1150-Article Text-3557-2-10-20200618
1150-Article Text-3557-2-10-20200618
1150-Article Text-3557-2-10-20200618
Ariyanti
Universitas Widya Gama Mahakam Samarinda
ariyanti.muflihin@gmail.com
Rinda Fitriana
Universitas Widya Gama Mahakam Samarinda
rindming@gmail.com
Abstract
This study focuses on correlation between reading comprehension and
writing ability in descriptive text. The researchers collect the data through
two instruments, i.e. test of reading comprehension and descriptive text
writing. This research is researched quantitatively and SPSS was used to
analyze the data. Then, the result of the study shows that mean score of
reading comprehension is 72.47. It means that the students reading
comprehension was good. Meanwhile, the mean score of writing ability in
descriptive text is 61.14. In addition, the researchers found that r-counted
is 0.098, and the r-table with n = 108 (df-2 = 106) with significance level =
95% (α = 0.05) is 0.189. It indicates low correlation between the two
variables.
Key words: Reading Comprehension; Writing Ability; Descriptive Text
Research Methods
The design of this study is correlation research design with
quantitative approach. According to Fraenkel et al. (2011) correlational
studies investigate the possibility of relationship between only two
variables, although investigation of more than two variable two common.
Based on Sukmadinata (2009) the relationship was given with the amount
of correlation coefficient and significant statically. The correlation have not
refer with the influences or cause-effect relationship from the variable to
other one. Positive correlation meant the high score in one variable relates
with the high score in another variable. Negative correlation meant the
high score in one variable related with the low score in another variable.
There are two variables in this study. First variable is reading
comprehension and the second variable is writing ability in descriptive
text. The sample of this study was the seventh-grade students of SMPK 1
W.R. Soepratman Samarinda in the academic year 2016/2017. The number
of this sample was 80 students. Try-out for reading instrument was taken
to get the validity instrument for the test. After conducting try-out, the
researcher was given reading comprehension test and writing descriptive
test to the sample. Then the researcher computes average score of reading
comprehension scores and writing descriptive scores. The last step, the
MEDIUM 73 68%
LOW 19 18%
READING ACHIEVEMENT
80
68
70
60
50
40
30
18
20 15
10
MEDIUM 65 60%
LOW 23 21%
WRITING ABILITY
70
60
60
50
40
30
21
19
20
10
Total 305.34
Since the value of r-counted is lower than the r-table, it can be said
that the Null Hypothesis is accepted. In brief, there is no
correlation between reading comprehension and writing ability in
descriptive text of the seventh grade students of SMP Katolik 1 W.R.
Soepratman Samarinda in the academic year 2016/2017.
Based on the result of the study, the researcher found the mean
score of Reading comprehension was 72.47. It means that reading
comprehension of the seventh grade students of SMP Kaolik 1 W. R.
Soepratman Samarinda in the academic year 2016/2017 state good. The
result of the study showed that from 108 students as sample, there were
15 % or 16 students get High score, 68 % or 73 students get Medium
score, and 18 % or 19 students get Low score.
From the result, the researcher also found the mean score of writing
ability in descriptive text was 61.14. The result of the study showed that
from 108 students as sample, there were 19 % or 20 students get High
score, 60 % or 65 students get Medium score, and 23 % or 21 students
get Low score. If the average score of reading achievement compared with
the average score of writing ability, it shows that students reading
Conclusion
Regarding to the research problem, the researcher concluded that
insignificant correlation existed between reading comprehension and
writing ability in descriptive text since the r-counted is lower than the r-
table: 0.098 < 0.1981, which means, the null hypothesis is accepted. It can
be concluded that students reading comprehension does not necessarily
influence their writing ability, although some previous researchers found
significant relationship between the two variables, this study showed
different result since there is difference of students’ level of education.
Based on the conclusion above, the researchers form two suggestions i.e.
for educators and future researchers. For educators, since it is not found
significances relationship between reading comprehension and writing
ability, it is suggested to focus on reading comprehension aspect only to
improve students writing ability. They need considers others aspect,
such, students readiness for comprehending text and writing text, the
learning materials which meet students capability, and other factor
which may influence students writing ability. Moreover, although previous
finding found significant correlations between reading comprehension and
writing ability, this study found the opposite. Therefore, it is suggested for
future researcher to widen their focus of study, such investigating the