The Lower Miocene Nukhul Formation (Gulf of Suez, Egypt) : Microfacies and Reservoir Characteristics
The Lower Miocene Nukhul Formation (Gulf of Suez, Egypt) : Microfacies and Reservoir Characteristics
The Lower Miocene Nukhul Formation (Gulf of Suez, Egypt) : Microfacies and Reservoir Characteristics
DOI 10.1007/s13202-017-0386-3
Abstract The Lower Miocene Nukhul Formation was dolomite and the upper dolomitized carbonate portions of
deposited early during early stages of Gulf of Suez rifting. the formation.
Outcrop of this Formation at Gebel el Zeit, Egypt is up to
100 m (328 ft) thick and consist of lower sandstone-dom- Keywords Gebel el Zeit Gulf of Suez Lower Miocene
inated and upper carbonate-dominated units. Samples were Nukhul Formation
collected from the Nukhul Formation outcrop to describe
the lithofacies, mineralogy, and petrographic characteris-
tics to better understand the hydrocarbon reservoir poten- Introduction
tial for the unit. The investigations showed that the lower
part of Nukhul Formation at North Gebel el Zeit consists of Worldwide, a more secure future energy source can be
poorly sorted, dolomitic sandstone and sandy dolomite achieved by increased production of heavy oil reserves. The
which were deposited in a shallow-marine setting. The major heavy oil accumulations in the Issaran field, Gulf of
presence of polycrystalline and crushed quartz grains in Suez, are trapped in Miocene fractured carbonate and silici-
Nukhul strata indicates that these strata were sourced by clastic reservoirs with average API between 10 and 12 (Joshi
recycled sediments associated with local uplift tied to et al. 2010). The main early Miocene producer of this heavy
rifting. The upper Nukhul consists of dolomitized carbon- oil is the Nukhul Formation, due to its highly fractured nature.
ates with preservation of primary textures; primary lime- Numerous sedimentological and structural studies of rift
stone depositional textures include the following: intraclast evolution have been performed on the Gulf of Suez due to
packstone, rudstone, and coral-algal boundstone, wacke- the presence of well-exposed, and relatively well-dated,
stone, and grainstone with minor floatstone. Carbonate rock syn-rift marine strata and the large amounts of exploration
strata were deposited in shallow marine, peritidal to sub- data available from region (Winn et al. 2001). The Permo–
tidal environments that developed on fault-block highs. Triassic to Holocene outcrops along the Gulf of Suez span
The presence of zoned saddle dolomite suggests some is generally of continental to shallow marine environments.
component of fault-controlled fluid flow. The reservoir The Oligocene–Miocene intracontinental Suez Rift
characteristic of the Lower Miocene Nukhul Formation at formed a fault-bounded marine trough (Lorna et al. 2013).
the Gebel el Zeit indicates favorable properties for reser- The early and middle Miocene syn-rift sedimentary
voir development in both the lower siliciclastic-dominated sequences are dominated by terrigenous clastics from
unroofing of the uplifted rift flanks or shoulders. These
& Mostafa Temraz
successions are among the most prolific petroleum reser-
gouda250@yahoo.com voirs in the Suez province. A thorough understanding of
Henning Dypvik
their depositional history and controlling factors such as
henning.dypvik@geo.uio.no rift shoulders relief, the timing of unroofing, local paleo-
geography, and sedimentary deposystems is required for
1
Egyptian Petroleum Research Institute (EPRI), Cairo, Egypt establishing an accurate development of known reservoirs
2
Geology Institute, Oslo University, Oslo, Norway and prediction in ongoing exploration.
123
J Petrol Explor Prod Technol
The Lower Miocene shallow marine Nukhul Formation distal, possibly deep marine conditions for portions of the
exposed at the Gebel el Zeit outcrop, Gulf of Suez Basin Nukhul Formation (McClay et al. 1998). Regionally it
(Fig. 1). It is the oldest and most extensive syn-rift deposit includes mix of sandstones, conglomerates, limestones,
in the Gulf of Suez (Fig. 2), and also the Nukhul Formation shales, and evaporites.
