operational asset, or portfolio of assets,
that exists in the context of their supply chains and surrounding business environment.
To maximize revenue and margin while minimizing cost and risk, the whole asset
together with the supply chain should continuously respond, in unison, to market
signals and disturbances as quickly as possible.
An ideal set of operational processes and best practices would manage your asset through
its lifecycle, production and manufacturing processes, in view of the value / supply chain
and sustainable operating processes. DX in operations seeks to uncover these operational
best practices, automate them and support decision making through technology.
Where to digitalize?
In this chapter, we introduce a high level view of business processes in operations and
the component business processes of which they are comprised. These functional
areas are frequently associated with departments, software applications, and data sets
to be integrated. Taken together we call it: Smart Manufacturing Value Map.
Safety & Human Asset & Production Quality Materials & Planning & Energy &
Effectiveness Maintenance Optimization & Yield Logistics Accounting Sustainability
The most capital and human resource intensive aspect of operations is production/
manufacturing, including the plant or facility construction. Whether brownfield or
greenfield, an asset undergoes years or decades of planning, design, engineering,
operation, and maintenance.
Throughout the asset lifecycle, there are significant opportunities for IT/OT convergence
and productivity improvements, ranging from education and maintenance to incident
response, obsolescence management, and data management. Digital transformation starts
at the beginning of the asset lifecycle with process simulation. Standard XML schemas,
which conform to ISO 15926, can be used to establish an asset knowledge graph and
asset knowledge management foundation. Ontologies, or data structures, can be used
to convert 3D P&ID data and steady state simulations into a semantic model to create
dynamic simulations, control and safety system configurations and logic, and, ultimately,
the asset knowledge graph.
oductio
Pr
n
Supplier Customer
sourcing energy supply n n logistics waste
g
uf
act u ri management
VA LUE C H AI N Upgrade,
revamp, expand
or decommission
Management, automation, and value chain (asset and supply chain) optimization are
central to all process industries. From raw material supply to product delivery and
consumption, process manufacturers must respond quickly and efficiently to market
changes and demand shifts. Digitalizing and integrating data and applications across
the value chain enables optimization. Since data and applications are spread across
organizational silos, an integrated supply chain approach typically requires an enterprise
initiative to stimulate collaboration and information sharing. Today, value chain
optimization is highly manual and dependent on skilled subject matter experts using
simple linear models that may be poorly maintained. As enterprise-wide integration
becomes a reality, companies can achieve automated value chain optimization with data-
driven, automated models and work processes, enabled by the cloud and ML to deliver
significant business agility and outcomes.
The decision cycle for investment planning, production planning, supply chain
scheduling, production accounting, and process control can be accelerated through
digitalization and IT/OT integration, resulting in greater certainty and impact. The
holy grail of value chain optimization lies in the closed loop optimization of planning,
scheduling, operations, and autonomy.
B2B
B2C
Exploration Trade & Procure Plan & Schedule Refining & Petrochem Distribute Cards
Opportunities
Operations Architecture
Big data analytics & digitalizing and integrating data with help of a digital platform
Data Analysis Quick and optimal “From plan to reality”, Overall production Logistics distribution. Real-time services for
& Reservoir decision-making with focusing on : optimization (yield How distribution can customers
modelling help of digital ▪ Cost optimization maximization). To be planned and
technologies to ▪ Blend quality improve Production coordinated between Service experience
optimize: crude assay, optimization quality, operational distributor workforce
refinery configuration, ▪ Safe operations excellence, and (conflict management)
product slate remote operations
Retail inventory
optimization
Track and trace (GPS)
Digital Enablers
AI and
Sensors Cloud The Internet Machine Big Data 3D Printing Software Robotics Data Algorithms
Computing of Things Learning as a Service Analytics
Safety & Human Asset & Production Quality opportunity for firms to reap new
Effectiveness Maintenance Optimization & Yield
rewards through digitized sensors.
Functional Reliable control Revenue Skilled workforce
safety & safety maximization
Clearly, this market scenario
Instrumentation Rigorous
Physical and Capital expense requires the process industry
& analyzer adherence
Cyber security management
maintenance to plans
to re-think traditional plant
Regulatory Asset Operating cost
compliance anagement
m containment operational management
methods. While process plant
Decision Support Data&aquality
ggregation Agile response t o
market changes owners have installed sensors and
Culture of digitized their plants for process
profitability
control, the next prominent
challenge will be to take action to
The key element of a smart manufactruing is deriving digitalize plant operations in a way
real-time data, such as raw material availability and that leverages the plant’s digitized
work-in- progress inventory, from the manufacturing sensor data.
process for decision making and problem solving.
