Assesment of Ground Conditions
Assesment of Ground Conditions
Assesment of Ground Conditions
Abstract
Mining software systems have provided a basis for integration of resource, survey, and design
functions. They can similarly provide a basis for incorporating ground conditions into the process.
Exploration and mine geologists have a prime role to play in this process, extending their
responsibilities further across the geological spectrum, into exploration of ground conditions,
analyses of results, and assessments of their implications for mining. Ground conditions are as much
a part of the geology of a prospect or mine as its mineralisation, and can have critical implications
for mining.
Engineering/structural logging and mapping can be readily integrated into current site procedures.
Results may be incorporated into the same databases as other geological data, and the same mining
software systems used to process and present results. Processing and presenting results similarly
involves plots of data along drill paths or exposures, as histograms and annotations. Block models of
ground conditions may be constructed, using similar interpolation and statistical techniques,
including geostatistics. Results may be plotted on two dimensional plans and sections, and extended
to three dimensional wireframe and solid modelling of surfaces or blocks, with perspective viewing.
Geologists may need to expand their skills through specialist training and experience, including an
appreciation of the role of geomechanics and ground conditions in mining.
Successful integration of resources and ground conditions offers opportunities to enhance mine
planning and operations through: higher-quality data on ground conditions, arising from
standardisation and geological cross-fertilisation; wider coverage of mine sites, providing potential
for a full map of ground conditions to be developed; and efficient processes, based on mining
software systems, exploiting graphic three-dimensional visualisation..
location and construction of waste dumps, and siting of While domains usually correspond to rock units, they may be
infrastructure. subdivided according to alteration (weathering, hydrothermal),
or dissection by major structures (eg fold axial planes).
Underground, ground conditions have a role in the selection of Deformed zones (sheared, mylonitic) may be classed as
a mining method and operating variables, including stope sizes domains in their own right.
and shapes, sequences of extraction, rates of production,
support, drilling and blasting, inflows of groundwater, caving Domains are directly related to the geological model of a
and subsidence, and hazards for men and machines. Recovery prospect or mine. Therefore, exploration and mine geologists,
of a measured resource is dependent on the combination of rock with their geomechanical advisers, must accept a primary role
conditions and stresses that determine the location and size of in the identification and delineation of domains.
retained pillars, collapses that sterilise ore, and caving of
surrounding rock. Dilution, which may displace deliverable ore, Natural conditions
is dependent on rock conditions and stresses within wall-rock
and effectuality of support that may be applied. Falls of rock, Investigations are directed to estimating the natural or in situ
induced by geologic structures, high stresses, and vibrations, character of rock, before disturbance by exploration and
remain a major hazard within mines. Inflows of groundwater mining. Fractures and breaks due to drilling, handling, blasting,
may be a significant cost and a limitation on mining. or other disturbances should be either disregarded or recorded
separately. This approach provides a common basis to relate
one form of data to another, and one site to another. Some
Mine optimisation
standard procedures, notably Rock Quality Designation (RQD),
Optimisation of mining requires that the method, design, specify that only natural breaks be logged - although giving the
sequence of extraction, support, etc, be matched to the ground benefit of doubt to borderline cases.
conditions. It should exploit the strength of rock and its
geologic structures, within the natural and redistributed Disregard of blasting-induced breaks is self-evident. However,
stresses, without causing undue dilution, loss of reserves, and diamond coring is a relatively violent process for core, which
hazards. Consequently, investigation and assessment of ground may induce a significant number of breaks on weaker planes
conditions, groundwater, and stresses must be an integral part that were not naturally broken in situ, prior to drilling.
of mineral exploration, feasibility, and mining operations. Moreover, the degree of induced breakage depends on the angle
of intersection between a structure and core, as well as machine
Investigative Principles and operator factors. Taking account of the power law of the
distribution of natural breaks in rock, the safest course is to
Background disregard all breaks that are judged to be induced by drilling.
