Perspectives of Indian Medical Students On E-Learning As A Tool For Medical Education in The Country: A Quantitative Study
Perspectives of Indian Medical Students On E-Learning As A Tool For Medical Education in The Country: A Quantitative Study
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.18203/2394-6040.ijcmph20203931
Original Research Article
1
MBBS student, Goa Medical College, Bambolim, Goa, India
2
Department of Microbiology, Goa Medical College, Bambolim, Goa, India
3
Department of Preventive and Social Medicine, Goa Medical College, Bambolim, Goa, India
*Correspondence:
Dr. Amit S. Dias,
E-mail: dr_amit_dias@yahoo.com
Copyright: © the author(s), publisher and licensee Medip Academy. This is an open-access article distributed under
the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License, which permits unrestricted non-commercial
use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
ABSTRACT
Background: In view of the COVID-19 pandemic, medical colleges resorted to e-learning to continue teaching;
giving us a unique opportunity to explore the potential of this tool, understand the student perspective, help improve
its structure and assess its scope for future use.
Methods: A quantitative cross-sectional study was conducted across Indian medical colleges using Google forms.
The questionnaire consisted of sections on e-learning experience, technological readiness, effects of COVID-19 on
education and attitude towards e-learning.
Results: From 32 medical colleges in India, 556 undergraduate medical students participated in the study. The results
showed that 93.3% students were exposed to e-learning, from which 99% were introduced to it following the COVID-
19 pandemic-imposed lockdown. The study reported the pros and cons of e-learning for medical education. E-
learning methods were deemed fit for theory lectures, but wasn’t preferred for clinics and demonstrations. Students
believed that e-learning- preferably short live online classes, together with efficient portals, provision of offline
videos and discussion of clinical cases- had great scope to support the traditional methods of teaching.
Conclusions: According to the students, e-learning has immense potential and is an irreplaceable ally to the
traditional method of medical education, even beyond the COVID-19 pandemic.
International Journal of Community Medicine and Public Health | September 2020 | Vol 7 | Issue 9 Page 3610
Lawande NN et al. Int J Community Med Public Health. 2020 Sep;7(9):3610-3616
with occasional presence and with e-communication For this study, we define e-learning as a technology-based
(hybrid-asynchronous learning); and (6) e-learning with learning in which a computer network is used to deliver
physical presence and with e-communication (hybrid- learning material (via audio, video and text medium)
synchronous learning).7 electronically to remote learners. This can be done
through e-mail, live chat sessions, online discussions,
The COVID-19 pandemic has led to the introduction of forums, quizzes and assignments.8,9
various e-learning tools in medical colleges, and has also
provided us with a unique opportunity to study the A separate questionnaire was given to students whose
challenges and sustainability of this method and evaluate colleges hadn't started online classes, to identify the
its role in medical education much beyond the pandemic. challenges they felt their colleges were facing, amidst the
Medical education is constantly growing at a rapid speed COVID-19 crisis.
and knowing the scope of technology-based learning,
beyond the pandemic, will be essential to keep the Indian The data obtained from Google forms, was quantitatively
medical graduates at par with the competitive world.4-6 analysed.
International Journal of Community Medicine and Public Health | September 2020 | Vol 7 | Issue 9 Page 3611
Lawande NN et al. Int J Community Med Public Health. 2020 Sep;7(9):3610-3616
had classes both in the morning and afternoon. While Among the students, 42% (218) said that
73.2% (380) preferred classes in the morning, 17% (88) assignments/projects/homework were given. Out of these,
preferred afternoon classes and 18% (52) did not have 21.9% (80) preferred if homework/projects/assignments
any preference for the timing of the e-class. were given, 51.1% (187) did not, while 27% (99) were
indecisive.
Where 74.6% (388) students had classes for an average of
30 minutes-1 hour, 20.6% (107) had them for 1 hour-2 Clinical skills were considered as an important part of
hours, 3.8% (20) had them for more than 2 hours and 1% their study in the medical curriculum by 98.1% (509) of
(5) had them for less than 30 minutes. The preferred the students. Among the students, 94.4% (490) found it
duration was 30 minutes-1 hour for 77.1% (401) of the difficult to study the subject without direct patient
students, less than 30 minutes for 9.4% (49), 1hour- exposure. Of the participants, 52.4% (272) had a clinical
2hours for 8.5% (44) and 4.6% (24) did not have any case discussion for their lectures.
preference.
International Journal of Community Medicine and Public Health | September 2020 | Vol 7 | Issue 9 Page 3612
Lawande NN et al. Int J Community Med Public Health. 2020 Sep;7(9):3610-3616
learning. Among the participants, 43.9% (228) faced Students felt that improvement in audio-visual software,
distractions during online classes, 18.5% (96) did not and inclusion of clinical discussions, adding more student-
37.6% (195) were not sure. While 48.3% (212) of the teacher interactive sessions, and solving existing network
distractions were avoidable, 17.3 % (76) were not and issues would better the quality of e-learning in the future.
