Aeronautical Bachelor: Network Developments
Aeronautical Bachelor: Network Developments
Aeronautical Bachelor: Network Developments
Bachelor
Network
developments
2. Network topology
What are the different types of network?
What are the advantages and disadvantages of a point-to-point strategy? Of a hub-and-
spoke strategy?
3. Network planning
What are the main steps of network planning? Of route openning?
What are the factors influencing network planning?
Which departments are involved?
4. Conclusion
REMINDER: NETWORK & SCHEDULE ARE THE BACKBONE OF AN AIRLINE OFFER
Airlines product is a perishable commodity that cannot be warehoused or sold another day. An empty
seat is a missed opportunity to generate revenue but will burn cash anyway.
1. Understanding the macro forces
influencing air traffic demand
Asia + Middle-East Northern America Europe Latin America and the Caribbean Oceania Africa
Competition The rise of a new business model in a market – such as LCCs – can
increase propensity to fly of a given population.
hãng có knang kết nối vượt trội so với kích cỡ của họ nhờ vào ''hub'' -> tăng khả năng bay
Airport hub Countries with air connectivity far out of proportion to their size,
status
because of their airports’ hub status, have a higher propensity to fly.
chuyến bay trên đầu người
Propensity to fly is defined as the number of flight trips per head of the population, or “trips per capita”,
per annum. It is a useful indicator of the level of air traffic in a country and of the potential for growth.
Nếu chỉ số này tăng theo thời gian, điều này có thể cho thấy ngành hàng không đang phát triển và tiềm năng cho sự tăng trưởng trong tương lai
Sources: PWC Propensity to fly in emerging economies
PROPENSITY TO FLY IS INTRINSICALLY LINKED TO COUNTRIES’ ECONOMIC HEALTH
Propensity to fly – trips per capita & GDP per capita in 2019
Trips per capita
10.00
Canada
1.00 France
Vietnam China
Brazil
0.10 Kenya
Group 1
Madagascar
0.01 Group 2
Group 3
0.00
- 5 000 10 000 15 000 20 000 25 000 30 000 35 000 40 000 45 000 50 000
Gross Domestic Product per capita
Global air traffic is dominated by domestic traffic. Yet, international air traffic is growing faster than domestic
traffic thanks to the continuous effect of globalization, the growth of emerging countries and their opening to
global economy.
Geographical features and geopolitics have a great influence on propensity to travel and routes: passengers
living in relatively small countries will have higher propensity to fly internationally. This explains why almost
1 international pax / 10 comes from Europe.
Sources: Sabre
IN THE SHORT TERM, COVID-19 RESHUFFLED THE TRAFFIC FORECASTS CARDS
GDP & demographics are the fundamental 2021-2025 passenger growth vs 2019
120%
E-commerce demand
Total pax
Rank Airport
2019*
1 Atlanta, US (ATL) 110 531 300 United States have 4 airports of the global Top 10
2 Beijing, CN (PEK) 100 011 438 busiest airports.
3 Los Angeles, US (LAX) 88 068 013
Asia is well represented, with 2 airports in China (PVG,
4 Dubai, AE (DXB) 86 396 757
PEK) and the Japanese capital airport (HND).
5 Tokyo, JP (HND) 85 505 054
6 Chicago, US (ORD) 84 649 115 Dubai, as the home base of the super connector
7 London, GB (LHR) 80 888 305 Emirates, is one of the world mega-hub airports.
8 Shanghai, CN (PVG) 76 153 455
9 Paris, FR (CDG) 76 150 009
10 Dallas/Fort Worth, US (DFW) 75 066 956
Sources: ACI
* Total passengers enplaned and deplaned, passengers in transit counted once
WORLD’S BUSIEST ROUTES FOR PASSENGER TRAFFIC
Asia-Pacific concentrates most busiest routes. The large majority of routes are short, domestic routes and
often served with high frequency (ex: CJU-GMP = 122 daily return flights).
This ranking highlights the role of air transport in territorial development strategies.
Total pax
Rank Route
2019
1 CJU-GMP 11 921 821
2 MEL-SYD 7 694 990
3 HAN-SGN 6 956 926
4 BOM-DEL 6 122 429
5 CTS-HND 5 444 375
6 JED-RUH 5 186 523
7 FUK-HND 4 657 979
8 CGK-DPS 4 541 986
9 HKG-TPE 4 308 876
10 PEK-SHA 4 135 611
Sources: Sabre, OAG
WORLD’S BUSIEST AIRPORTS FOR CARGO TRAFFIC
Cargo (FTK)
Rank Airport
2019*
1 Hong Kong, HK (HKG) 4 809 485
Geographical distribution of top cargo airports
2 Memphis TN, US (MEM) 4 322 740
3 Shanghai, CN (PVG) 3 634 230 depends on several factors:
4 Louisville KY, US (SDF) 2 790 109 Freighter airlines’ base (Memphis for FedEx,
5 Incheon, KR (ICN) 2 764 369 Louisville for UPS)
6 Anchorage AK, US (ANC)** 2 745 348 Proximity of large maritime ports (ANC, and
7 Dubai, AE (DXB) 2 514 918 Asian coasts)
gần cảng lớn
Low level of connectivity, lack of network continuity, no main base. Traffic is mostly point-to-point
(P2P).
