3 Centrcurvarticl
3 Centrcurvarticl
3 Centrcurvarticl
The Fundamentals
The eccentricity of an ellipse, defined by = c/a, indicates how much the curve is elongated in
contrast to a circle of the same height (2b), and the lower the value of , the more the curve
approaches a circle in fact, when c = 0, = 0 and the curve is a circle. In general, with conic
sections, < 1 gives an ellipse, = 1 gives a parabola, and > 1 a hyperbola. Thus the domain
of eccentricity for an ellipse is 0 < < 1, and since the mean value of between 0 and 1 is 1/2, it
follows that the majority of ellipses have an eccentricity 1/2 and a 2c.
The coefficient of compression or aspect ratio of an ellipse or pseudo-ellipse (n = b/a) is quite
distinct from the eccentricity and indicates the relation between the height and the width, (also
its flatness or roundness). Clearly, when b = a, the coefficient of 1 indicates a circle, and since b
and a are interchanged in a prolate form, the domain of this coefficient is 0 < n < 1.
A building in the form of a prolate semi-ellipsoid can be stood on a stilted (perfectly vertical)
ground floor for a more graceful form, or a prolongation of the ellipse with decreasing diameter,
like the iconic Swiss Re gherkin tower (30 St Mary Axe, London) of Arup/Norman Foster +
Associates. Curiously, although prolate semi-elliptic forms existed in Persia and the onion shape
was common in the East, this prolate form was rarely adopted in the West for arches or domes
in previous centuries. It doesnt require any more roof height than a 2-centered Gothic arch, but
perhaps its because an ellipse requires a constantly changing radius that makes it hard to
realize. For most practical purposes though, with or without todays computing power, a close
approximation to an ellipse can be realized quite simply with only 2 different radii. Of course, the
specific focusing properties of a real elliptic curve are not to be found in a 3-centered arc, so the
latter should not be used if a focusing surface is required for reflected sound or light.
There are many ways of drawing a close approximation to an ellipse1, and some of them (e.g.
with 5 centers) are as complicated as drawing a true ellipse or are limited in eccentricity. A
pseudo-ellipse can be drawn from a 2-centered arc where b = c and R = 2b (or r = c = 1/2a = 3/4b
and R = 2b as in the Achaemenid cupolas2), but a better-known method of drawing one is often
employed to represent a circle in isometric projection (Fig. 2a). This is drawn in an isometric
rhombus and is known as the Stevens method, but it imposes a curve where b = c only.
Two circles are drawn with radius r of 1/4 the required major axis or span width, in such a way
that they meet at the centerline. Two tangents are drawn at any angle (e.g. 45, 30 or 60, as
you like) to meet the centerline at point O, giving the center of the circle with radius R that
completes the top part of the pseudo-ellipse. The 30 example also shows another method of
drawing such a curve as the central triangle joining the three foci is equilateral, and the lower
points of intersection of the center circle intersect the other two circles in line with O T and OT.
It may be observed that the centers of the minor and major arcs are located on the axes. In
addition, the points of tangency T and T' are the points of change of center of curvature
common to both minor radius arc and major radius arc; the normal at each of these points is
thus in line with both their centers. Whilst this method is normally used for an eccentricity of 1/2
(since c = r), it does allow us to move to a general case where b, c and r are independent.
Moreover, it shows how the pseudo-elliptic curve changes with different aspect ratios, even
with the same eccentricity; and as a corollary the inverse is also true, since different eccentricities are possible with the same aspect ratioin contrast with a true ellipse. Assuming a
constant minor axis, any change in the eccentricity of a true ellipse requires a change in the
major axis thus changing the aspect ratio, whereas a change in the eccentricity of a pseudoellipse can be done without a change in the major axis or the aspect ratio. And a major
problem for an architect with defining a 3-centered arch is that there are so many variables. If
you disregard the height to the spring line and extrapolations like the eccentricity and aspect
ratio, there are 5 in all: a, b, c, r and R. So the first thing to do is to eliminate some of the
unknown parameters by giving them known or assumed values. Assuming construction of an
oblate arch, for example, the span width and possibly the rise height are often given in building
constraints. In the event there is some doubt about the rise height, the architect or his client
usually has an idea of how rounded or flattened the arch should be, in particular with regard to
the ceiling or roof height. So even if you only have the span width (2a), you can work out the
rise height from the desired coefficient of compression or aspect ratio (b/a), bearing in mind the
need for a common rise height if several arches are contiguous. Fortunately, this can be done
graphically for an oblate or prolate ellipse with a computer drawing tool (e.g. PowerPoint,
Illustrator or Photoshop etc.), by flattening a circle to the required height and width.
You then have the choice of deciding either on a value for the eccentricity, or choosing the
value of the minor radius. If you have decided on the aspect ratio and drawn the equivalent
ellipse in the step above, you will have a good idea of what the curve is to look like since the
difference between the equivalent ellipse and the 3-centered curve is so slight. But this doesnt
indicate the eccentricity required, which is linked with the focal separation (c = .a). In general,
the smaller the eccentricity (or focal separation compared with the half-span) the more
rounded is the curve, and thus more suited, in the oblate form of an arch, to an opening that is
not wide (but this does not apply for the prolate form, assuming you have free rein with the
height). For spans of 120 cm or less, a semicircular arch is usually best ( = 0; c = 0) since the
rise height is only 60 cm; for spans up to 2.2 m a well-rounded ellipse goes well (0 < < 1/2;
0 < c < r); for spans of about 2.4 m the semi-rounded curve of the above diagram 2b ( = 1/2;
c = r) fits well; and for spans of 2.5 m or greater, the curve should be duly elongated without
changing the rise height (1 > > 1/2; c > r). It may help to make an assumption for the focal
separation c in terms of a multiple of the minor radius, r ; you can thus use a curve with a
known eccentricity and aspect ratio that satisfies your aesthetic requirements for various span
widths. In addition, you can easily calculate several possible scenarios, as a spreadsheet with
the following formulas makes this so simple. And, with experience, it becomes clear for which
spans you should use which eccentricity and aspect ratio to give the desired harmonious curve
to an arc, which arent necessarily those of the rough guidelines given above, especially if your
assumptions are different or youre considering a roof or prolate form.