34.4% (151) of the students were unsure. Among the The subjective preference of the students for the use of e-
students 47.5% (223) felt that scrolling through social learning methods for various types of medical classes is
media/ talking to people during online lectures was a given in Figure 3.
cause of their decreased concentration.
Technological readiness
International Journal of Community Medicine and Public Health | September 2020 | Vol 7 | Issue 9 Page 3613
Lawande NN et al. Int J Community Med Public Health. 2020 Sep;7(9):3610-3616
time students complained of missing out on attendance maintenance of even the most current and sophisticated
due to the poor network. software, the ability of teachers and students to access
and use technology is highly compromised.21 Organising
Classic lectures can be improved by increasing student- training workshops for students as well as teachers
teacher interaction.15,16 In an online set up, this could be regularly, to improve their technological skills and be at
done via polls, quizzes, tests and other interactive par with updates in software is a solution. Also, usage of
sessions. Use of e-learning modules (flash multimedia a single, safe and effective software by all medical
and digitized images), patient surrogates such as virtual institutions in India, would standardise the training
patients (to teach clinical examination, procedural, programs which need to be given to students and
diagnostic skills and communication skills) and virtual- teachers.
reality simulators (to teach palpation, surgical and
resuscitation skills) is needed.3 A common drawback identified by a majority of the
participants (79%) was loss of connection during classes
Live online classes were chosen over pre-recorded due to poor or unstable network availability and
classes, perhaps due to it being more engaging and disruption in the flow of the lecture. This obstacle can be
interactive.17 Many (80.1%) were in favour of classes overcome by recording the lectures and providing them to
being recorded and sent, post a live session. A good the students through various social platforms. Another
approach to see that the classes missed can be referred solution to this would be provision of alternate means of
back, and that important topics can be reviewed when attending these lectures, for example through a ‘call in’
required, would be to ensure that a system is in place for means for joining and attending classes in audio only
recorded live classes to be sent in a timely manner daily mode. An innovative and effective solution would be
or weekly. development of e-learning software that function
smoothly even at low bandwidths.22
The students had their doubts cleared by the teacher
during class, or in a separate doubt-resolving session, or A recent survey by Uma V stated that 40% of the
by direct contact with the teacher through email, which concerns about online education were related to
should be encouraged as it is a good way to assure better unreliable connectivity, 30% cited the cost of data and
understanding in class. Though many students did not 10% reported uncertainty in electrical supply.23 Only 28%
receive any homework assignments, a study conducted by of the students belonging to rural households had access
Ahsan et al stated that introducing a simple pre-lecture to the internet at home.24 Such issues need to be worked
assignment (PLA) before the lecture will help make on, to extend the reach of e-learning to rural population as
classes more student-centred and focused more toward well.
active learning.18 Preparing for a lecture beforehand, puts
a student in a better place to understand and gather The medical field calls for students to have a great deal of
information taught in class, which promotes in-depth social soft skills in order to win the trust of patients and
learning.19 ace the art of medicine. The lack of patient exposure and
clinical cases creates a great void in medical learning,
Although the pace of the lectures was found to be which seemed to be one major setback for e-learning,
adequate, only 15.8% reported that they could concentrate causing students to prefer the traditional method of
through the whole class, while 60% of the respondents in classes. While e-learning was considered unsuitable for
this study could not concentrate beyond 30 minutes and practical classes and demonstrations, it was considered a
felt it would be more effective if the duration of the great method to teach theory classes and case discussions.
classes was reduced. A study on concentration of medical
students by Stuart and Rutherford showed similar results This gap in the clinical sphere of e-learning can be met by
where student concentration rose sharply to reach a introducing innovative ideas like purely holding clinical
maximum in 10-15 minutes, and fell steadily thereafter.20 case discussions in a separate interactive class, or
The study also stated that the optimum length of a lecture integrating these discussions while teaching certain topics
may be 30 minutes instead of 60 minutes. Technical could help increase clinical interest and diagnostic skills.
issues and lack of interaction were an important hurdle in In addition, separate video clips demonstrating basic
the flow of the lecture, causing preference of offline clinical skills, such as clinical procedures and physical
classes with respect to better concentration. Decreasing examination skills could be streamed live or sent pre-
the length of the lecture or providing breaks between the recorded. This could be used as a supplementary learning
sessions; making offline videos of the live lecture resource to help students master clinical skills. 25 The
available to all students and trying to make the sessions online lecture sessions allowed students to attend classes
more interactive, as mentioned above, are solutions, in in their own comfort zones, make better notes with the
order to ensure better concentration of the students. audio-visual aids, address their queries more freely and
also avoid the travel hassles.
