killing me softly (part nine)
✿ G E N R E ✿
she fell first, he fell harder; fluff with hints of angst; drama; no explicit smut
✿ P A I R I N G ✿
rafe cameron x fem!introverted!kook!reader
✿ C O N T E N T W A R N I N G ✿
swearing, suggestive language, overthinking, sexual jokes/teasing, alcohol/drug mention, rafe being pushy/frustrated/unable to communicate his thoughts properly, tense back-and-forth bc of a verbal dispute
✿ S Y N O P S Y S ✿
it's the last year of high school and you were paired up with rafe cameron for a 2 week long project in art class. this wouldn't be a problem if you weren't awkward as hell and well ... if there weren't your big fat crush on him.
could this be the beginning of a friendship or maybe even more? one thing was certain: rafe cameron was intense, impulsive, and complex in ways that weren't always for the better, and your mind? that shit was even more tangled. but you hadn't spent all these years crushing on him from a distance just to let this chance slip through your fingers ... right?
✿ S U M M A R Y O F R E C E N T E V E N T S ✿
after the confrontation with rafe at school, you told cara about everything over facetime. with the tension between you and rafe finally gone, even texting with him felt more comfortable. when you showed up at his place, sarah opened the door, eyeing you curiously before letting you know that rafe had been very insistent on getting her to leave. inside, he finally came downstairs, freshly showered, and you launched into another monologue, thanking him for not making a big deal out of your awkward behavior. despite being briefly flustered, rafe smoothly deflected it.
✿ W O R D C O U N T ✿
3.9k+
✿ A / N ✿
i had sm fun writing this and i hope you guys will enjoy it as well hihihi. plus i'm always feeling excited with how the chapter ends bc i make shit up as i go LMAO. anyway, hope you will enjoy this as much as i did <33
✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿
"You want some?" Rafe asked casually, not bothering to look up as he sliced a banana.
You were sitting on a mahogany stool at the spacious kitchen counter, hands clutching your bag on your lap while Rafe prepared his food across from you.
Judging by the ingredients, you assumed it was his post-workout meal—Greek yogurt (obviously the low-fat kind), oats, chia seeds, chopped fruit, and a hefty scoop of protein powder he had mixed in at the start.
Honestly, it looked pretty good, but you had already eaten dinner with your parents back at home. Plus, after the conversation you’d had just a few minutes ago, your appetite was pretty much nonexistent.
For the second time that day, you had launched into a long-winded monologue. Only this time, instead of a confession, you'd been expressing your gratitude for his nonchalance.
And his response? Mhm, of course, he had done exactly what you'd just acknowledged in your little speech—smoothly deflected and shifted the dynamic right back in his favor.
Ugh, now he probably actually thinks that was some weird attempt at flirting. WHY AM I LIKE THIS?
But no, today you had decided not to spiral over stuff. And honestly, you'd been doing okay so far—until you'd opened your own damn mouth again.
So, trying to push down the wave of secondhand embarrassment, you forced a polite smile and shook your head. "Oh, no thanks, I already ate at home."
Rafe finally looked up, eyebrows raised as he met your eyes. "You actually not hungry, or is this just some polite etiquette bullshit?"
This guy and his directness…
"No, I really don't want anything," you replied awkwardly, glancing at his bowl for a split second. "But it looks good."
Rafe let out a short, amused breath before turning back to the cutting board. "Aight."
Lifting the board, he slid the banana slices into his bowl. And the way his arms flexed slightly as he did? Um… yeah. Something about the way he was just making his own food, casually slicing fruit—WHY WAS THAT WEIRDLY ATTRACTIVE?
You honestly had no idea where to look despite his arms and hands—help. Just sitting here watching him felt so weird anyway, you felt like some kind of creep.
And the silence creeping in again? He didn’t seem to care, but for you, it created an uncomfortable tension.
Okay, say something. Anything.
"My mom wanted me to say hi to Ward," you said, and since you could already feel the confusion creeping onto his face, you quickly added with an awkward smile, "Because of the Grady-White. She hopes he's happy with his decision."