Calculating the Unknown Parameters
For the sake of simplicity, we shall just look at the case of an oblate arc, but the calculations
are obviously the same with a prolate form. When the parameters a, b, c (as well as , given by
c/a, and the coefficient of compression given by the ratio b/a) have been decided upon, only
the minor and major radii remain to be determined, and this is what we shall calculate here.
However, the choice of the minor radius is also a leveraged factor in differentiating an arch or
prolate pseudo-ellipsoid in terms of general roundness or flatness, especially in case you wish
to clearly distinguish it from a true ellipse, but the calculations are much the same.
In Fig. 3, applying the Pythagorean theorem to the right triangle OMF or OMF gives:
.
(R - r)2 = (R - b)2 + c2 ; . . R2 2Rr + r2 = R2 2Rb + b2 + c2, or 2R(b r) = b2 + c2 - r2 ;
.
. . the major radius R = b2 + c2 - r2 (II)
2(b - r)
You may note that the term (b r) in the second equation implies that the relation between the
rise height and the minor radius greatly affects the major radius or flatness/roundness of the top
part of the curve: firstly, r cannot be greater than b (and should be much less than b for a wellrounded top curve), and when r = b you get a flat-topped, or pseudo-3-centered curve (R ).
On the other hand, b cannot be greater than R since this gives a prolate curve where b and a
are interchanged (since the foci of an ellipse are always on the major axis), and when b = R you
get a circle.
Example 1 ( < 1/2; c < r)
.
Span 2a = 220 cm; . . a = 110 cm.
Rise height b = 71 cm (i.e. aspect ratio b/a required = 0.645)
.
Focal separation 2c = 1 3/4r (or required = 0.4667); . . c = 7/8 r.
Given:
Assumed:
.
From equation (I) r = 110 7/8 r ; r(1 + 7/8) = 110 ; . . r = 110 x 8 = 58.67 cm
15
From equation (II) R = 712 + (7/8 r)2 - r2 = 712 - r2(1 - 49/64) = 5041 - (3441.8 x 15/64)
2(71 58.67)
2 x 12,33
24.67
.
24.67
Example 2 ( = 1/2; c = r)
.
Span 2a = 240 cm; . . a = 120 cm.
Rise height b = 72 cm (i.e. aspect ratio required = 0.6)
Focal separation 2c = 2r (since eccentricity required = 0.5).
Given:
Assumed:
.
From equation (I) r = 120 r ; 2r = 120 ; . . r = 60 cm.
Given:
Assumed:
.
Focal separation 2c = 4 1/4r (or eccentricity required = 0.68); . . c = 17/8 r.
. . R = 16650
= 438.16 cm.
38
Fortunately the calculations can be checked before being set in concrete, since scale drawings
will immediately show up any mistakes; the tangents of the minor-radius curve and the majorradius curve only coincide at T and T if the calculations are correct.
An interesting point about these solutions is that once you have found the curve you like, and
consequently the radii for a given eccentricity and aspect ratio, then re-dimensioning to any
size with that same eccentricity and aspect ratio is a piece of cake since you can scale the
basic parameters (a, b, c, r and R) in geometric proportion. On the other hand, if you want an
even margin around a pseudo-elliptical arch, or to make a pseudo-elliptical staircase, you can
simply use the same centers with both radii increased arithmetically by the width of the margin
or stairs. In this latter case the eccentricity and aspect ratio will be different for the inside and
outside curves, but the margin or stair width remains constant.
If you are converting an existing semicircular arch into a (narrower and shallower) 3-centered
arch, in this case you can assume values for b and r (R > b > r), assuming R is unchanged;
then it only remains to find the value of c and a. By rearranging equation II,
..
.
. 2R(b r) = b2 + c2 - r2 ; . . c2 = r2 - b2 + 2R(b r), or c = {r2 - b2 + 2R(b r)} ;
and, from equation I, a = c + r.
In the event you want to go beyond the purity and rigidity of late Modernism, you can adopt an
asymmetry like in the form of an egg. In this case you can assume values for b and R, then the
calculation of the pseudo-ellipse form for each side would be a matter of choosing either a
different value for r for each side (from which you can calculate the different values for a and c
using the formulae of the above paragraph), or a different value for a for each side from which
you can calculate the different values for c and r as follows:
..
.
. 2R(b r) = b2 + c2 - r2 and substituting for r = a c . . 2R(b a + c) = b2 + c2 (a c) 2
.
.
. . 2Rb 2Ra + 2Rc = b2 + c2 a2 + 2ac - c2 . . 2Rc - 2ac = b2 a2 + 2Ra 2Rb
.
.
. . 2c(R a) = b2 a2 + 2R(a b) . . c = b2 a2 + 2R(a b)
2(R a)
and, from equation I, r = a - c.
However, making the formwork requires exact knowledge of where T and T are located. Once
you have found the curve you like and know the radii (r and R), the precise location of these
tangent points can be determined by trigonometry, as follows:
with two radii to make an oblate or prolate pseudo-semi-ellipsoid, either using steel or
concrete, and offering column-free floor space as well as bending and shear rigidity.
indicating the ratio c : R-b or tan . In the example shown in Fig. 8, this ratio coincides with a
pitch of 3 : 4 (tan = 0.75), since it is an oblate Achaemenid curve very close to a true
ellipse and clearly designed with a 3/4/5 triangle3 in an orgy of harmonious ratios of 1: 2, 2 : 3
and 3 : 4 usually attributed to Pythagoras lending itself naturally to this pitch of roof and
giving an abundance of round figures in the calculations (see appendices I and II, where
round figures in the calculations are retained as much as possible). However, the same can
be done for any pitch of roof, e.g. the more common 1 : 2 where tan = 0.5 and the tangent
point is nearer the center of the quadrant, but its coordinates l and d are not round figures.