The Snowy Mountains Scheme, NSW, was one of the pioneers Distinguishing natural from induced breaks is often difficult,
of systematic investigations and assessments of ground especially where the breaks are along a pervasive planar
conditions for engineering works (Moye 1955). Particularly, structure, such as bedding, cleavage, foliation, or a vein. There
procedures for engineering logging of diamond drilled cores, may be a case in some circumstances to separately log breaks
laboratory measurements of properties of materials, and field induced on planar structures. Only experienced geologists or
measurements of groundwater/permeability were codified. geotechnicians should undertake engineering logging and
Their influence has endured into current practices (eg, Sharp mapping.
and Jordan 1982). The Geological Society [of England]
Engineering Group (1970) provided impetus to development of Standard procedures
standard procedures. All these logging and mapping techniques
were graphical. Standard procedures should be used wherever applicable, to
ensure consistency within and between projects. The
Computer-aided procedures and integration of geomechanics International Society for Rock Mechanics (ISRM) has
with geological and survey processes developed impetus in the established standards for many geomechanical procedures,
1970s as computers became sufficiently powerful and practical. including logging and mapping (Brown 1981). These may form
Early developments occurred at the Mount Isa Mine (Quan the basis for standards that may be adopted within the mineral
Sing and Smith 1973), amongst others. These types of exploration and mining industry.
procedures are now widely adopted for mineral exploration and
mining operations (eg, Nordqvist 1985; Mathews and Database format
Rosengren 1986; McArthur and Kuipers 1990). Data is recorded in a digital database format, which is amenable
to computerised processing, analyses, and presentation. For
Application of geostatistical estimation techniques to ground logs of drilled cores, this contrasts with conventional graphical
conditions (Miller 1979; La Pointe 1980; Barla et al 1987; logs, like those pioneered by the Snowy Mountains Authority
Young and Hoerger 1988) provided further capabilities for (Moye 1955), and the subject of subsequent standard
integration of geomechanics and mineral resources. Now, the procedures. They are not readily amenable to computerisation.
widespread application of workstations and high-end PCs, In contrast, digital data may be readily presented in a graphical
running powerful mining software systems, can provide these format by mining and general software systems.
capabilities for every mineral prospect and mine.
A variety of computer-based techniques for direct entry of
Characterisation of domains digital data into a digital database are available:
Domains are regions or zones of reasonably uniform character,
allowing for natural variations of rock. They are the primary • Bar-code readers, attached to a hand-held or portable
unit, or subdivision, for a geomechanical characterisation of computer, which are becoming efficient and popular.
rock and soil. There are usually larger differences between rock
units and domains than within them.
• Pen-based hand-held and portable computers, which On-site geologists can undertake surveys from direct sources,
are becoming practical field tools, where data can be particularly drilled holes, drilled cores, and exposures,
directly entered onto a formatted screen, equivalent to including materials, structures, and groundwater. Analyses and
manual logs. assessments for short-term planning and operations may be
• Palmtop/notebook/laptop computers, which remain a undertaken by either on-site geologists or specialists, depending
direct, efficient, and effectual technique. on experience and local resources.
One of these should be adopted at a field or mine site to replace Mining software systems, which already integrate resource
hand-written logs. Each can operate with prompts, validation, estimation, survey, and mine design functions, are readily
and limit-checking, minimising logging and transcription applied to incorporate ground conditions and groundwater in
errors. the process.
There is a direct analogy with estimation of mineral resources, that contribute to the response of a rock mass to mining, or any
where modelling and estimation will be done on-site if other disturbance.
sufficient expertise or facilities are available, or off-site if they
are unavailable. In any case, a specialist may review modelling Logging
and estimation. Logging comprises a log, or table, of text and numeric
information, usually from a linear source. Examples are a log of
Similarly, cross-over responsibilities of geologists and drilled cuttings, core, or a line along an exposure. Geological
geomechanics specialists will depend on whether specialists are and geomechanical features may be logged within intervals
engaged on-site and the experience of on-site geologists. along lines, equivalent to assay intervals, or as individual
Likewise, a specialist may review programs. structures and other features. Data is compiled into a database.