Rafe held your gaze for a moment, his expression neutral, before turning back to his food. "Yeah, I guess. He's been traveling a lot for work lately—probably hasn’t even had time to take it out properly."
O-kay. Something about the way he said that—kinda defensive like his dad was some untouchable figure or something—made you pause. You weren’t sure what to make of it, especially since just yesterday, he’d snapped at you for bringing up Ward’s whole former Pogue background.
And then, just as quickly, you felt bad for judging him. Losing his mom couldn’t have been easy—of course, he clung to his dad. That was just human.
You nodded. "Oh, yeah, I get that. My mom barely has time for herself either, she’s always running from one meeting to the next."
Shit, shit—wrong direction. Talking about your mom when his was, well… not around anymore? Yeah, not the best move.
Fuck. And sure enough, something in that must have struck a nerve—a barely visible crease on his forehead—but he just shrugged and pulled a spoon from a drawer. "That’s just part of the deal if you want to be successful."
You could tolerate the fact that he was a gym bro—that was honestly still kind of hot. Even the whole kissing-his-dad’s-ass thing, you could somewhat understand. But a potential finance bro/hustler/money-obsessed whatever?
Yeah. That actually gave you the ick.
Whatever, whatever. Nobody's perfect, right? Hahahahaha.
"Yeah, I guess," you said, your tone coming out drier than intended.
Rafe smirked. "What? You don’t agree?"
Your cheeks warmed. Of course, you didn’t, but getting into that debate right now? You weren’t in the mood to annoy him again—especially not in this setting.
You fidgeted with the strap of your bag on your lap. "I just think it’s important to have enough time to take breaks and enjoy life too, that’s all."
Rafe let his spoon sink into his yogurt and huffed a small laugh—amused or condescending, you couldn’t quite tell. "With that mindset, you should probably look for a sugar daddy."
Again, you weren’t sure if he was joking or actually judging you.
"Shouldn’t be too hard to find one around here," you shot back, allowing yourself a smirk.
Rafe’s mouth tugged downward like he was trying to hold back a laugh. “You sure that message for my dad actually came from your mom?”
And yeah, of course, your face turned red, but more than that, a half-shocked, half-amused chuckle escaped you. "That's insane."
“Is it?” Rafe’s smirk deepened, and his tone? Oh, he knew he was being a little shit.
You shook your head, brows furrowed, an incredulous smile on your lips. “No, you’re right. I’m actually just here to become your stepmother.”
“Shit, no thanks,” Rafe scoffed, amused. “One vulture in the family is enough.”
Wow. Rafe really had some complicated relationships with his relatives.
He probably had his reasons, you figured, so you just nodded. "Guess I came here for nothing then."
That, apparently, was enough to get a real chuckle out of him. He shrugged, that smug little grin still on his face. “A real gold digger would already be investing in the next generation of rich men, just saying”
Normally, a comment like that—probably his idea of being slick—would have turned you into a human tomato. But for some reason, his bullshit was so ridiculous, so absurdly over-the-top, that his almost-arrogant delivery just made you laugh.
And that? That pulled a real smile onto Rafe’s lips and poor guy didn’t even realize why.
✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿
You slipped your phone back into your bag just as Rafe returned with an A3 notepad and a purple pencil case.
He placed both in front of you on the dining table. "Wheezie’s desk is covered in a bunch of crap. This was the only stuff that looked remotely useful."
You had brought your iPad with you but you figured sketching and planning on big sheets of traditional paper made more sense, especially since the final product wouldn’t be digital anyway. It also made the whole idea feel more tangible.
Rafe had thrown in a comment about how it didn’t really matter as long as the "shit got drawn somehow," but he still went upstairs to get you what you asked for.
"This should work, thanks," you said, pulling the notepad closer—only to quickly realize it wasn’t just any notepad. It was Wheezie’s personal sketchbook.
You shook your head and met Rafe’s gaze as he dropped into the chair next to you. "This is her sketchbook."
"I can see that," Rafe noted, obviously.
