I have not read the book, which I understand contains many important elements of plot and theme that both film adaptations sand off. And this movie definitely has moments that highlight Spielberg’s limits as a director at the time.
But I really don’t agree with the idea that Spielberg was totally floundering out of his depth, inappropriately bathing everything in a tone of wonderment because that was the only mode he knew. Yes, the opening childhood section has a storybook…