has high-quality petroleum reservoir in more than 15 fields At Gebel el Zeit, the Nukhul Formation consists of
(Saoudi and Khalil 1986). The unit is generally interpreted lower siliciclastic interval and upper carbonate interval
to represent fluvial, alluvial fan, lagoonal, lacustrine, and representing shallow-marine conditions (Allam 1988;
shallow-marine environments in various structurally sub- Evans 1990). However, the stratigraphic characteristics of
dued basins. Some workers have also postulated more the Nukhul Formation at Gebel el Zeit vary considerably
123
J Petrol Explor Prod Technol
along strike. The thickness of Nukhul Formation is up to approximately time equivalent between south and north
100 m (328 ft) at North and South Gebel el Zeit and Gebel el Zeit, although biostratigraphic information con-
consists mainly of lower sandstone and conglomerate unit firming synchroneity is lacking (Evans 1990). The Nukhul
and dolomitized carbonate unit upper (Figs. 1, 2). Locally, Formation is up to several hundred meters thick to the west
the lower clastic interval may be absent. Nukhul strata are and east of the study area in the Gemsa-Zeit Bay Basin and
absent at Gebel el Zeit, where Rudeis-Kareem marl and East Zeit Basin (Fig. 1) although maximum thicknesses are
shale can be found directly on pre-Nukhul units. Nukhul unknown due to sparse data from the basin centers (Bos-
clastic and carbonate units are assumed to be worth et al. 1998).
123
J Petrol Explor Prod Technol
Tectonic evolution of the suez gulf rift radiometrically dated to 24–21 Ma (early Miocene; Sell-
wood and Netherwood 1984), while the earliest Miocene
The Suez Gulf is a rifted basin where structural activity has and Oligocene rift-related faulting have been discussed by
strongly influenced the sedimentological and stratigraphic Patton et al. (1994). Apatite fission track ages from granitic
expression of rift-related strata. The fault extension-in- basement indicate major uplift of the Red Sea Hills to the
duced evolution exerts a primary control on sedimentation, west of the Gulf of Suez (Fig. 1), associated with early
controlling both fluid flow and creating sites of deposition rifting occurred at 21–23 Ma (early Miocene) (Omar et al.
(Gawthorpe and Leeder 2000; Mack et al. 2009; Lorna 1989). Extensional movements along the northwestern Red
et al. 2013). Gulf of Suez rifting started in the late early Sea coast and early Miocene tilting of Gebel el Zeit fault
Miocene (e.g., Evans 1990; Schutz 1994). Early syn-rift blocks in the region resulted in high relief and coarse
igneous rocks from the Gulf of Suez have been grained alluvial deposits (Bosworth et al. 1998). Much
123
J Petrol Explor Prod Technol
Methodology
Results
123
J Petrol Explor Prod Technol
Fig. 5 a–e photomicrograph show siliciclastic-disseminated dolo- cemented by halite (Bar scale = 200 lm), f SEM photomicrograph
mite: a, b quartz arenite with sutured poly crystalline grains (PQ), BSEI showing quartz grains partially replaced by dolomite crystals
highly porous, and slightly cemented with dolomite c, e showing (Bar scale = 200 lm)
concave convex and straight grains contacts, d showing quartz arenite
Petrography and mineralogy growth kinetics (Sibley and Gregg 1987; Amthor and
Friedman 1991).
The basal Nukhul Formation sandstone grades quickly Based on its associations, the Nukhul-zoned dolomite
upward into dolostones that with sparse (mostly molluscan) occurs in three modes: siliciclastic-disseminated quartz
bioclasts and some burrowing. Dolostones transition dolomite, sandy dolomite, and pure zoned dolomite.
upward into a variety of facies, often with variable amounts
of admixed quartz sand (removed the interpretation of Siliciclastic disseminated dolomite
environments at this point in the manuscript, as these are
results not interpretation). This mode of dolomite consists of euhedral (idiotopic),
The dolomites are recognized and classified according to finely crystalline material with crystals sizes less than
crystal-size distribution (unimodal or polymodal) and 80 lm that are scattered within the host sediments (Fig. 5).
crystal-boundary shape (planar or non-planar), according to The host sediments are chiefly composed of whitish to
Sibley and Gregg (1987). The classification is descriptive, greenish grey, friable to slightly cemented quartz arenite
but carries genetic implications, since size distribution and microfacies. The framework of this quartz arenite varies in
crystal boundary shape is controlled by nucleation and size from very fine to pebbly grains, with subangular to
123
J Petrol Explor Prod Technol
Fig. 6 a, b photomicrograph shows sandy dolomite: a sandstone with photomicrograph BSEI showing replacement of quartz grains by
completely dedolomitized quartz grains. b Sandstone with partially dolomite crystals as detected by EDX (Bar scale = 200 lm)
dolomitized quartz grains (Bar scale = 200 lm). c SEM
sub-rounded, and moderately to well-sorted grains. dolomite generally is limited to the dolomitized sandstone
Quartz grains are predominantly monocrystalline (Qm) lithofacies that represents the main constituent of the lower
with straight extinctions, tangential and long, and con- part of the studied Nukhul Formation.