Rafe raised an amused brow, like you were joking. "Of course, we can."
You frowned. "She’s got personal stuff in here. You don’t just take someone’s sketchbook."
"Then just skip over those pages."
Why wasn’t he getting it? "That’s… no. Can you just grab a different one?"
That’s when it clicked for Rafe that you were actually serious, and now he was the one frowning in confusion. "Why? Paper is paper. Who cares?"
Bruh. "That’s not the point. I wouldn’t want someone randomly flipping through my sketchbook either. It’s… it’s just disrespectful."
Rafe scoffed like you were being ridiculous and rubbed his hand over his chin, annoyed. "Wheezie doesn’t give a shit."
Okay, was he just refusing to get it, or did he genuinely not understand what you meant? Or… did he just want to win the argument?
"I do," you shot back, a queasy feeling settling in your stomach as his blue eyes locked onto you with sharp intensity. If you were a guy, he probably would’ve decked you based on that look alone.
For a moment, he just stared at you, and you thought he was about to double down. But to your surprise, he let out an amused breath and pushed himself up. "Shiiit, right. You almost killed me yesterday when I touched your iPad."
Relieved that he had actually given in—despite the lingering warmth on your cheeks from remembering that embarrassing moment—you allowed yourself a resigned smile. "I told you, I thought you were going through my art gallery."
Rafe gripped the back of the chair, raising his brows smugly. "Although… on second thought, it kinda looked like you were trying to find an excuse to get close to me."
NO NO NO NO NO, WAS HE SERIOUS RIGHT NOW?!
Heat rushed to your face at full intensity as the scene replayed in your head. You had freaked out so badly that you’d practically thrown yourself at Rafe on Kelce’s couch, desperately trying to yank your iPad out of his hands—only to realize he had just been looking at your project notes. And, because you had the absolute worst luck, your hand had accidentally brushed against his thigh as you’d awkwardly pulled away.
And, up until now, he hadn't said a word about it. So WHAT THE HELL WAS THIS?!
Sure, he was probably just messing with you again, clearly enjoying the reaction he could get out of you, but oh god, this was so... WHY.
"No, that—oh my god, no… NO." You had no idea how to respond. "Just, no."
Rafe held your gaze, letting out an amused scoff. "Shit, okay." He grabbed Wheezie’s sketchbook, and—unless you were imagining things—you could almost hear the slightest hint of something off in his joking tone. “One ‘no’ would’ve been enough."
And with that, he turned away to get another sketchpad.
You ran both hands down your face, wishing you could just disappear. Why was every conversation, every interaction with Rafe so… intense?
On top of that, you never really knew how he’d respond—what topic shift, what comment, fuck no, what mood he’d hit you with next. It was deeply unsettling and, for someone like you, ridiculously hard to adjust to.
And even though, somehow, you felt comfortable around him, at the same time, you always felt so awkward—like you were walking a fine line. The thought that he might notice or figure out that you had a crush on him? UGGGHHH.
At this point, you were pretty sure he knew. Because today…it felt like he was steering the conversation toward—toward what exactly? It just felt different.
Fuck. And now you’d probably gone and pissed him off too.
And out of sheer fear of falling back into that painfully tense situation like yesterday at Kelce’s, you felt the urgent need to fix your reaction.
Rafe tossed a plain notebook onto the table as he came back. "This shitty-ass pad meet your royal standards, princess?"
And his tone? Definitely irritated. But about what exactly?
Uncertain, you glanced up at him, nervously playing with your fingers. Just ask. Communication is key, right? HAHAHAH.
"Did I say something wrong?", you carefully asked.
Rafe made a face, leaning a hand against the chair beside you. ABORT. ABORT. ABORT. "Like what?"
"I don’t know…" Fuck. Of course, someone like him wouldn’t take well to being called out. "The sketchbook thing. I didn’t mean to make you mad."
"Mad?" Rafe pushed off the chair, letting out a short, amused chuckle, like what you said was completely ridiculous. He tapped a finger against his temple. "Your head tell you that?"