In many cases an external dome is mounted above an interior dome, in which case the above
truss of Fig. 8 can be combined with that of Fig. 6.
Conclusion
In response to growing demand for making 3-centered arches, this paper has been extended
in scope. In addition to demonstrating a simple formula for calculating the radii of any threecentered arc, several examples are given of real-life cases for those who wish to make
arches, vaults or domes for interior or exterior applications.
1
Browning, Hugh C. The Principles of Architectural Drafting: a Sourcebook of Techniques and Graphic Standards.
Watson-Guptill Publications, New York 1996.
2
3
Dieulafoy, Marcel. LArt antique de la Perse, IV: Les monuments vots de lpoque achmnide. Paris 1884-89.
Le Corbusier. Vers une Architecture. Editions Crs, Paris 1923.
Arch building with radiating voussoirs was known from 3000 B.C. and in Mesopotamia and Persia,
at least up to the middle of the 6th century B.C. (before the influences of Egypt and Greece),
architecture was essentially arcuated, using sun-dried or kiln-fired bricks due to the lack of timber
and building stone. We also have many examples to prove that arcs were not always semicircular,
and it was probably understood that the arcs that best withstood earthquakes and the passage of
time were those extended vertically in what we would today call a quasi-catenary form. It is
doubtful that a true catenary or even a true ellipse could be made at that time, but making a threecentered curve was perfectly feasible. And, over the years, it is probable that they hit upon a way
of drawing a three-centered arc from a rectangle and triangle with dimensions based on small
whole numbers.
From evidence such as the clay Babylonian tablet known as Plimpton
it has
become
clear that
Fig.322
8 The
pitch
of the roof
should
that
of the
some trigonometry and especially the 3/4/5 right triangle were known
fromcoincide
aroundwith
1800
B.C.
And
common the
tangent
of the 3-centered
while it carries no historical weight; it is not surprising that Euclid attributed
invention
of what
curve to simplify truss design.
we now know as the theorem of Pythagoras to one of his own, although Pythagoras of Samos,
who lived at the time of Cyrus, made no claim to this invention. Moreover, triangulation in Greek
roofs did not appear before the 3rd century B.C., and since the Greeks had plenty of building stone
and timber, and their architecture was thus columnar and trabeated, it is more likely that the
necessity for arcuated building applications was the mother of this invention, in Mesopotamia or
Persia rather than in Greece.
Experience with the calculation of numerous 3-centered arcs shows that the only format that
systematically gives round figures (even to the coordinates l and d of the common tangent point)
occurs when the internal triangle is of the form 3/4/5 (tan = 3/4 or 4/3). The most harmonious of
these is the curve called Achaemenid in the text. This curve is very near to a real ellipse, with the
ratios r/c = 1 and b/R-b = 1, and is suitable for spans up to about 2.5 meters or roof height.
10
Drawing the Achaemenid 3-centered curve is simply a matter of starting with a rectangle ABCD,
6 x 4 units (or multiples thereof) divided into four quarters and then making a diagonal from a top
corner to the mid point at the bottom so as to cut the major axis at F. Each point F is the center of
the minor curve, radius 3/2, while O is the center of the major curve, radius 4. Note that the
triangle AEO is also 3/4/5.
The coordinates of the common tangent at T are 1.2 and 2.4 units respectively from the major
and minor axes.
It can be assumed that many other formats were tried before the above curve was retained to
meet the constraints of oblate cupolas. And since the easier a curve is to draw, the easier it is to
fabricate on a building site, other formats with tan = 3/4 must have been looked at, including
r/c = 1/3 with b/R-b = 1/2; or r/c = 1/2 with b/R-b = 5/8; or r/c = 2/3 with b/R-b = 3/4; and with
tan = 4/3 an example is r/c = 1 with b/R-b = 2. All of these formats give round figures, but not
necessarily graceful curves.
The following figure is an example of a reasonably graceful curve that can be drawn with the
greatest simplicity. Based on a rectangle measuring 18 x 13, it offers an aspect ratio of 5/9, which
is slightly lower than the previous example, while the eccentricity is 2/3, i.e. slightly higher. As a
result, this format is suitable for wider spans that the previous example, say 2.5 to 3 meters
(e.g. 2.7m = 15 x 18cm).
11
This paper has shown a simple way to calculate the radii for any 3-centered arc, and the
following copy of a spreadsheet with these formulae gives examples of exact dimensions (as
much as possible with round figures) and the approximate appearance with an example for
each heading. If you need the freedom to try your own combinations of values any
spreadsheet, such as Microsoft Excel, can be programmed as required; but this can be quite
time-consuming which is why the following list has been made with as many examples as
days in a human gestation period (273).