This entails obtaining process and asset data from
individual manufacturing stages using devices
and solution, such as (smart) sensors, control and
automation, automation networks.
Human reliability
Human reliability affects health, safety, security, and environment (HSSE); efficiency; and
availability. In the airline industry, 90% to 95% of all accidents are caused by human factors.
Studies show that process industries have similar characteristics, with the leading cause of
unplanned downtime and accidents attributed to human errors.
Human reliability and predictability can drastically diminish in times of stress. Most
incidents occur during stressful times, such as startups, shutdowns, transitions, and
abnormal situations. The most common human errors are caused by not following
standard operating procedures, unclear operating instructions, too many pressing actions
to handle, inadequate safety and hazard assessments, poor communication, outdated
procedures, inadequate training, and poor alarm management programs.
▪ An operator training simulation is one of the best ways to prepare operators with
realistic simulations of normal and critical situations.
As IT and OT converge, much of the domain knowledge will follow. For example, the sensor level
has always been in the domain of process measurement technologies, such as pressure. Today,
the expertise is evolving to include wireless networking, power consumption, data, and cyber
security. The sensor domain will become IT-aware, while the domain will become sensor-aware.
IoT technologies and IT/OT convergence are also providing for the significantly improved
management of domain knowledge. By digitalizing domain knowledge, today’s enterprises
no longer suffer from huge expertise losses when individuals retire. Digitalizing domain
knowledge using media, such as video, makes it widely available to anyone in need.
For example, it can allow a process pressure expert to expeditiously get up to speed on
wireless networking and data transfer technologies.
Together, safety and human reliability serve as a cornerstone of operations in the energy and
chemical industries. Rigs, plants, ships, pipelines, terminals, and assets are constantly changing
to meet new and evolving regulatory requirements, production targets, and operational
objectives. Safely managing these changes is a daunting task that requires risk assessment,
approvals, change management, and documentation. Many layers of protection are needed to
ensure HSSE. Generally, these include design integrity, asset integrity, and operational integrity.
Safe operations
“
Companies take great measures to ensure safe
operations by conducting HAZOP studies and We can use robotics, augmented reality, big data,
the digital twins and other aspects of Industry
implementing alarm management and procedural
4.0 to help achieve Dow’s 2025 sustainability
automation solutions to keep each process in a safe
goals and to continue to improve our safety
operating window. Companies also use a multitude of
performance. Safety, as well as cyber security,
systems and process analytical equipment to detect
remain paramount as our industry continues to
gas leaks and fugitive emissions, and they use safety
“
evolve.
instrumented systems (SIS) to safely shut down the
Billy B. Bardin. Global Operations Technology Director.
process in case of an incident. These systems can be The Dow Chemical Company. (Chemengonline.com)
Cyber security
Cyber security is a common denominator among all technologies. The cyber security
strategy and implementation approach based on the Purdue Model now extends
throughout the enterprise. A new standards-based approach has been designed to
encompass IT and OT systems. While OT typically uses the NIST cyber security framework,
IT requirements and interactions with third parties could involve additional standards, such
as ISA/IEC 62443 and ISO 27001.
Unique to IIoT, IT/OT convergence implementation teams will continue making decisions
regarding the segregation of OT networks from corporate networks, OT network isolation
from the Internet, least privilege access controls at site and process levels, and cross-site
communication restrictions. Meanwhile, cyber security domain expertise is evolving to
encompass the formerly disparate OT and IT domains.
Antivirus Security
Security Secure Network Virus Check Software
Implementation/ Information Audit
Assessment Design Service Backup Service
Management Service
Network Security
OS Patch Antivirus
Firewall Healthiness Incident
Management Update Check Service Response
Backup Unidirectional
Recovery Gateway
System
Comprehensive system and network security services for plant, manufacturing and operation environments
Lack of Corporate
buy-in and investments
21%
Preserving legacy 7%
investments
DX requires introducing a culture that supports change while also enabling the company’s
overarching business strategy. It asks for informed leaders who acknowledge the existence of
a “digital divide” between plant personnel who deeply understand OT and their counterparts
who deeply understand IT. While OT expertise is typically gained through years or decades of
real-world industrial experience or “tribal knowledge”, the sudden and rapid explosion of IT
has produced a new set of tools that are unfamiliar and overwhelming to industrial customers.