A tabular representation of typical engineering logs are shown
For projects where these principles have not already been in Figure 1.
implemented, the role and responsibilities of on-site geologists
may need to be expanded. As this will involve more activities Mapping
and expertise, more staff may need to be provided on-site. In
this way, site geologists should be appointed to provide a Mapping constructs a graphical representation of the location
complete coverage of geological factors that are relevant to and nature of geological structures, rock units, and other
mining. This may require senior company management and geological features, usually represented on a plan or section,
geologists to develop a sharper focus on the primary objective drawn to scale. Examples are maps of outcrops, pit faces, or
of optimised mining. underground development. Data may be compiled into a
digitised database.
Engineering Logging and Mapping Interval logging
Role Purpose
Engineering/structural logging of cores and exposures is the Interval logging of diamond drilled cores and lines along
prime source of information on ground conditions at the site of exposures is undertaken to estimate the mechanical and
a prospect or mine. During exploration and early stages of structural character of rock units (domains), and identify and
development, cores may be the only source of three- characterise large geologic structures or deformed zones.
dimensional coverage of mineralisation and ground conditions.
As a mine matures, open pit exposures or underground Procedure
development may become the prime source of information. Geologic features that may be relevant for mining are logged as
groups within each interval. Intervals are typically 1-3 m
Engineering logging and mapping is a direct extension or length, corresponding to assay intervals where appropriate, or
complement of standard geological logging of cores and to drill runs elsewhere. Such grouped data is less specific than
exposures. Whereas this type of logging is already an integral if every feature were logged individually, but logging is
part of many exploration and development projects, it needs to practical for the volume of rock that may impinge on mining.
become more universal, standardised, and comprehensive to As the aim of the logging is a broad characterisation of each
maximise its benefits. rock unit, all cores should be logged, along with other
geological information.
Terminology
Logged features are those that can reasonably be logged in a
Condition field environment and may contribute to a geomechanical
The ‘condition’ of rock is its fitness for the task. In this instance characterisation of each rock unit. Logged fields may vary
the task is mining; more generally it may be any excavation according to the geological setting and requirements of the
within or loading upon rock. Specifically, ‘condition’ includes: project/mine. A minimum list of fields (for most projects) is
specified in Table 1, divided into five basic groups.
• mechanical properties, such as shear strength, tensile
strength, and deformability, of soil and rock Supplementary drilling, development, or cuttings may be
materials, its structures, or the rock mass as a whole, needed to provide coverage of ground conditions and
including effects of time and water; groundwater at pit perimeters and underground service
development.
• physical properties, such as density and water
content;
Processed results may be graphically presented in two forms:
• hydraulic properties, such as permeability and • strip logs, as histograms, scatter plots and
storativity; and annotations, much like the conventional graphic log,
• petrologic properties, including mineralogy, texture, showing relationships amongst the various logged
and quartz content. fields (Figure 2);
• plots along paths of holes, typically on cross sections,
In practice, the ‘condition’ of rock is estimated by index in the form of histograms and annotations, showing
properties, such as point load strength of materials, degree of relationships with mineralisation or a resource model,
weathering, density and nature of structures, porosity, texture, rock units, major geologic structures, and mine
and mineralogy. layouts, actual and planned (Figure 3).
The term ‘condition’ may be extended to include stresses and Additionally, statistical characterisation of each domain or rock
porewater within a rock mass, which are each natural factors unit may be presented in tables, histograms, scatter plots, and
similar forms.
Figure 1 – Representation of raw and processed digital data on rock conditions in a tabular form. An interval log
includes data on rock conditions within each interval of core or exposure, corresponding to assay intervals or coring
runs. A structural log includes data on the character of individual structures in a core or exposure.
Table 1 - Minimum data fields for general purpose or wall in an open pit or underground development. Sampling
engineering interval logging of diamond drilled cores lines have directional bias, so that a range of directions of lines
and lines along exposures, assuming complementary should be included, where possible. Likewise, a minimum list
of logging fields is specified in Table 2.
geological logging.