Eccentricity
Coordinates of T
2a
Span
b
Rise
c
(= a - r)
r
minor
R
Aspect
Major
b/a
140.0
45.00
30.00
40.00
132.50
150.0
60.00
24.00
51.00
200.0
74.00
36.00
210.0
74.00
220.0
c/a
tan
(a
0.643
0.429
0.343
42.97
37.84
87.50
0.800
0.320
0.873
57.53
38.42
64.00
133.80
0.740
0.360
0.602
69.01
54.83
46.50
58.50
136.00
0.705
0.443
0.750
81.60
46.80
75.00
47.50
62.50
159.00
0.682
0.432
0.565
78.26
54.40
220.0
75.00
52.50
57.50
145.00
0.682
0.477
0.750
87.00
46.00
220.0
74.00
51.00
59.00
153.20
0.673
0.464
0.644
82.94
49.61
220.0
73.50
45.70
64.30
182.40
0.668
0.415
0.420
70.58
59.29
220.0
71.00
52.00
58.00
168.50
0.645
0.473
0.533
79.29
51.18
226.0
74.00
52.00
61.00
171.50
0.655
0.460
0.533
80.71
53.82
230.0
69.00
56.00
59.00
220.80
0.600
0.487
0.369
76.42
55.35
232.0
69.50
56.00
60.00
229.80
0.599
0.483
0.349
75.79
56.64
233.0
75.00
48.70
67.80
236.10
0.644
0.418
0.302
68.32
64.90
233.0
69.50
56.48
60.02
233.01
0.597
0.485
0.345
76.08
56.73
233.0
75.95
50.00
66.50
203.50
0.652
0.429
0.392
74.27
61.91
233.0
80.10
46.40
70.10
182.75
0.688
0.398
0.452
75.27
63.88
235.0
68.50
54.00
63.50
357.60
0.583
0.460
0.187
65.66
62.42
12
(b
250.0
75.00
55.00
70.00
375.00
0.600
0.440
0.183
67.62
68.85
300.0
80.00
74.00
76.00
762.50
0.533
0.493
0.108
82.19
75.56
Eccentricity = 1/2 (c = r)
Coordinates of T
2a
Span
b
Rise
c
(= a - r)
r
minor
R
Aspect
Major
b/a
140.0
45.00
35.00
35.00
101.25
150.0
45.00
37.50
37.50
200.0
75.00
50.00
220.0
80.00
225.0
c/a
tan
(a
0.643
0.500
0.622
53.49
29.72
135.00
0.600
0.500
0.417
51.92
34.62
50.00
112.50
0.750
0.500
1.333
90.00
30.00
55.00
55.00
128.00
0.727
0.500
1.146
96.44
36.16
75.00
56.25
56.25
150.00
0.667
0.500
0.750
90.00
45.00
226.0
66.19
56.50
56.50
226.00
0.586
0.500
0.354
75.33
53.27
226.0
70.00
56.50
56.50
181.48
0.619
0.500
0.507
82.04
50.40
231.0
67.00
57.75
57.75
242.65
0.580
0.500
0.329
75.79
54.86
233.0
68.24
58.25
58.25
233.00
0.586
0.500
0.354
77.67
54.92
240.0
70.00
60.00
60.00
245.00
0.583
0.500
0.343
79.46
56.76
245.0
71.00
61.25
61.25
258.51
0.580
0.500
0.327
80.27
58.22
248.0
72.00
62.00
62.00
259.20
0.581
0.500
0.331
81.49
58.86
250.0
74.37
62.50
62.50
232.98
0.595
0.500
0.394
85.41
58.15
250.0
75.00
62.50
62.50
225.00
0.600
0.500
0.417
86.54
57.69
270.0
75.00
67.50
67.50
375.00
0.556
0.500
0.225
82.32
65.85
300.0
80.00
75.00
75.00
640.00
0.533
0.500
0.134
84.96
74.34
300.0
84.00
75.00
75.00
392.00
0.560
0.500
0.244
92.74
72.87
300.0
90.00
75.00
75.00
270.00
0.600
0.500
0.417
103.85
69.23
316.0
100.00
79.00
79.00
238.10
0.633
0.500
0.572
118.23
68.57
320.0
105.00
80.00
80.00
220.50
0.656
0.500
0.693
125.55
65.77
350.0
105.00
87.50
87.50
315.00
0.600
0.500
0.417
121.15
80.77
360.0
100.00
90.00
90.00
500.00
0.556
0.500
0.225
109.76
87.80
400.0
120.00
100.00
100.00
360.00
0.600
0.500
0.417
138.46
92.31
13
(b
Eccentricity
Coordinates of T
2a
Span
b
Rise
c
(= a - r)
r
minor
R
Aspect
Major
b/a
150.0
30.00
58.50
16.50
150.00
150.0
34.75
47.00
28.00
182.0
45.50
56.88
200.0
40,00
200.0
c/a
tan
(a
0.400
0.780
0.488
65.73
14.83
195.00
0.463
0.627
0.293
54.88
26.87
34.125
182.00
0.500
0.625
0.417
70.00
31.50
78,00
22,00
200.00
0.400
0.780
0.488
87.64
19.78
40.00
72.00
28.00
250.00
0.400
0.720
0.343
81.08
26.49
220.0
60.00
60.00
50.00
235.00
0.545
0.545
0.343
76.22
47.30
226.0
56.25
71.00
42.00
226.00
0.498
0.628
0.418
87.21
38.75
231.0
71.00
59.25
56.25
182.63
0.615
0.513
0.531
85.62
49.68
235.0
68.50
59.20
58.30
235.20
0. 583
0.504
0.355
78.71
50.94
235.0
70.60
62.50
55.00
188.00
0.601
0.532
0.532
88.35
48.55
240.0
60.00
70.00
50.00
300.00
0.500
0.583
0.292
84.00
48.00
250.0
70.00
65.00
60.00
276.25
0.560
0.520
0.315
83.03
57.23
255.0
75.00
65.00
62.50
237.75
0.588
0.510
0.399
88.18
58.04
255.0
72.00
72.50
55.00
218.10
0.565
0.569
0.496
96.95
49.27
256.0
72.00
70.00