An effective approach to DX recognizes that both skill sets are important, collaboration is
necessary, and collaboration and skill sets must be addressed at all levels of an organization.
7.2 LEADERSHIP
DX initiatives require changes in the culture and mindset of the organization, which
typically reflect the communication and working style of the leadership. Leaders must
recognize the need for change and the capacity constraints that make this difficult.
Due to the enterprise-wide impact of DX and its dependency on IT, the ideal champion of a
company-wide DX tends to be the CEO, or increasingly, a CIO or Chief Digital Officer (CDO)
who can champion and organize the resources and investments required.
DX provides a framework for aligning the leadership team, who can speak with one voice
through this lens to reinforce the company’s strategy and drive a new way of working.
To mitigate anxiety and fear of change, digital leaders have a responsibility to create an
environment where employee development and experimentation are encouraged.
There is a myriad of opportunities for those who actively embrace DX and participate.
Everyone must examine their unique contributions to the organization and their knowledge
and skills and then connect those strengths to the DX process—giving employees control
over how the DX will unfold and framing new technologies as a way to become even better
at what they were already good at doing.
Program management, team building, and sustainability from project inception through
implementation into day-to-day workflows creates opportunities for those who wish to
contribute.
As your company becomes increasingly aware of the external threats and opportunities
of DX, there is a corresponding desire to act. Although strategies should be developed
with an external context, the practical execution of DX begins internally, where your
company can fully own its actions and outcomes. No one knows your problems and
needs better than you.
S T EP 2
S T EP 3
TO EMBARK ON YOUR DX
JOURNEY: Align with corporate Assess
goals and strategy readiness
Maturity
model
ST EP 6
S TEP 4
S TEP 5
Identify quick
wins and
estimate benefits
ST E P 7
ST E P 8
To start with, you need an understanding of your company’s business objectives and
strategy to frame your DX approach. Digitalization efforts driven only by operations tend
to result in limited impact across the enterprise and can lead to long cycles of technical
discussions, limited C-level support, and IT involvement. Strategic investments can be
difficult to justify with operations viewed as a cost center that is fundamentally charged
with delivering maximum productivity at the lowest cost. A strategic approach therefore
involves connecting with your company’s business strategy and business processes. These
business cases can be driven and supported by the C-level or proposed by the organization
and endorsed by the leadership.
STEP 2
ASSESS READINESS
1 2 3
4 5 Shopfloor 6 13 Workforce 14Inter- and
Learning & Intra-Company
Integrated Development Collaboration
Vertical Horizontal
Product 7 8 Enterprise 9
Integration Integration
Livecycle
15 Leadership 16 Strategy &
10 11 Facility 12 Competency Governance
To help manufacturers take the first step on their transformation journey, the Singapore Economic Development Board (“EDB”)
launched the Smart Industry Readiness Index (“SIRI”) and its accompanying Assessment Matrix in November 2017. SIRI identifies
3 fundamental building blocks of Industry 4.0: Technology, Process, and Organisation. All 3 building blocks must be considered to
harness the full potential of Industry 4.0.
MATURITY MODEL
Every DX journey is unique and supported by enabling technologies and services. Along
with maturity and operational assessments, your focus areas and desired outcomes will be
used to guide you in determining your ideal approach for creating value.
STABLE &
RISK INDUSTRY LEADING SUSTAINABLE
REPEATABLE
MINIMIZATION EFFICIENCY & AUTONOMOUS
OPERATIONS
TARGETED
OUTCOMES
VULNERABLE OPERABLE OPTIMAL SUSTAINABLE
Disengaged and
Active knowledge Culture of learning Leaders are digital
People & Culture losing vital
transfer & development innovators
knowledge
Engaged &
IT / OT Collaboration Siloed Tolerant Collaborating
integrated
Internal communications mechanisms are necessary so that everyone can stay informed,
take notice, and act. These measures can involve internal campaigns, blogs, social media
town hall meetings, etc.