This type of airline network is quite rare because of its cost to operate. Most airlines operating
unconnected networks are focusing on niche markets or serving territorial development strategies.
chiến lược phát triển lãnh thổ
Niche market là một thị trường nhỏ hẹp, tập trung vào một nhóm đối tượng
khách hàng cụ thể có nhu cầu và sở thích đặc biệt.
TYPES OF NETWORK: CLUSTER TREE
Base
Base
Base
đầu mút
Network is hierarchized: distinction between hubs (operating bases) and spokes. Hubs benefit from excellent
connectivity, low connectivity for spokes. A star network can be organized with several hubs. Depending on
the airline’s strategy, traffic can be both P2P or connecting. hub nằm ở vị trí chiến lược, mật độ lưu lượng khách lớn và
đc kết nối với nhiều địa điểm khác -> excellent connectivity
This network organization meets several constraints:
Some cities are leviathans (ex: Paris in France)
Allows to position operating bases
Allows to develop hub strategies (particularly true for legacy carriers)
TYPES OF NETWORK: NON HUB STAR NETWORK
3 markets to distinguish:
How many routes can be combined thanks to Outlying markets: traffic connecting at
this mini-hub? the hub A
This network organization allows to connect markets where traffic potential is too low to open a direct
route.
Hubs are often located in densely populated cities (capitals) where demand is strong enough to
guarantee a minimum level of P2P traffic from / to network spokes.
Factors influencing the selection of freight airlines’ hub are different: a central location will often be
favored (ex: FedEx in Memphis and in Anchorage for Asia-North America cargo traffic).
HOW MANY THEORETICAL FLIGHT CONNECTIONS CAN BE DONE ON TURKISH AIRLINES’
NETWORK?
304
destinations served
directly from Istanbul
Sources: Routes
TYPES OF NETWORK: PRINCIPLE OF HUB & SPOKE NETWORK // HUB BANKING
Departing flights
Arriving flights
tập trung các chuyến bay
Airlines operating a hub & spoke network use a system called “hub banking” which clusters flight around
similar times. An average day may have up to 10 'banked' times, in which several flights all leave within
minutes of each other.
The airline co-ordinates arrivals and departures at its hub in order to minimize delays for passengers
continuing through the hub to final destinations.
Sources: airliners.net
HUB & SPOKE NETWORKS BRING A VIRTUOUS DYNAMIC FOR BOTH PASSENGERS AND
OPERATORS
Connections can generate from 50% to 150% additional traffic for a given route.
Reduced “domino effect”: routes can be Local demand have to be strong enough to fill
easily interrupted if not profitable. the cabin : low density markets may be
Product attractiveness: direct flights are more excluded.
convenient to passengers: no stopover, Requires more routes for the same market
minimized travel time. Passenger willingness footprint
to pay for a direct flight is higher Congestion at large international airports may
Decreases airport dependency: largest P2P limit the number of required frequencies or
carriers can benefit from airport competition possibilities to capture attractive slots.
willing to attract new carriers (airport Varying frequency and pricing are the only
incentives, facilities…) delays may be limited ways to counter demand variations: varying
to one aircraft’s routes. demand in a given city-pair cannot be offset
From a route perspective, lower operating by demand from other markets.
costs (ground ops, maintenance, fuel, crew…)
Higher utilization of aircraft and crews,
thanks to low TAT and optimized dispatches.
3. Network planning
Network planning requires a high level of cooperation between operational, commercial & support
departments.
Marketing
Commercial Operational
Ground departments
departments Commercial ops
Revenue
Maintenance
Management
Fleet
Crews
management
Flight
Corporate Financials
ops
Int’l
corporate
NETWORK PLANNING ACCURACY INCREASES WITH TIME
Accuracy
Flight D-Day
• Identification of potential operating Supplier / Existing • Airport facilities & slot availability
Collaborator
blockers (trained pilots or availability facilities (runway, accessibility…)
mechanics, spares…)
Market
analysis
Market
• Market needs vs current offer Gap • General traffic history & trends at
history &
analysis country / region level, past
trends
attempt & failures
Market Competition
analysis • Competition structure, market share
• Existing travelling passengers & segment & business model
expectations, new segments to stimulate Route
analysis
• Pax & cargo demand analysis, competitors
Source: Airbus Consulting fare positioning & existing schedule
FACTORS INFLUENCING NETWORK PLANNING: FLEET
Schedule
= robustness
Schedule flexibility
+
Schedule stability
Whether airlines are operating hub & spokes or P2P networks, creating a robust schedule is key to avoid
propagated delays.