58.00
240.00
0.563
0.547
0.417
92.31
53.54
256.0
72.00
68.25
59.75
256.00
0.563
0.533
0.371
89.03
56.02
262.0
62.50
86.41
44.59
262.00
0.477
0.660
0.433
104.13
40.92
288.0
78.77
80.00
64.00
288.04
0.547
0.556
0.382
102.85
59.78
290.0
70.00
90.00
55.00
332.50
0.483
0.621
0.343
107.84
52.03
290.0
75.00
95.00
50.00
243.00
0.517
0.655
0.565
119.61
43.52
294.5
70.17
97.25
50.00
294.53
0.477
0.660
0.433
117.13
45.88
300.0
60.00
117.00
33.00
300.00
0.400
0.780
0.488
131.46
29.66
300.0
78.00
80.00
70.00
474.00
0.520
0.533
0.202
93.86
68.61
300.0
71.56
94.00
56.00
347.80
0.477
0.627
0.340
112.04
53.01
310.0
71.00
105.00
50.00
323.00
0.458
0.677
0.417
124.23
46.15
315.0
72.50
102.00
55.50
370.00
0.460
0.648
0.343
120.00
52.50
14
(b
320.0
74.00
107.50
52.50
332.00
0.463
0.672
0.417
127.69
48.46
325.0
74.50
110.00
52.50
338.50
0.458
0.677
0.417
130.19
48.46
350.0
75.00
120.00
55.00
425.00
0.429
0.686
0.343
137.84
52.03
350.0
75.00
125.00
50.00
375.00
0.429
0.714
0.417
144.23
46.15
360.0
75.00
130.00
50.00
400.50
0.417
0.722
0.399
148.54
46.43
376.8
80.75
138.40
50.00
376.83
0.429
0.735
0.467
159.57
45.30
400.0
80.00
156.00
44.00
400.00
0.400
0.780
0.488
175.28
39.55
400.0
80.00
150.00
50.00
440.00
0.400
0.750
0.417
169.23
46.15
420.0
82.00
160.00
50.00
466.00
0.390
0.762
0.417
179.23
46.15
450.0
180.00
67.50
157.50
270.00
0.800
0.300
0.750
162.00
126.00
450.0
105.00
160.00
65.00
405.00
0.467
0.711
0.533
190.59
57.35
500.0
100.00
195.00
55.00
500.00
0.400
0.780
0.488
219.10
49.44
Coordinates of T
b
Rise
c
(= a - r)
r
minor
R
Aspect
Major
b/a
150.0
50.00
50.00
25.00
87.50
160.0
50.00
50.00
30.00
180.0
56.50
56.50
200.0
60.00
220.0
c/a
tan
(a
0.667
0.667
1.333
70.00
15.00
102.50
0.625
0.625
0.952
70.69
21.72
33.50
114.40
0.628
0.628
0.976
79.90
23.98
60.00
40.00
140.00
0.600
0.600
0.750
84.00
32.00
60.00
60.00
50.00
235.00
0.545
0.545
0.343
76.22
47.30
238.0
68.00
68.00
51.00
195.50
0.571
0.571
0.533
92.00
45.00
240.0
75.00
75.00
45.00
153.75
0.625
0.625
0.952
106.03
32.59
250.0
75.00
75.00
50.00
175.00
0.600
0.600
0.750
105.00
40.00
270.0
87.50
87.50
47.50
163.20
0.648
0.648
1.156
123.42
31.08
300.0
90.00
90.00
60.00
210.00
0.600
0.600
0.750
126.00
48.00
300.0
100.00
100.00
50.00
175.00
0.667
0.667
1.333
140.00
30.00
320.0
100.00
100.00
60.00
205.00
0.625
0.625
0.952
141.38
43.45
350.0
120.50
120.50
54.50
197.50
0.689
0.689
1.565
166.42
29.35
15
(b
400.0
140.00
140.00
60.00
222.50
0.700
0.700
1.697
191.69
30.46
400.0
144.50
144.50
55.50
217.30
0.723
0.723
1.985
194.06
24.97
440,0
120.00
120.00
100.00
470.00
0.545
0.545
0.343
152.43
94.59
450.0
150.00
150.00
75.00
262.50
0.667
0.667
1.333
210.00
45.00
480.0
150.00
150.00
90.00
307.50
0.625
0.625
0.952
212.07
65.17
500.0
166.70
166.70
83.30
291.60
0.667
0.667
1.335
233.36
49.95
The Achaemenid
Coordinates of T
b
Rise
c
(= a - r)
r
minor
R
Aspect
Major
b/a
12.0
4.00
3.00
3.00
8.00
24.0
8.00
6.00
6.00
36.0
12.00
9.00
60.0
20.00
144.0
(a
d
(b
c/a
tan
0.667
0.500
0.750
4.80
2.40
16.00
0.667
0.500
0.750
9.60
4.80
9.00
24.00
0.667
0.500
0.750
14.40
7.20
15.00
15.00
40.00
0.667
0.500
0.750
24.00
12.00
48.00
36.00
36.00
96.00
0.667
0.500
0.750
57.60
28.80
150.0
50.00
37.50
37.50
100.00
0.667
0.500
0.750
60.00
30.00
162.0
54.00
40.50
40.50
108.00
0.667
0.500
0.750
64.80
32.40
174.0
58.00
43.50
43.50
116.00
0.667
0.500
0.750
69.60
34.80
180.0
60.00
45.00
45.00
120.00
0.667
0.500
0.750
72.00
36.00
183.0
61.00
45.75
45.75
122.00
0.667
0.500
0.750
73.20
36.60
186.0
62.00
46.50
46.50
124.00
0.667
0.500
0.750
74.40
37.20
192.0
64.00
48.00
48.00
128.00
0.667
0.500
0.750
76.80
38.40
204.0
68.00
51.00
51.00
136.00
0.667
0.500
0.750
81.60
40.80
210.0
70.00
52.50
52.50
140.00
0.667
0.500
0.750
84.00
42.00
216.0
72.00
54.00
54.00
144.00
0.667
0.500
0.750
86.40
43.20
222.0
74.00
55.50