DX PROGRAM ORGANIZATION
LEGEND
Customer Yokogawa
Executive Sponsor Executive Sponsor
DX Steering
Committee
Customer Project Team Yokogawa Project Team
Functional SME
Digital Operations Delivery / Project
Program Manager Manager
Finance Planning Operations
Workstream 1
Technology SME
Workstream 2
Figure: Example of a DX program organization outlined by Yokogawa. The customer project team is mirrored to
the DX vendor project team (in this case, Yokogawa). This overview is part of a broader DX framework that will be
discussed in Chapter 8.
DX requires a mindset and culture that places the market, customer value, and customer
experience first. The company must adopt a perspective that prioritizes the needs of
the market over the needs of its departments or leaders and promotes the necessary
organizing principles, processes, portfolio, and operations to deliver those market needs.
In this way, the application of technology, automation, and other expenses can be linked to
business process improvements and their associated value. The ROI model and projections
can be clearly modeled around business processes, costs, and projected returns.
STEP 7
In process industries, business processes also include operational processes, such as plant
startups and shutdowns and shift handovers. As these processes are mapped to the value
chain and other enterprise operations, they unlock greater potential for value delivery.
The quest for digital nirvana is enabled by technology and built upon a systematic
approach to the aggregation and normalization of data.
In process industries, this means auditing your connectivity and access to all process and
asset data with the aim of integrating all OT data in a single data lake and ensuring data
fidelity and quality.
As the data is aggregated, a rigorous approach to data cleansing must be applied, which
addresses duplicate data, enrichment, normalization, and data relationships. Only a data-
centered approach to technology ensures a reliable foundation from which analytics,
application logic, and interoperability can be applied.
Do I have the data? Is my data useful? What and how do I How do I create new
Can I get the data? What can I really do optimise using my business concepts
with my data? data? & value?
P
O
L
VE
DE
DE
SIG
N
D IS C
OVER
Across the spectrum of process industries, Yokogawa partners with customers to support
your journey, while enabling the use of industrial automation technologies, IT/OT services,
and domain knowledge to support operations. We envision a DX that optimizes your
operations through the enterprise value chain.
Our engagement model starts with understanding your goal, identifying challenges,
quantifying financial impact, and estimating the complexity of the change. These actions
are followed by discovery stages to comprehensively understand as-is and desired business
processes, human factors, and enabling technologies. Quick wins are designed to accelerate
implementation and generate proof of value. Throughout this process, we continuously
develop and tune the continuous delivery of value achieved through digitalization.
DISCOVER
Activities:
► Organizational alignment
► Initiative Prioritization
Deliverables:
► DigitalProducts and Services
► Training Program
► Documentation
► Sustainability Plan
differs for each company, the imperative is connecting data, systems, and
organizations to the value chain and
to co-create solutions that fit your needs,
business and domain knowledge. Our
requirements, and budgets. Many solution
dedication to customer success puts
providers have piece-meal offerings, including
you at the forefront of your DX, co-
consulting, IT, and OT technologies. Increasingly, innovating with you throughout your
the best fit DX approach requires a partner who journey to ensure that solutions are
will support you throughout this journey, is tailored to your exact needs.
open and oriented to all possibilities, and takes
responsibility in all aspects of the process from
planning to performance-based results.
Asset & Safety & Production Energy & Value Chain Quality & Yield
Maintenance Human Optimization Sustainability Optimization Apps
Apps Effectiveness Apps Apps Apps
Apps
Yo ko g a w a A p p s
Identity Management
Analytics
Analytics & Artificial Intelligence
Cyber Security
Eg. Enterprise data lake,
weather, market data
Data Enterprise Data Management & Orchestration
Curation
Enterprise Data Lake (OT+IT) Service
Providers
Data Eg. Data science &
Enablement Data Ingestion Data Preparation
visualization services
Site ‘A’
(Secure)
O N- P REM I S E
Site ‘B’
Operator Other IT
Station SCADA Historian
ERP HR Systems
Multi-site
Control
Network
DCS/PLC/RTU OT Data IT Data
(secure) (secure)
CRM SCM PLM
Field IIoT Network EDGE
Network Systems
IT Systems
(Hybrid)
OT Systems
CLOUD APPLICATIONS
Infrastructure Options:
EDGE TECHNOLOGY
Typical OT Components:
Trademarks
The names of corporations, organizations, products, services and logos herein are either registered
trademarks or trademarks of Yokogawa Electric Corporation or their respective holders.