cave–convex grain contacts. Some polycrystalline grains
(Qp) with sutured boundaries were observed locally Pure dolomite
(Fig. 5a, b). The cementing materials in this microfacies
commonly include disseminated dolomite, giving the This facies occurs as very fine planer-e, unimodal micro-
rock a highly porous character (Fig. 5a, c, f). Halite crystalline dolomite (less than 80 lm in size) that is
cements stained with green (weathered glauconite?) are cemented by ferruginous materials (Fig. 8). These typical
also detected (Fig. 5d). euhedral-dolomite crystals resemble those described by
Concave–convex contacts between quartz grains as well Friedman and Sanders (1978) and Sibley (1982). This pure
as clear undulatory extinction (Fig. 5a, c) indicate high dolomite forms the main constituent of the upper unit of the
stress on the quartz grains. studied Nukhul Formation (Fig. 4). The microcrystalline
dolomites usually have well-developed microporosity,
Sandy dolomite which is visible only in thin sections impregnated with
fluorescent epoxy and viewed using ultraviolet light
This lithology occurs as very fine planer-e, unimodal microscopy (Fig. 7f).
microcrystalline dolomite (less than 80 lm in size) The pure dolomite forms dense mosaics of euhedral to
replaced host sediments (Fig. 6a–c) which are scattered subhedral planar-e (euhedral) crystals that have clear cores
throughout the host rock matrix. The quartz grains are and rim textures (Fig. 7a–d) and non-mimic replacement of
partial to completely replaced by dolomite (Figs. 6, 7). The host allochems (ooids, peloids, intraclast, and fossil-frag-
replacive dolomite fabrics are associated with intracrys- ments). These allochems can be recognized by their ghost
talline and ‘‘vuggy’’ porosity (Fig. 6). This porous textures (Figs. 7, 8).
123
J Petrol Explor Prod Technol
Fig. 7 a, b photomicrograph showing very fine crystalline planar-e planar-e to planar-s zoned dolomite with ‘‘ghost’’ of early replaced
mosaic-zoned dolomite. c, d showing very fine crystalline planar-e to foram texture. f showing very fine crystalline planar-e of recrystal-
planar-s zoned dolomite PPl &CN. e showing very fine crystalline lized zoned dolomite with vugs and intracrystalline porosity
These dolostones also are composed of fine to medium dolomite in middle section, and pure dolomite at the upper
crystalline planar dolomite with intercrystalline pores, vugs, portion (Fig. 9).
and some microporosity. Bioclasts are represented by algae
and skeletal molds. The intense dolomite recrystallization has
rendered most grains and many original fabrics unrecogniz- Discussion
able petrographically (Fig. 8a–g). The host sediment often
was a porous oolite with early calcite spar cement, which was Dolomitization and diagenesis
subsequently completely replaced by dolomite (Fig. 8a, f).
XRD and petrographic analyses of Nukhul Formation The results of analysis on Nukhul Formation dolostones
confirm that the formation grades up from disseminated illustrate their complex diagenetic history which involves
dolomite in lower, clastic-dominated section to sandy early diagenetic as well as burial diagenetic stages.
123
J Petrol Explor Prod Technol
Fig. 8 a showing very fine crystalline planar-e to planar-s zoned algae ghost and vugs in c, e showing very fine crystalline planar-e to
dolomite with ‘‘ghost’’ of early replaced shell fragments texture. planar-s zoned dolomite with ‘‘ghost’’ of early replaced ooids texture.
b showing very fine crystalline planar-e zoned dolomite with f showing very fine crystalline planar-e of recrystallized zoned
ferruginous cement. c, d showing very fine crystalline planar-e to dolomite with vugs and intracrystalline porosity
planar-s zoned dolomite with red algae and ghost of ooids in c red
123
J Petrol Explor Prod Technol
Fig. 9 showing XRD analysis results of the studied Nukhul Formation, the lower unit composed mainly of siliclastic disseminated dolomite
grades into sandy dolomite to completely dolomite in the upper part
diagenetic product (Ye 1992; Gu 2000; Qian and You characterized by curved crystal faces (Figs. 10 and 11).