55.50
148.00
0.667
0.500
0.750
88.80
44.40
225.0
75.00
56.25
56.25
150.00
0.667
0.500
0.750
90.00
45.00
240.0
80.00
60.00
60.00
160.00
0.667
0.500
0.750
96.00
48.00
246.0
82.00
61.50
61.50
164.00
0.667
0.500
0.750
98.40
49.20
252.0
84.00
63.00
63.00
168.00
0.667
0.500
0.750
100.80
50.40
258.0
86.00
64.50
64.50
172.00
0.667
0.500
0.750
103.20
51.60
264.0
88.00
66.00
66.00
176.00
0.667
0.500
0.750
105.60
52.80
16
300.0
100.00
75.00
75.00
200.00
0.667
0.500
0.750
120.00
60.00
330.0
110.00
82.50
82.50
220.00
0.667
0.500
0.750
132.00
66.00
360.0
120.00
90.00
90.00
240.00
0.667
0.500
0.750
144.00
72.00
375.0
125.00
93.75
93.75
250.00
0.667
0.500
0.750
150.00
75.00
390.0
130.00
97.50
97.50
260.00
0.667
0.500
0.750
156.00
78.00
420.0
140.00
105.00
105.00
280.00
0.667
0.500
0.750
168.00
84.00
450.0
150.00
112.50
112.50
300.00
0.667
0.500
0.750
180.00
90.00
480.0
160.00
120.00
120.00
320.00
0.667
0.500
0.750
192.00
96.00
Coordinates of T
b
Rise
c
(= a - r)
r
minor
R
Aspect
Major
b/a
170.0
42.50
53.10
31.90
170.20
172.0
43.00
53.75
32.25
175.0
43.75
54.70
180.0
45.00
200.0
c/a
tan
(a
0.500
0.625
0.416
65.35
29.46
172.00
0.500
0.625
0.417
66.15
29.77
32.80
174.90
0.500
0.625
0.417
67.33
30.27
54.00
36.00
202.50
0.500
0.600
0.343
65.68
34.05
50.00
62.50
37.50
200.00
0.500
0.625
0.417
76.92
34.62
200.0
50.00
55.00
45.00
350.00
0.500
0.550
0.183
63.11
44.26
250.0
62.50
77.00
48.00
259.70
0.500
0.616
0.390
94.46
44.71
263.0
65.75
79.50
52.00
288.70
0.500
0.605
0.357
96.96
48.98
264.0
66.00
84.00
48.00
253.00
0.500
0.636
0.449
103.67
43.79
265.0
66.25
85.50
47.00
246.50
0.500
0.645
0.474
105.64
42.46
288.0
72.00
96.00
48.00
252.00
0.500
0.667
0.533
118.59
42.35
300.0
75.00
100.00
50.00
262.50
0.500
0.667
0.533
123.53
44.12
320.0
80.00
112.00
48.00
260.00
0.500
0.700
0.622
137.36
40.75
350.0
87.50
120.50
54.50
291.00
0.500
0.689
0.592
148.27
46.90
17
(b
Coordinates of T
b
Rise
c
(= a - r)
r
minor
R
Aspect
Major
b/a
144.0
36.00
45.00
27.00
144.00
156.0
39.00
48.75
29.25
160,0
40,00
50,00
168.0
42.00
180.0
c/a
tan
(a
0.500
0.625
0.417
55.38
24.92
156.00
0.500
0.625
0.417
60.00
27.00
30,00
160,00
0.500
0.625
0.417
61.54
27.69
52.50
31.50
168.00
0.500
0.625
0.417
64.62
29.08
45.00
56.25
33.75
180.00
0.500
0.625
0.417
69.23
31.15
200.0
50.00
62.50
37.50
200.00
0.500
0.625
0.417
76.92
34.62
224.0
56.00
70.00
42.00
224.00
0.500
0.625
0.417
86.15
38.77
240.0
60.00
75.00
45.00
240.00
0.500
0.625
0.417
92.31
41.54
256.0
64.00
80.00
48.00
256.00
0.500
0.625
0.417
98.46
44.31
264.0
66.00
82.50
49.50
264.00
0.500
0.625
0.417
101.54
45.69
288.0
72.00
90.00
54.00
288.00
0.500
0.625
0.417
110.77
49.85
300.0
75.00
93.75
56.25
300.00
0.500
0.625
0.417
115.38
51.92
320.0
80.00
100.00
60.00
320.00
0.500
0.625
0.417
123.08
55.38
360.0
90.00
112.50
67.50
360.00
0.500
0.625
0.417
138.46
62.31
(b
Coordinates of T
b
Rise
c
(= a - r)
r
minor
R
Aspect
Major
b/a
158.0
39.50
48.82
30.18
162.67
160.0
40.00
49.44
30.56
170.0
42.50
52.53
180.0
45.00
55.62
c/a
tan
(a
0.500
0.618
0.396
59.94
28.05
164.75
0.500
0.618
0.396
60.70
28.41
32.47
175.04
0.500
0.618
0.396
64.49
30.19
34.38
185.34
0.500
0.618
0.396
68.29
31.96
18
(b
183.0
45.75
56.55
34.95
188.40
0.500
0.618
0.396
69.43
32.49
200.0
50.00
61.80
38.20
205.93
0.500
0.618
0.396
75.87
35.51
220.0
55.00
68.00
42.00
226.35
0.500
0.618
0.397
83.49
39.04
250.0
62.50
77.25
47.75
257.42
0.500
0.618
0.396
94.84
44.39
260.0
65.00
80.34
49.66
267.71
0.500
0.618
0.396
98.64
46.17
300.0
75.00
92.70
57.30
308.90
0.500
0.618
0.396
113.81
53.27
320.0
80.00
98.88
61.12
329.49
0.500
0.618
0.396
121.40
56.82
340.0
85.00
105.07
64.94
350.04
0.500
0.618
0.396
128.99
60.37
360.0
90.00
111.24
68.76
370.68
0.500
0.618
0.396
136.57
63.92
Coordinates of T
b
Rise
c
(= a - r)
r
minor
R
Aspect
Major
b/a
160.0
49.44