Difficulty in operating the software through which online
classes were held was a complaint reported by 22.1% of A study conducted by Rose S established that reduced
the students. In the absence of proper support and student-student discussions, dependence on emails and
International Journal of Community Medicine and Public Health | September 2020 | Vol 7 | Issue 9 Page 3614
Lawande NN et al. Int J Community Med Public Health. 2020 Sep;7(9):3610-3616
internet facilities and a difficulty in delineating Dean of Goa Medical College, Prof. Dr. S. M. Bandekar
boundaries between home and work were some of the for giving us the opportunity to conduct this study.
pitfalls of online education that needed to be worked on.26
We would also like to thank Dr. Aadishree Kenkre for
Though most of the institutes of the participants in the being our constant support during this project. Finally, we
study, had rapidly converted their entire preclinical would like to thank all the participants who gave us their
curriculum to online formats, some of them were still valuable time to be a part of this study.
unable to initiate this transition due to lack of
infrastructure and technological awareness, especially Funding: No funding sources
when a large part of the medical fraternity had been Conflict of interest: None declared
redirected to fight the COVID-19 pandemic.3 Ethical approval: Approval granted by the Institutional
Ethics Committee of Goa Medical College, Bambolim,
Most of these students looked forward to e-learning and Goa, India
believed it to be useful. There is a need for training the
students as well as the medical faculty in conducting e REFERENCES
classes and the use of technology to its full potential.
Overcoming the technical problems, by providing a portal 1. WHO. WHO announces COVID-19 outbreak a
that is more convenient for both, the teachers as well as pandemic, 2020. Available at:
all students; and using this platform to provide more https://www.euro.who.int/en/health-topics/health-
videos, offline recorded lectures, and clinical cases to the emergencies/coronavirus-covid-
students, will allow institutions to adapt to this new form 19/news/news/2020/3/who-announces-covid-19-
of education, and to accept it as an important ally to the outbreak-a-
traditional face to face mode of education. pandemic#:~:text=The%20meeting%20follows%20t
he%20announcement. Accessed on 18 June 2020.
Limitations of this study include an inability to achieve a 2. MoHFW. India: Ministry of Health and Family
larger sample size and a wider representation of the Welfare, 2020. Available at: http://mohfw.gov.in.
medical colleges in India, due to difficulty in reaching out Accessed on 19 June 2020.
to medical students across India amidst this COVID-19 3. Sahi PK, Mishra D, Singh T. Medical education
lockdown. amid the COVID-19 pandemic. Indian Pediatr.
2020. Available at:
CONCLUSION https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32412913/.
4. Ruiz JG, Mintzer MJ, Leipzig MR. The impact of e-
In conclusion, this study showed that e-learning is an learning in medical education. Acad Med.
effective tool that can augment the medical student 2006;81(3):207-12.
learning experience in India. Students can watch the 5. Unnikrishnan B, Kulshrestha V, Saraf A, Agrahari
recorded online classes- that could range from theory AC, Prakash S, Samantaray L, et al. Pattern of
lectures to clinical skills demonstrations and utilize them computer and internet use among medical students
for further reference. By overcoming the setbacks that in coastal South India. South East Asian J Med
challenge its implementation, it can be used as a means to Educ. 2008;2(2):18-25.
supplement traditional teaching methods even beyond the 6. Virtanen JI, Nieminen P. Information and
COVID-19 pandemic. communication technology among undergraduate
dental students in Finland. Eur J Dent Educ.
Scope for further research 2002;6(1):147-52.
7. Negash S, Wilcox MV. E-learning classifications:
differences and similarities. In: handbook of
Further research could be conducted to gather the
distance learning for real-time and asynchronous
opinions of the teaching faculty and conducting research
information technology education. London:
on development of more efficient software for e-learning
Information Science Reference (an imprint of IGI
by getting inputs from IT engineers will further help us
Global); 2008:1-23.
get better insight and explore e-learning to its full
8. Abdullah F, Ward R. Developing a General
potential. A qualitative study would also be helpful to
Extended Technology Acceptance Model for E-
understand the issues of individual colleges and would
Learning (GETAMEL) by analysing commonly
give a better insight on the pros and cons of this method
used external factors. Computers Hum Behav.
and the means to overcome the barriers to use this method
2016;56:238-56.
effectively.
9. Zhang D, Zhao JL, Zhou L, Nunamaker Jr JF. Can
e-learning replace classroom learning? Commun
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
ACM. 2004;47(5):75-9.
10. ICMR. National Guidelines for Ethics Committees
We would like to thank the Institutional Ethics Reviewing Biomedical andnd Health Research,
Committee, Goa Medical College, Goa, India and the 2020. India: Indian Council of Medical Research.
International Journal of Community Medicine and Public Health | September 2020 | Vol 7 | Issue 9 Page 3615
Lawande NN et al. Int J Community Med Public Health. 2020 Sep;7(9):3610-3616
International Journal of Community Medicine and Public Health | September 2020 | Vol 7 | Issue 9 Page 3616