Service Letter SL2022-726/KNB

Action code: WHEN CONVENIENT

Service experience with

2020-compliant fuels
Fuel equipment

SL2022-726/KNB
July 2022
Dear Sir or Madam
Concerns
With the introduction of the global sulphur emission cap enforced Owners and operators of MAN B&W
worldwide since January 2020, the shipping industry has seen two-stroke marine combustion engines.
various new heavy fuel oil types, blends, and distillates for the Type: All MAN B&W engines.
marine market (in the following referred to as “fuel oils”).

Although MAN Energy Solutions assumed that new fuel oils could Summary
lead to failures, we have seen neither a significant nor a general This Service Letter focuses on the
increase in failing fuel injection equipment in service by the end of issues reported and observed in
2021. service and describes how to manage
the downside effects.
However, we have received reports of a few incidents that have
raised our awareness and, at present, we cannot exclude that new Some of the effects introduced with
fuel oils, or new fuel oils in combination with ship operation, are 2020-compliant fuels, and which can
affected by the introduction of the low-sulphur cap. influence the operation of main engine
fuel equipment, are:
One particular challenge with the operation on new fuels is to ensure
that fuel oil quality and specification complies with the engine – Low viscosity
specification at any time. The following pages offer some guidance – Cavitation
and recommendations based on our observations over the past – Time between overhaul (TBO)
years.
Other relevant Service Letters:
If you have any questions or inquiries regarding this Service Letter, SL2009-515
contact our Operation Department at Operation2S@man-es.com SL2014-593
SL2019-670
SL2019-681
Yours faithfully

Mikael C Jensen Stig B Jakobsen

Vice President Senior Manager
Engineering Operation

Head office (& po. address) PrimeServ Production Forwarding & Receiving MAN Energy Solutions
MAN Energy Solutions Teglholmsgade 41 Teglholmsgade 35 Teglholmsgade 35 Branch of MAN Energy Solutions
Teglholmsgade 41 2450 Copenhagen SV 2450 Copenhagen SV 2450 Copenhagen SV SE, Germany
2450 Copenhagen SV Denmark Denmark Denmark CVR No.: 31611792
Denmark Phone: +45 33 85 11 00 Phone: +45 33 85 11 00 Phone: +45 33 85 11 00 Head office: Teglholmsgade 41
Phone: +45 33 85 11 00 Fax: +45 33 85 10 49 Fax: +45 33 85 10 17 Fax: +45 33 85 10 16 2450 Copenhagen SV, Denmark
Fax: +45 33 85 10 30 PrimeServ-cph@man-es.com manufacturing-dk@man-es.com shipping-cph@man-es.com German Reg.No.: HRB 22056
info-cph@man-es.com Amtsgericht Augsburg
www.man-es.com
Service Letter SL2022-726/KNB

Contents

Low viscosity.......................................................................2
Fuel atomising nozzles..................................................2
Cavitation.............................................................................3
High-pressure pipes.....................................................3
Fuel pump – fuel booster..............................................3
Plug screw in top cover/distributor block.....................3
Fuel valve.......................................................................5
Fuel valve spring housing....................................................8
Fuel oil circulation system...................................................9
Summary & closing remarks..............................................13
Design update.............................................................13
Recommendations......................................................13

In the following, we present some of the effects higher Mark number due to the higher efficiency.
introduced with 2020-compliant fuels. The first The reason why this has become an issue is related to the
section (p. 2) adresses low-viscosity-related issues, higher delta temperature between the max. temperature
the second section (pp. 3-8) looks at cavitation in fuel for the nozzle during combustion and the cooling effect
equipment, and the last section (pp. 9-13) gives from the injected fuel.
guidelines on how to prevent cavitation by ensuring
correct adjustment of pressure regulating valves in HFO typically has a temperature of 130 to 140 degrees
the fuel supply system. Celsius whereas the fuels of today may have a viscosity
that does not require heating. On the contrary, some new
fuel types may need to be cooled in order to ensure a mini-
Low viscosity mum of 2 cSt at engine inlet.

Handling of low-viscosity fuel oil on board can be a In some cases, this increased temperature difference may
challenge when taking into account that the main engine challenge the lifetime of the nozzle and thus reduce the
requires min. 2 cSt. Sometimes it may be necessary to specified time between overhaul (TBO).
cool the fuel oil.