Schedule stability: commercial carriers’ schedules are as steady as possible
Schedule flexibility: Flight & ground operations (flight time, block-time, embarking and disembarking
constraints at airport are rounded with few additional minutes to anticipate potential disruptions
(weather, technical failure…).
FACTORS INFLUENCING NETWORK PLANNING: AIRPORT SLOTS
Slot allocation principles
A slot is the authorization for a flight to use a
runway at a busy airport for either a takeoff or a 1. Grandfathered slots
landing. These airports are called Level 3 airports
or coordinated airports. 2. Non-grandfathered slots:
Management of airport slots is required at some
airports where the available airport infrastructure Abandoned /
Newly available slots
is insufficient to meet the demand. confiscated slots
Airport coordination parameters are updated
twice each year – in conjunction with the IATA 3. Slot pool
seasons:
IATA winter season: begins on the last
New entrants Existing operators
Sunday of October and ends on the last
Saturday of March.
In a coordinated airport, slots are allocated
IATA Summer season: begins on the last
by independent coordinators on the basis of
Sunday of March and ends on the last historic rights at the given airport.
Saturday of October.
Sources: IATA Worldwide Slot Guidelines
IN EUROPE, USE-IT OR LOOSE IT RULE WAS AT THE ORIGIN OF GHOST FLIGHTS DURING
PANDEMIC
Grandfather rights, also called the 80-20 rule, are
granted under the condition that airlines use at least
80% of their slots during the season.
Because of this system, airlines reducing their use of
the slots risk losing them. This is the Use it or loose it
rule.
In 2020 during the pandemic, European airlines kept
flying empty flights before the European Commission
decided to suspend the grandfather rule.
In Europe, for the current Winter 2021-2022 period,
the "use it or lose it" threshold was lowered to 50%.
6 criteria determine a slot pair's value: constraint
level, general economic environment, flight time of Airports slots are extremely valuable for
the day, slots frequency, aircraft turn-around time, airlines. In 2016, Oman Air broke the world
seasonality. record price for a slot pair. Oman Air paid
US$75 million for the right to land at
Heathrow on a early-morning arrival slot.
Sources: Simple Flying
FACTORS INFLUENCING NETWORK PLANNING: SEASONNALITY
xác định thời điểm ít du lịch nhất để tránh operate khoảng tgian đó
-> tiết kiệm đc tiền.
Example of routes monthly traffic
Anticipating the traffic seasonality is a % Total OD traffic
crucial task for any airline. The objective OSL-PAR DXB-PAR BLQ-PAR ORY-TLS
is to balance out the typical low periods 14% Summer Winter Annual
Freedom Description
Distribution – Integration
Commercial
to PSS & 1st ticket sale
AOC extension
(update of OM-A, OM-C + OM-B Flight ops
OM-D as required)
Competitive
environment
Hand off to flight ops
Assessment of Detailed
AC & schedule New route (risk and route study)
route financial
planning short list & maintenance
attractiveness assessment
(scheduling)
Bilateral
constraints
Commercial deals
with local airport Deals securing
and stakeholders
Marketing Misc.(Office,
Aeronautical
support / maintenance,
incentives
direct funding etc.)
ROUTE OPENNING STEPS: TRAFFIC FORECAST PRINCIPLE
Traffic estimate
Potential traffic to be captured. Basis for scheduling and
revenue management.
Market reaction
Route stimulation, competition aggressiveness, airline
attractiveness
Route status
Traffic volume & type, growth, competition offer
(fares, capacity, schedule)
Letter Transport
Int’l Letter CAA to
Ministry to Traffic right
route Letter to CAA transport Local meeting
opening Foreign Affairs confirmation
Ministry
Ministry
ROUTE OPENNING STEPS: NEGOTIATION & CONTRACTS SETTLEMENT WITH 3RD PARTIES
• Fuel supply
Fuel contract • Fueling and defueling ops
Identifying network development opportunities requires an understanding of global traffic organization and
trends in the forces affecting airlines’ revenue growth. They are both driven primarily by passenger growth
and therefore propensity to fly.
Propensity to fly of a given population is a consequence of demographic, socioeconomic and geographical
forces and is influenced by local air transport maturity.
Europe and North-America generate 49% of global air traffic. Yet, Asia and Africa air traffic is expected to
boom in the upcoming years.
In the long-term, passenger demand and traffic distribution evolutions will follow GDP and demographic
growths. In the short to middle-term however, crisis like COVID-19 or Russian-Ukrainian conflict may
jeopardize airlines’ network development strategies.
Airlines’ network topology should be adapted to market needs and airlines’ capabilities. Hub and spoke
mở rộng phạm vi địa lý, địa bàn hoạt động
networks increases airlines’ geographical footprint while direct flights on a Point-to-Point network are often
more attractive to customers.
Network planning requires high level of cooperation between operational, commercial & support
departments.
Factors influencing network planning are both internal and external. On top of market demand, fleet,
operation, slots, traffic rights and seasonality constraints should be taken into account.
USEFUL SOURCES