2006). The backscattered electron (BSE) image of the saddle
dolomites reveals their complex textures. As shown in
Late diagenetic (Epigenic) dolomitization Fig. 11, the saddle dolomites have core and cortex por-
tions. The cortex is divided into multi cortex from inner to
It is suggested that the Mg-rich burial fluids ascended via outer cortex (Fig. 11). The inner cortex is composed of
deep-seated joints, fractures, and faults caused by early dark-zoned non- and light ferroan dolomite, and each
Miocene tectonics; these waters spread laterally along band varies in width. Outer cortex is characterized by dark
porous zones and bedding planes. The upward migration non-ferroan dolomite with lightly thin-zoned ferroan
of the Magnesium water was arrested by impervious dolomite. The width of the ferroan dolomite zone varies at
shales. different positions, and most of the zoned strips are linear.
These fluids are interpreted to account for the high The complex petrography of the saddle dolomites sug-
degree of dolomitization in the lower parts of the Nukhul gests their complex origin.
Formation (siliciclastic-disseminated dolomite; Fig. 10). In
these dolomitized zones, the primary allochems and tex- Reservoir characteristics
tural fabric have completely recrystallized.
In the lower siliciclastic portion of Nukhul Formation Carbonate reservoirs are very important targets for oil and
pores is partially filled with saddle dolomite crystals gas exploration. Carbonate reservoir rocks constitute 20%
(Fig. 11). These dolomites are preferentially developed in of sedimentary rocks while they hold more than 50% of the
fractured zones close to faults (Yang et al. 2007). This world’s proven hydrocarbon reserves and account for 40%
suggests that the formation of the saddle dolomites may of the world’s total hydrocarbon production (Saberi 2010).
be related to fault-controlled fluid flow. The saddle Dolomitization, a diagenesis process is responsible for the
dolomites consist of clear non-planar euhedral dolomite transformation of limestone into dolomite. Diagenesis of
crystals with an average size exceeding 1 mm and are limestone into dolomite involves the substitution of some
123
J Petrol Explor Prod Technol
123
J Petrol Explor Prod Technol
Fig. 11 SEM-BSE photomicrograph shows saddle dolomite crystals with inner core and multi cortex
123
J Petrol Explor Prod Technol
zoned, saddle dolomite crystals indicate later, fault-con- Jackson JA, White NJ, Garfunkel Z, Anderson H (1988) Relations
trolled fluid flow. between normal-fault geometry, tilting and vertical motions in
extensional terrains: an example from the southern Gulf of Suez.
J Struct Geol 10:155–170
Acknowledgements I thank Prof. Dr. Henning Dypvik, Geology Joshi S, Thabet E, Abugreen Y, Samir M, Hassan W, Omara M
Institute, Oslo University, Norway for hosting me during the project (2010) Identifying reservoir pathways in a fractured dolomitic
achievement and his constructive reviews greatly enhance the quality heavy oil reservoir. SPE 129098
of the paper. This work is jointly funded by the Research Council of Lorna JS, Frank R, Robert LG, Paul W, Ian S, Dave H (2013)
Norway, (Project No. 195631\V11 Yggdrasil program) and by the Submarine slope processes in rift-margin basins, Miocene Suez
Egyptian Petroleum Research Institute, Cairo, Egypt. Rift, Egypt. GSA Bull 125:109–127
Mack GH, Leeder MR, Perez-Arlucea M (2009) Late Neogene rift-
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the basin evolution and its relation to normal fault history and
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http:// climate change along the southwestern margin of the Gerania
creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted Range, central Greece. Geol Soc Am Bull 121:907–918
use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give McClay KR, Nichols GJ, Khalil SM, Darwish M, Bosworth W (1998)
appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a Extensional tectonics and sedimentation, eastern Gulf of Suez,
link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were Egypt. In Purser BH, Bosence DJW (eds.) Sedimentary and
made. tectonic evolution of rift basins: the Red Sea–Gulf of Aden.