42.00
38.00
120.80
180.0
55.62
56.25
33.75
200.0
61.80
62.50
220.0
67.98
225.0
c/a
tan
(a
0.618
0.525
0.589
61.28
32.75
117.01
0.618
0.625
0.916
79.05
24.88
37.50
130.02
0.618
0.625
0.916
87.83
27.65
53.00
57.00
190.36
0.618
0.482
0.433
75.65
52.31
69.53
55.00
57.50
189.25
0.618
0.489
0.459
79.00
52.25
230.0
71.07
56.00
59.00
194.90
0.618
0.487
0.452
80.31
53.76
238.3
73.64
58.90
60.25
196.50
0.618
0.494
0.479
84.95
54.33
240.0
74.16
59.00
61.00
199.80
0.618
0.492
0.470
84.93
55.21
250.0
77.25
65.50
59.50
189.20
0.618
0.524
0.585
95.55
51.36
260.0
80.34
70.00
60.00
190.60
0.618
0.538
0.635
102.16
50.65
280.0
86.52
86.50
53.50
183.29
0.618
0.618
0.894
122.15
39.89
300.0
92.71
96.10
53.90
192.30
0.618
0.641
0.965
133.53
38.79
360.0
111.25
125.00
55.00
222.02
0.618
0.694
1.128
166.16
36.48
19
(b
Coordinates of T
b
Rise
c
(= a - r)
r
minor
R
Aspect
Major
b/a
160.0
49.44
40.00
40.00
129.44
180.0
55.62
45.00
45.00
200.0
61.80
50.00
220.0
67.98
226.0
c/a
tan
(a
0.618
0.500
0.500
57.89
35.78
145.62
0.618
0.500
0.500
65.12
40.25
50.00
161.80
0.618
0.500
0.500
72.36
44.72
55.00
55.00
177.98
0.618
0.500
0.500
79.60
49.19
69.84
56.50
56.50
182.84
0.618
0.500
0.500
81.77
50.54
230.0
71.07
57.50
57.50
186.07
0.618
0.500
0.500
83.21
51.43
240.0
74.16
60.00
60.00
194.16
0.618
0.500
0.500
86.83
53.67
250.0
77.25
62.50
62.50
202.25
0.618
0.500
0.500
90.45
55.90
360.0
111.25
90.00
90.00
291.25
0.618
0.500
0.500
130.25
80.50
b
Rise
c
(= a - r)
r
minor
R
Aspect
Major
b/a
161.8
50.00
50.00
30.90
105.90
220.0
68.00
68.00
42.00
238.3
73.64
73.65
260.0
80.34
266.0
(b
Coordinates of T
c/a
tan
(a
0.618
0.618
0.895
70.60
23.03
143.92
0.618
0.618
0.896
96.02
31.29
45.50
155.95
0.618
0.618
0.895
103.99
33.91
80.40
49.60
170.10
0.618
0.618
0.896
113.49
36.94
82.20
82.20
50.80
174.10
0.618
0.618
0.894
116.07
37.86
288.0
89.00
89.00
55.00
188.49
0.618
0.618
0.895
125.67
40.99
296.0
91.47
91.47
56.53
193.74
0.618
0.618
0.894
129.16
42.14
366.0
113.10
113.10
69.90
239.55
0.618
0.618
0.894
159.70
52.10
400.0
123.61
123.60
76.40
261.81
0.618
0.618
0.894
174.53
56.95
523.6
161.80
161.80
100.00
342.71
0.618
0.618
0.894
228.46
74.54
20
(b
Coordinates of T
b
Rise
c
(= a - r)
r
minor
R
Aspect
Major
b/a
150.0
25.00
58.33
16.67
225.00
180.0
30.00
67.50
22.50
200.0
33.33
76.00
240.0
40.00
300.0
c/a
tan
(a
0.333
0.778
0.292
63.00
16.00
330.00
0.333
0.750
0.225
72.44
21.95
24.00
338.10
0.333
0.760
0.249
81.81
23.29
96.00
24.00
320.00
0.333
0.800
0.343
103.78
22.70
50.00
133.33
16.67
300.00
0.333
0.889
0.533
141.18
14.71
350.0
58.33
145.00
30.00
415.20
0.333
0.829
0.406
156.29
27.79
360.0
60.00
150.00
30.00
420.00
0.333
0.833
0.417
161.54
27.69
400.0
66.67
165.00
35.00
480.70
0.333
0.825
0.399
177.96
32.51
420.0
70.00
175.00
35.00
490.00
0.333
0.833
0.417
188.46
32.31
(b
Coordinates of T
b
Rise
c
(= a - r)
r
minor
R
Aspect
Major
b/a
150.0
50.00
50.00
25.00
87.50
180.0
60.00
60.00
30.00
200.0
66.67
67.00
250.0
83.33
270.0
c/a
tan
(a
0.667
0.667
1.333
70.00
15.00
105.00
0.667
0.667
1.333
84.00
18.00
33.00
116.50
0.667
0.670
1.344
93.48
19.69
83.00
42.00
146.00
0.667
0.664
1.324
116.52
25.31
90.00
90.00
45.00
157.50
0.667
0.667
1.333
126.00
27.00
300.0
100.00
100.00
50.00
175.00
0.667
0.667
1.333
140.00
30.00
350.0
116.67
143.00
32.00
195.10
0.667
0.817
1.823
171.06
15.39
360.0
120.00
140.00
40.00
202.50
0.667
0.778
1.697
174.46
20.31
400.0
133.33
165.00
35.00
222.60
0.667
0.825
1.848
195.78
16.65
21
(b
Coordinates of T
b
Rise
c
(= a - r)
r
minor
R
Aspect
Major
b/a
150,0
56,25
45,00
30,00
81,70
180.0
67.50
64.00
26.00
200.0
75.00
78.00
225.0
84.38
250.0
c/a
tan
(a
0.750
0.600
1.768
71.11
14.77
96.10
0.750
0.711
2.238
87.74
10.61
22.00
105.90
0.750
0.780
2.525
98.45
8.10
56.25
56.25
126.56
0.750
0.500
1.333
101.25
33.75
93.75
100.00
25.00