It is well known that cavitation is more prone to occur in

very low viscosity fluids, and it is therefore important that
fuel oil treatment system operation can match the specific
fuel in use. Special attention must be paid to change-over
scenarios where improper operation of the fuel oil
treatment system can lead to unintended high fuel oil
temperatures and, consequently, very low viscosities. The
fuel oil condition met by the main engine must always
comply with MAN Energy Solutions specifications,
according to ISO 8217.

This was addressed in our service letter SL2009-515

issued in 2009, and we recommend revisiting this service
letter and pay special attention to the recommendations.

Fuel atomising nozzles

Some vessels have reported cracks in fuel nozzles after
switching to a 2020-compliant fuel. Fig. 1 shows a nozzle
tip with a crack. This is most dominant for engines of Fig. 1: Crack found on the tip of a nozzle

Service experience with 2020-compliant fuels. Page 2 of 13

Service Letter SL2022-726/KNB

Cavitation However, it cannot be excluded that the cavitation was

initiated only by the use of new fuel oils.
In general, cavitation can occur in both the high-pressure
pipes from the fuel booster to the fuel valve and internally If the high-pressure pipe cone suffers severe cavitation
in the fuel valves. Fig. 4 shows an overview of the fuel damage that leads to a high-pressure fuel oil leakage and,
equipment investigated. therefore, erosion damage, this may ultimately lead to
damage on the top cover mating surface between the top
We recommend inspecting the fuel equipment when cover and the high-pressure pipe.
convenient within the next 12 months. This is particular
important if the new fuel oils used on board since 2020 Fuel pump – fuel booster
have different characteristics compared to the fuel oils Cavitation damage has not been reported for the fuel
used prior to 2020. pump or fuel booster, see Fig. 4.

In the following, various examples of cavitation are shown Plug screw in top cover/distributor block
and described. Crack formation around the plug screw in the top cover
has been reported in a few cases. The root cause has
High-pressure pipes been identified to be a loose plug behind the plug screw.
We have received a few reports of cavitation in the
high-pressure pipes for engines operating only or mainly The loose plug would “hammer” against the plug screw at
on distillate or ULSFO, see Fig. 3. every injection, and thus stress the threads in the top
cover and initiate a crack at the thread in the top cover.
The same observation has been made for engines which Cavitation on the plug may lead to loose plugs.
operated on HFO until the introduction of the global
sulphur emission cap enforced since January 2020. A repair kit consisting of new plugs and tools for
overhauling the mating seat in the top cover can be
In most cases, the pipe cavitation seems to have ordered from PrimeServ, see Fig. 5.
progressed slowly and is often detected when
overhauling/exchanging the fuel valves.

Fig. 2: Inspection of the high-pressure pipe end/seat reveals a Fig. 3: An endoscope was used to inspect for damage inside the
crack – no special equipment required high-pressure pipe

Service experience with 2020-compliant fuels. Page 3 of 13

Service Letter SL2022-726/KNB

Fuel valve

High-pressure
pipe

204
216 289

182
194 253
Fuel pump - fuel 265

booster

277
Plug screw in the
top cover
228
241

Fig. 4: Fuel injection equipment

Top cover plate Crack indication Cross section Plug Repair kit

Fig. 5: Crack indication around the plug screw in the top cover, top cover plate and repair kit

Service experience with 2020-compliant fuels. Page 4 of 13

Service Letter SL2022-726/KNB

Fuel valve

4
3
1

6
7

Fig. 6: 1. Spindle guide 2. Foot 3. Shim 4. Spring 5. Thrust spindle pipe 6. Non-return valve 7. Fuel valve head 8. Holder/body

Fuel injection valves may also show signs of cavitation on

the internal parts shown in Fig. 6, and as illustraded in
Figs. 7–17.

Fuel valve head (pos. 7)

Cavitation has been found inside the fuel valve head, see
Figs. 7 and 8.