London, Chapman and Hall, pp 223–238
Omar GI, Steckler MS, Buck WR, Kohn BP (1989) Fission-track
analysis of basement apatites at the western margin of the Gulf
References of Suez rift, Egypt: evidence for synchroneity of uplift and
subsidence. Earth Planet Sci Lett 94:316–328
Patton TL, Moustafa AR, Nelson RA, Abdine SA (1994) Tectonic
Allam A (1988) A lithostratigraphical and structural study on Gebel
evolution and structural setting of the Suez rift. In Landon SM
el-Zeit area, Gulf of Suez, Egypt. J Afr Earth Sci 7:933–944
(ed.) Interior rift basins: AAPG Memoir 59, pp 9–55
Amthor JE, Friedman GM (1991) Dolomite rocks textures and
Qian YX, You DH (2006) An analysis of Ordovician dolomitisation
secondary porosity development in ellenburger group carbonates
origin in northwestern Tazhong area. Xinjiang Petrol Geol
(lower ordovician), west Texas and southeastern New Mexico.
27:146–150
Sedimentology 38:343–362
Saoudi A, Khalil B (1986) Distribution and hydrocarbon potential of
Bosworth W, Taviani M (1996) Late Quaternary reorientation of
Nukhul sediments in the Gulf of Suez. In: Proceedings of the 7th
stress field and extension direction in the southern Gulf of Suez,
exploration seminar, vol 1. Egyptian General Petroleum Corpo-
Egypt: evidence from uplifted coral terraces, mesoscopic fault
ration, Cairo, pp 75–96
arrays, and borehole breakouts. Tectonics 15:791–802
Schutz KI (1994) Structure and stratigraphy of the Gulf of Suez,
Bosworth WP, Crevello P, Winn RD Jr, Steinmetz J (1998) Structure,
Egypt. In: Landon SM (ed) Interior rift basins, vol 59. American
sedimentation, and basin dynamics during rifting of the Gulf of
Association of Petroleum Geologists, Memoirs, Tulsa, pp 57–96
Suez and northwestern Red Sea. In: Purser BH, Bosence DJW
Sellwood BW, Netherwood RE (1984) Facies evolution in the Gulf of
(eds) Sedimentary and tectonic evolution of rift basins: the Red
Suez area: sedimentation history as an indicator of rift initiation
Sea-Gulf of Aden. Chapman and Hall, London, pp 77–96
and development. Mod Geol 9:43–69
Dickson JAD (1965) A modified staining technique for carbonates in
Saberi MR (2010) An integrated approach for seismic characteriza-
thin section. Nature 205:587
tion of carbonates. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Bergen
Evans AL (1990) Miocene sandstone provenance relations in the Gulf
Sibley DF (1982) The origin of common dolomite fabrics, clues from
of Suez: insights into syn-rift unroofing and uplift history. AAPG
the Pliocene. J Sediment Petrol 52:1087–1100
Bull 74:1386–1400
Sibley DF, Gregg JM (1987) Classification of dolomite rock texture.
Friedman GM, Sander JE (1978) Principles of sedimentology. Wiley,
J Sediment Res 57:967–975
New York, p 792
Winn D Jr, Robert D, Paul B Crevello, William B (2001) Lower
Gawthorpe RL, Leeder MR (2000) Tectono-sedimentary evolution of
Miocene Nukhul Formation, Gebel el Zeit, Egypt: model for
active extensional basins. Basin Res 12:195–218
structural control on early syn-rift strata and reservoirs, Gulf of
Grammer GM, Harrison WB III (2003) An overview of hydrothermal
Suez. AAPG Bull 85:1871–1890
dolomite (HTD) reservoirs with examples from the Michigan
Yang MH, Jin ZJ, Lu XX, Pan WQ, Hu JF (2007) Basement-involved
Basin: Presentation for the Michigan Geological Survey. http://
transpressional structure and the formation of the Bachu Uplift,
wsh060.westhills.wmich.edu/RPSEA/refs/HTDoverview/HDO.
Tarim Basin, Northwestern China. Acta Geol Sin 81:158–165
pdf. Accessed 19 Mar 2014
Ye DS (1992) The origin of the Qiulitage Group dolomite (Cambrian
Gu JY (2000) Characteristics and origin analysis of dolomite in lower
to Ordovician) in northern Tarim Basin. Acta Sedimentol Sin
Ordovician of Tarim Basin. Xinjiang Petro Geol 21:120–122
10:77–86
Hosny W, Gaafar I, Sabour AA (1987) Miocene stratigraphic
nomenclature in the Gulf of Suez region. In: Hantar G (ed.)
Egyptian GPC eighth exploration seminar, preprint
123