132.10
0.750
0.800
2.607
123.34
8.95
265.0
99.38
91.50
41.00
141.90
0.750
0.691
2.152
128.68
17.28
300.0
112.50
110.00
40.00
159.70
0.750
0.733
2.331
146.76
15.77
350.0
131.25
130.00
45.00
186.10
0.750
0.743
2.370
171.46
17.49
400.0
150.00
155.00
45.00
211.90
0.750
0.775
2.504
196.79
16.69
(b
Coordinates of T
= 30 ; 2c = R - r (equilateral)
2a
Span
b
Rise
c
(= a - r)
r
minor
R
Aspect
Major
b/a
220.0
57.00
72.40
37.60
182.40
220.0
69.74
55.00
55.00
250.0
64.00
83.33
280.0
78.51
300.0
360.0
c/a
tan
(a
0.518
0.658
0.577
91.20
32.56
165.00
0.634
0.500
0.577
82.50
47.63
41.67
208.33
0.512
0.667
0.577
104.16
36.09
84.00
56.00
224.00
0.561
0.600
0.577
112.00
48.50
95.10
75.00
75.00
225.00
0.634
0.500
0.577
112.50
64.95
106.80
100.00
80.00
280.00
0.593
0.556
0.577
140.00
69.28
22
(b
Roof 1:2
Coordinates of T
b
Rise
c
(= a - r)
r
minor
R
Aspect
Major
b/a
300.0
122.50
36.00
114.00
194.49
300.0
100.00
65.45
84.55
400.0
176.40
30.90
450.0
180.00
500.0
c/a
tan
(a
0.817
0.240
0.500
86.99
101.96
230.91
0.667
0.436
0.500
103.26
75.62
169.10
238.15
0.882
0.155
0.500
106.57
151.22
58.90
166.10
297.84
0.800
0.262
0.500
133.16
148.57
196.60
69.90
180.10
336.41
0.786
0.280
0.500
150.44
161.09
600.0
200.00
130.90
169.10
461.81
0.667
0.436
0.500
206.52
151.25
600.0
225.00
98.18
201.83
421.36
0.750
0.327
0.500
188.43
180.52
600.0
250.00
65.45
234.55
380.91
0.833
0.218
0.500
170.34
209.79
800.0
352.80
61.80
338.20
476.30
0.882
0.155
0.500
213.15
302.44
1000.0
393.20
139.80
360.20
672.82
0.786
0.280
0.500
300.88
322.18
Roof
(b
2:3
Coordinates of T
tan = 0.667
2a
Span
b
Rise
c
(= a - r)
r
minor
R
Aspect
Major
b/a
250.0
75.00
71.74
53.26
182.50
300.0
132.50
25.10
124.90
360.0
132.50
68.15
400.0
176.64
450.0
c/a
tan
(a
0.600
0.574
0.667
101.30
44.30
170.15
0,883
0.167
0.667
94.38
103.92
111.85
234.63
0.736
0.379
0.667
130.23
93.04
33.51
166.49
226.88
0.883
0.168
0.667
125.89
138.51
198.75
37.65
187.35
255.22
0.883
0.167
0.667
141.58
155.88
500.0
220.85
41.81
208.19
283.56
0.883
0.167
0.667
157.30
173.22
600.0
265.00
50.20
249.80
340.30
0.883
0.167
0.667
188.77
207.84
1000,0
441.65
83.69
416.31
567.18
0.883
0.167
0.667
314.62
346.39
23
(b
Roof 1:1
Coordinates of T
tan = 1 ;
2a
Span
b
Rise
c
(= a - r)
r
minor
R
Aspect
Major
b/a
280.0
130.00
17.07
122.93
147.07
300.0
135.06
25.50
124.50
400.0
180.05
34.05
450.0
200.00
500.0
c/a
tan
(a
0.929
0.122
1.000
103.99
86.93
160.57
0.900
0.170
1.000
113.52
88.05
165.95
214.11
0.900
0.170
1.000
151.37
117.37
42.67
182.33
242.69
0.889
0.190
1.000
171.57
128.95
225.10
42.50
207.50
267.61
0.900
0.170
1.000
189.20
146.75
600.0
270.12
51.00
249.00
321.14
0.900
0.170
1.000
227.04
176.10
1000.0
450.20
85.00
415.00
535.23
0.900
0.170
1.000
378.40
293.50
(b
Roof 3:4
Coordinates of T
tan = 0.75
2a
Span
b
Rise
c
(= a - r)
r
minor
R
Aspect
Major
b/a
200.0
75.00
37.50
62.50
125.00
204.0
94.00
12.00
90.00
220.0
60.00
75.00
240.0
94.00
250.0
c/a
tan
(a
0.750
0.375
0.750
75.00
50.00
110.00
0.922
0.118
0.750
66.00
72.00
35.00
160.00
0.545
0.682
0.750
96.00
28.00
39.00
81.00
146.00
0.783
0.325
0.750
87.60
64.80
110.00
22.50
102.50
140.00
0.880
0.180
0.750
84.00
82.00
250.0
75.00
75.00
50.00
175.00
0.600
0.600
0.750
105.00
40.00
280.0
80.00
90.00
50.00
200.00
0.571
0.643
0.750
120.00
40.00
300.0
112.50
56.25
93.75
187.50
0.750
0.375
0.750
112.50
75.00
300.0
135.00
22.50
127.50
165.00
0.900
0.150
0.750
99.00
102.00
320.0
142.50
26.25
133.75
177.50
0.891
0.164
0.750
106.50
107.00
350.0
157.50
26.25
148.75
192.50
0.900
0.150
0.750
115.50
119.00
24
(b
400.0
180.00
30.00
170.00
220.00
0.900
0.150
0.750
132.00
136.00
500.0
225.00
37.50
212.50
275.00
0.900
0.150
0.750
165.00
170.00
600.0
270.00
45.00
255.00
330.00
0.900
0.150
0.750
198.00
204.00
1000.0
450.00
75.00
425.00
550.00
0.900
0.150
0.750
330.00
340.00
25