"No!" You furrowed your brows, painfully aware that, yes, it absolutely had. "I just… you seemed pissed."
Rafe nodded. "Yeah. Pissed. Not mad." A lopsided smirk pulled at his lips. "There’s a pretty big difference, you know."
"I know," you shot back, your brows still drawn together. "I wasn’t even trying to— I just meant—"
You cut yourself off when Rafe ran a hand down his face. "Okay, fuck, stop that."
You shook your head in irritation, caught off guard by his tone.
He motioned to his temples with both hands. "That. The crazy-ass shit constantly running through your head." He scoffed, shaking his head. "I swear to God, it’s pissing me off—no clue how you live like that. If I wasted my time overthinking every little thing the way you do? Jesus."
His jaw tensed for a second before he flicked his fingers toward you. "Whatever it is, just say it. No overanalyzing, no long-ass justifications." His voice dropped lower, almost mocking. "Or is this some ‘please let me be easy to deal with’ pick-me type bullshit? ‘Cause if that’s the case—" he pulled back slightly, raising his brows— "I’m so fucking out."
That response completely shut your brain down, because holy shit.
The way he’d just called you out like that, the direct confrontation—It was too much. You had no idea how to react.
And your body? Fuck, your throat was tight, your heart slammed against your ribs, and your palms were so clammy it was almost overstimulating.
But what nearly sent you over the edge was the way he was looking at you. Blue eyes sharp, jaw clenched, that fucking intensity in his gaze that was almost ... intimidating.
It took everything in you to hold back tears.
But something about the way he’d phrased it—Like you hadn’t just told him this exact morning, in full vulnerability, that overthinking was a huge problem for you. Like you hadn’t literally thanked him earlier for not making a big deal out of it.
Oh, that pissed you the fuck off.
"I'm not a fucking pick-me girl," you snapped, sharper than even you expected. "Like—what the fuck? You think I overanalyze shit or question things on purpose?" Your brows pulled together in frustration. "Just this morning I tried explaining exactly that, so what the fuck?"
Now it was your turn to let out a breath of disbelief, a wry smile tugging at your lips. "And maybe I wouldn’t have to give ‘long-ass justifications’ if I wasn’t constantly put in situations where I felt like I needed to."
"And yeah, maybe I should think less but you should definitely think a whole lot more—then maybe you'd have realized that I was just trying to address the obvious tension you had going on. I just … I wanted to make it easier for both of us to work on this project without weird vibes. Not because I’m desperate for you to like me or some shit."
OH MY HOLY FUCKING SHIT. Did I really just say that? OH MY GOD.
Your heart wasn’t just pounding anymore—it was slamming against your ribs like thunderous shockwaves. Because fuck, no one had pissed you off enough to actually snap like that in a long time.
For a moment, Rafe didn’t say anything. He just stared at you, jaw slightly tense, that one crease forming between his brows—the same one that always appeared when he couldn’t quite figure out how to react to a situation that overwhelmed him.
Then, finally, he let out a dry chuckle, tapping his fingers against his temples in that signature gesture of his. "See? That’s exactly what I’m talking about." He exhaled, shaking his head. "I was literally just trying to fucking help you, and in your head, you turned it into something completely different."
You blinked, taken aback. “Help me?” A disbelieving, irritated smile appeared on your face. “You literally just told me I piss you off and that I’m crazy in the head.”
“Jesus Christ.” Rafe ran a hand through his hair, briefly turning away as if trying to collect himself, then met your eyes again with renewed intensity. “You’re so fucking complicated. The ‘Did I say something wrong?’ shit just now? That…” He shook his head, seemingly confused and frustrated. “Shit, I thought you didn’t want me to make a big deal out of things.”
You just stared at him, completely overwhelmed because—HUH????
Your brows furrowed as you asked, incredulously, “So… you thought the best way to respond to me asking if you were mad was to … act even more irritated?”
“Fuck, I was trying to save you from another weird-ass monologue situation, okay?” Rafe shot back, his voice still dense with frustration, but something in his tone had shifted. He pulled out the chair beside you and sat down, body angled toward you, and his hands? Bro was in full gesture-mode. “You’re always so fucking tense. What do you think it’s like for me, huh? I feel like I’m walking through a fucking minefield or some shit.”