Fig. 7: Cavitation found inside fuel valve head – towards Fig. 8: Close-up of cavitation damage
non-return valve

Service experience with 2020-compliant fuels. Page 5 of 13

Service Letter SL2022-726/KNB

Non-return valve (pos. 6) Thrust spindle pipe (pos.5)

For quite some years now, the standard design on our Cavitation has been reported on the mating face at the top
medium and small-bore engines (50, 60 and 70 bores) has position towards the non-return valve, especially for 80, 90
been a type where the non-return valve and thrust spindle and 95-bore engine fuel valves, see Fig. 12. In severe
pipe are designed as one unit. This design has shown cases, the cavitation will intersect the circular sealing area
clear superiority over the two-part design used on our and bypass the injection pressure. Cavitation occurs also
large-bore engines. For this reason, we have introduced a in more rare cases at the lower end, see Fig. 13.
similar one-unit type and tested it for 8,000 hours of
service on a G95ME-C engine, and the results were very We have not received any reports of cavitation at this lower
promising, see Fig. 9. end position for 50, 60 and 70-bore engine designs.

Whereas cavitation is rarely found on the upper end of the

non-return valve (Fig. 10), cavitation has been found on the
lower end (Fig. 11).

Fig. 9: Non-return valve and thrust spindle pipe vs. combined non-return valve and thrust spindle pipe

Fig. 10: Cavitation is rarely found at upper end of the non-return Fig. 11: Close-up of cavitation damage found at lower end of
valve – towards the fuel valve head – here found in fully functional non-return valve – towards thrust spindle pipe
condition without cavitation

Service experience with 2020-compliant fuels. Page 6 of 13

Service Letter SL2022-726/KNB

Spring (pos. 4)
In a few cases, cavitation has been found on the inner
diameter of the spring coils, see Fig. 14. Cavitation marks
might also be found on the thrust spindle pipe, see Fig. 15.

This type of cavitation occurs when the circulation

pressure is too low for the fuel circulating loop, and it is
mainly related to an incorrect pressure setting or a worn
out “pressure holding valve”.

Fig. 12: Cavitation found on upper end of thrust spindle pipe

– towards non-return valve

Fig. 14: Cavitation found on spring

Fig. 13: Cavitation found on lower end of thrust spindle pipe

– towards spindle guide

Countermeasure:
Introduction of the combined one-unit non-return valve for
the 80, 90 and 95-bore engines. Cavitation is avoided by
omitting of the mating sealing surfaces.
Fig. 15: Cavitation found similarly on cylindrical part of thrust
spindle pipe

Service experience with 2020-compliant fuels. Page 7 of 13

Service Letter SL2022-726/KNB

Spindle guide (pos. 1) Fuel valve spring housing

We have seen very few cases of cavitation on the spindle
guide. The cavitation has been found on the mating face The spring housing is a wear part that secures the correct
towards the thrust spindle pipe, see Fig. 16. In such cases, tightening force in the engine. If it is not up to acceptable
cavitation was also found on the position for the thrust standard, this may have a huge impact on the operation of
spindle pipe. Fig. 17 shows an example purely cometic the fuel valve and the lifetime of internal components.
cavitation.

Fig. 16: Cavitation found on thrust piece in spindle guide

Fig. 18: Spring housing

Fig. 17: Cavitation marks are considered to be merely cosmetic

Fuel valves must always be properly maintained and

correctly installed.

Service experience with 2020-compliant fuels. Page 8 of 13

Service Letter SL2022-726/KNB

Fuel oil circulation system

Correct supply and circulation pressures are important to ensure sufficient circulation of the fuel during engine
prevent cavitation in the fuel supply system. Fig. 19 shows standstill and to ensure a sufficient fuel flow during engine
a fuel oil system with highlighted pressure regulation operation.
valves.
More information about the pressure regulating valves and
Therefore, correct functioning and adjustment of pressure their adustment can be found in Table 1.
regulating valves in the fuel supply system is essential to

50 μm

50 μm 10 μm

50 μm 10 μm

Fig. 19: Fuel oil system

Service experience with 2020-compliant fuels. Page 9 of 13

Service Letter SL2022-726/KNB

Fuel oil supply pumps: Fig. 19.

Two screw pumps in parallel (one in standby mode)

An internal safety/bypass valve is built in (red circle) to prevent damage

to the pump housing.

Do not adjust this safety valve, as it is preset by the maker.

Make sure that it is set correctly according to maker’s specification.