Again, supplementary drilling or development may be needed
• Location: to extend coverage to pitwalls or underground service
! depth or distance from-to down-hole or along a development.
logging reference line, which locates each interval in
space. Table 2 - Minimum data fields for general purpose
• Integrity of core (which may be adapted to logging of an
detailed structural logging of diamond drilled cores and
exposure): lines along exposures.
! recovered core;
! fragmented core, whether natural or induced; • Location:
! Rock Quality Designation (RQD). ! depth or distance down-hole or along a logging
reference line, which locates each feature in space.
• Rock and Soil materials:
! rock unit or rock type, which is the basis for defining • Domain
domains; ! rock unit or rock type, which is the basis for defining
! texture of soil or rock material; domains
! degree of weathering or hydrothermal alteration, ! degree of weathering or hydrothermal alteration.
which is also the basis for defining domains;
! qualitative strength of soil or rock material; • Type of feature:
! field measurement of an index of strength, either: ! geologic structures (eg fracture, foliation, vein,
- Point Load index, or cleavage),
- rebound hammer index. ! ‘housekeeping’ features (eg survey point, gap in
sample).
• Geologic structures:
! three fields for each of natural fractures, natural • Orientation:
breaks on a layering or anisotropy, and veins: ! dip-direction and dip for planar structures,
- frequency of occurrence in interval, ! bearing/azimuth and dip for linear features.
- representative infilling materials, • Dimension:
- representative structure to core angles. ! Extent, or size, of the visible part of each structure.
• Comments: • Surface and infill characteristics:
! additional descriptive and judgmental information. ! .infilling/coating mineral(s),
! width of infill/coating materials,
! planarity of surfaces,
Structural logging ! type and orientation of lineations on surfaces.
Purpose • Comments:
Detailed structural logging of diamond drilled cores and ! additional descriptive and judgmental information.
exposures (outcrop, open pit, underground) provides
information on the distribution, orientation, and nature of
individual geologic structures in rock. It complements interval Analysis and presentation
logging. Particularly, it provides a basis to identify and The first analytical task is identification and characterisation of
characterise each natural group of structures, interpret their natural groups of structures, based on their relative orientations.
origins, and establish relationships amongst groups and their Results are presented as spherical projections (Figure 4), tables,
host rock units. and other types of plots.
Figure 2 – Graphical strip-log representation of rock conditions from an interval log, which can highlight
relationships amongst the logged variables.This form of presentation is equivalent to conventional graphic logs, but
all data is stored in a digital form.
Figure 3 – Illustration of an integrated representation of ground conditions, geology, and mining layouts, using a
mining software system. Rock conditions are represented as histograms and annotations along paths of drilled holes,
drawn from interval or structural logs.
Figure 4 – Identification of groups of geologic structures from a structural log of a core or an exposure, which is the
basis for characterisation of geologic structures in each domain of rock. Structures within each orientation group
have a common origin and similar character, allowing for natural variations.
domains of rock conditions, and geologic structures are the Table 3 - Minimum data fields for general-purpose
prime influence on the response of rock to mining. structural mapping of exposures.
Procedure
• Location:
Fractures, faults and similar types of breaks have an ! represented as an intersection trace of each feature
exponential distribution of size or extent, so that a convenient on the map.
minimum cut-off size can be adopted for mapping. The adopted
cut-off will depend upon the specific occurrence of structures, • Domain:
but a cut-off of 2-3 m will usually be appropriate. It should not ! Rock unit or rock type, represented as intersection
be more than 5 m because structures cannot be clearly observed traces of boundaries, and contained symbols.
beyond about 5 m. All structures that can be seen to extend ! degree of weathering or hydrothermal alteration, as
more than the cutoff are mapped; all those smaller than the cut- symbols.
off are ignored.
• Type of feature:
Intersection traces are mapped onto plans or sections, with line- ! represented by the style of line of intersection trace.
styles to represent each type of structure. The range of data that
is recorded on a map is similar to that for structural logging. • Orientation:
Again, while the actual data recorded may vary with the ! dip-direction and dip for planar structures,
geological setting, a minimum list of fields is listed in Table 3. ! bearing/azimuth and dip for linear features.