Pressure regulating valve - Overflow valve: Fig. 19.

50 μm The valve
10 μm is a proportional type valve designed to measure the pressure

from the venting tank to the circulation pumps (but before heater/cooler,
etc.). A pressure
50 μm
of 4 bar must be obtained.
10 μm

Fuel oil circulation pumps: Fig. 19.

Two screw pumps in parallel (one in standby mode)

An internal safety/bypass valve is built in (red circle) to prevent damage

to the pump housing.

Do not adjust this safety valve, it is preset by the maker.

Make sure that it is set correctly according to maker’s specification –
typically 16 bar.

Pressure adjusting valve: Fig. 20.

The valve is a proportional type valve that will give a certain pressure
deviation from the setpoint throughout the load span of the engine.

Incorrect setting of the built-in safety valves in the supply/circulation

pump can lead to uncontrolled flow from outlet to inlet at the pump itself.

This may lead to fuel pressure pulsation in the circulating system as the
engine starts to consume fuel oil.

Table 1: Pressure regulating valves and adjustments

Service experience with 2020-compliant fuels. Page 10 of 13

Service Letter SL2022-726/KNB

Fig. 20 shows in more detail where the pressure adjusting

valve is located in the circulation system close to the engine
inlet. Furthermore, the figure gives the different settings
depending on engine type.

Fuel inlet to engine

from circulation
pump

Fuel return line to

venting tank:
4 bar for all engine
types

Fuel valve

Pressure adjusting valve:

MC/MC-C engines 7 - 8 bar
High pressure pipes ME/ME-C engines 8 - 10 bar

Fuel pump

VT
8004

Fig. 20: Fuel circulation on the engine

Service experience with 2020-compliant fuels. Page 11 of 13

Service Letter SL2022-726/KNB

Common fuel supply systems, covering both main engine overhaul. During this bypass, the overflow valve takes over
and gensets, may be more exposed to cavitation as it is the function of the internal overflow valve of the main
more difficult to ensure correct supply and circulation engine.
pressures at all times under all conditions.
During normal operation of main engine and gensets, the
Fig. 21 highlights item 10 between the inlet and outlet of shut-off valve in the bypass line (below item 10) must be
the main engine. The bypass line with overflow valve, item closed. Otherwise, the two overflow valves will be in series
10, serves the purpose of bypassing the main engine if, for and act against each other!
instance, the main engine fuel oil system needs a major

Fig. 21: Common fuel oil system for main engine and auxiliary engines

Service experience with 2020-compliant fuels. Page 12 of 13

Service Letter SL2022-726/KNB

Similarly, the common supply system for two main engines Summary & closing remarks
will be affected.
Design update
As shown in Table 2, we recommend keeping: As a countermeasure, the new combined non-return valve
– The supply pressure at 4 bar (must be measured at the with integrated spindle pipe will soon be introduced as a
string from the venting tank to cope with internal standard spare part for 80, 90 and 95-bore engines with
resistance from filters, viscorator, flowmeter, etc.) conventional fuel valves (interchangeable with the existing
– The circulation pressure as high as possible for the two-part design of the non-return valve and thrust spindle
engine type pipe).

Supply pressure Circulating pressure Recommendations

To minimise the impact of downside effects influencing the
4 bar ~10 bar
TBO, we recommend the following:
Measured at the string from As close to 10 bar as – At all times, the fuel oil condition met by the main
the venting tank possible for ME engine engine must comply with MAN Energy Solutions
types specifications, according to ISO 8217.
Table 2 – The operation of the fuel oil treatment system must
match the specific fuel in use.
Ensure that: – Keep focus on maintenance.
– The overflow valve at the supply loop works well and is – Maintain and ensure that the fuel supply and circulation
correctly maintained (in case of problems with the system is working properly.
function, consider exchanging the valve with a good – Carry out inspections for cavitation in the fuel system.
quality valve from an acknowledged supplier). – Consider introducing shorter inspection intervals.
– The pressure adjusting valve at the circulation loop for – Ensure that the necessary spare parts are available on
main engine works well and is correctly maintained and board.
adjusted.
For questions regarding spare parts, contact PrimeServ at
Primeserv-cph@man-es.com

Service experience with 2020-compliant fuels. Page 13 of 13