• Dimension:
Presentation ! Extent, or size, of the visible part of each structure,
Results are presented as consolidated maps of plans and represented by length of intersection trace.
sections, typically corresponding to the standard series for the
• Surface and infill characteristics:
prospect/mine. A separate series shows interpreted rock units,
! infilling/coating mineral(s),
mineralisation, and structures, with actual or planned mining.
! type and orientation of lineations on surfaces.
mineral resources are universally acknowledged; a similar Mathews K E and Rosengren K J, 1986. The integrated
approach is required for ground conditions. planning of geotechnical investigations for new mining
projects, in Proceedings of the Second Project Development
A basis for standards on logging and mapping ground Symposium, pp43-54 (The Australasian Institute of Mining and
conditions in the mining industry exists in the civil engineering Metallurgy: Melbourne).
industry. Standards for mining engineering must be compatible.
Miller S M, 1979. Geostatistical analysis for evaluating spatial
However, mineral exploration and mining have significant
dependence in fracture set characteristics, in Proceedings of the
differences from civil projects, so that variants of standards
16th Application of Computers and Operations Research in the
need to take account of unique geological and operational
Mineral Industry, (ed: T J O'Neil), pp537-545 (SME of AIME).
circumstances, including on-site geologists and facilities,
extensive drilling programs, continual development of new Moye D G, 1955. Engineering Geology for the Snowy
exposures in a mine, established mining software systems, and Mountains Scheme, Journal of The Institution of Engineers,
an extractive rather than a developmental role for excavations - Australia, Oct-Nov:287-298.
ie they become a liability rather than an asset.
Nordqvist A, 1985. Geomechanical characterisation of the
research mine, in Large Scale Underground Mining,
References Proceedings of the International Symposium on Large scale
Underground Mining, Lulea, (ed: G Almgren), pp25-33
Barla G, Scavia C, Antonellis M, and Guarascio M, 1987. (Centek Publishers: Lulea).
Characterisation of rock mass by geostatistical analysis of the
Masua Mine, 6th International Congress of Rock Mechanics, Quan Sing G D and Smith E L, 1973. A computer system to
Montreal, 2:777-786 (International Society of Rock process geological, survey, and rock mechanics data for M.I.M.
Mechanics). Holdings Limited, in Proceedings of the Western Australia
Conference, pp363-375 (The Australasian Institute of Mining
Brown E T (ed), 1981. Rock characterisation testing and and Metallurgy: Melbourne).
monitoring, ISRM Suggested Methods (Pergamon Press).
Sharp K R and Jordan D W, 1982. Logging of rock cores,
Geological Society Engineering Group, 1970. The logging of Workshop on Geotechnical logging of boreholes, pp1-7
rock cores for engineering purposes, Quarterly Journal of (Australian Geomechanics Society: Victoria Group).
Engineering Geology, 3:1-24.
Wade N H, Naderi F and Nikols D, 1988. Role of the computer
La Pointe P R, 1980. Analysis of the spatial variation in rock in managing and applying geotechnical data to surface mine
mass properties through geostatistics, in The State of the Art in design, in Computer Applications in the Mineral Industry (eds:
Rock Mechanics, Proceedings of the 21st US Symposium on Fytas, Collins and Singhal), pp339-352 (Balkema).
Rock Mechanics, pp570-580 (University of Missouri_Rolla).
Young D S and Hoerger S F, 1988. Geostatistics applications to
McArthur G J and Kuipers A J, 1990. Computer methods for rock mechanics, in Key Questions in Rock Mechanics,
mine geology at Hellyer, in Proceedings of the Mine Geologists Proceedings of the 29th US Symposium on Rock Mechanics
Conference, pp49-55 (The Australasian Institute of Mining and (ed: Cundall et al), pp271-282 (Balkema).
Metallurgy: Melbourne).