That… You knew you should still be mad because his reaction had been totally over the top considering you had just wanted to clear the air for both of you. But somehow… the frustration in his voice, that strained desperation—
It felt like he wanted you to understand but didn’t know how to communicate it.
Maybe you weren’t so different after all.
And the fact that he even thought about pulling you out of an uncomfortable situation—even if he did it in the weirdest fucking way...
Your expression softened, a hint of amusement in your voice. “I don’t need to be handled like I’m made of glass.”
Rafe leaned back slightly, his own tension easing just a bit. “It sure as fuck seems like you do.”
“I don’t, and I don’t want to be.” You paused, watching his expression. “The way you are… your bluntness… I don’t mind it.”
Ohhh shit, you needed to be careful not to slip into another confession speech because THAT kind of confession would actually kill you.
Especially because you were trying your hardest to suppress the irritation about your current state. You almost felt … normal. Because what the fuck, where were the red cheeks, the overwhelming urge to sink into the floor from sheer humiliation?
“Yeah, sure.” Rafe scoffed in disbelief, drumming his fingers lightly on the table. His other hand gestured toward you as he spoke, his tone dry. “Then why the fuck do you always react so… weird? Like, seriously—” He motioned toward himself, a slightly irritated smile on his face. “Are you scared of me or some shit?”
That pulled an incredulous laugh out of you. Shaking your head, you smiled amused. “What? No! Oh my God. It’s just…"
The fact that he still hadn’t realized your awkwardness and blushing around him were caused by your massive crush on him—God, that was actually a relief. A huge, stupid weight lifted off your shoulders.
“I just need a little time to get used to new people, that’s all.”
Rafe looked at you like he was trying to connect the dots in his head, piecing you together. He scratched his chin, tilting his head slightly. “So… you still feeling too uncomfortable or what?”
It was kind of cute that he was actually trying to understand your brain. Even if it seemed to cost him every ounce of willpower and patience he had.
The faintest blush crept onto your cheeks. “No, I mean… not because of you, at least.”
It’s because I’ve had a crush on you for seven years, and now I’ve been thrown into this completely overwhelming situation by my fucking art teacher, and I’m terrified of making a fool of myself. Which, clearly, I already am.
But instead, all you said was, “That’s something I need to work on myself.”
Rafe studied you for a second, still looking puzzled, then shook his head. “Okay, fuck this, that’s enough.” But the remaining bite in his voice didn’t seem to be directed at you anymore. “Friday night, yeah?—Kelce is throwing some party at his place with the shittiest people from our grade. You’re coming along, downing a line of shots or snorting a line of coke—I don’t give a shit—but you’re turning your fucking brain off for once.”
He raised his eyebrows, his next words carrying a firm urgency. “And later, you’re gonna let someone fuck all that tension, overthinking bullshit, whatever-the-fuck, right out of your brain.”
YO WHAT THE FUCK??? EXCUSE ME???
Your expression flickered between disbelief, amusement, and irritation, and since it couldn’t decide on one, you just stared at Rafe blankly.
Because you had no fucking clue if he was joking or being serious—because holy fucking shit if he was serious then??? WHAT.
Of course, you’d been to parties before but the host was usually someone Cara was cool with but Kelce’s party???
Rafe shrugged. “Bring a friend, come alone, I don't care, but shit’s not gonna change if you don’t do something about it.”
OH SURE, BECAUSE IT’S JUST THAT EASY, RIGHT?
“That’s insane,” you finally said, your voice edged with dry amusement. “How… I mean, what? How is that supposed to help me?”
“Shit, it would help me,” Rafe scoffed, clearly entertained. “Whatever your problem is—whether it’s all in your head or, shit, I don’t know, maybe you just need to get properly laid—but whatever it is, it’s pressure. And once that’s gone—” He pulled his lips into a half-smirk, lifting his shoulders with complete nonchalance. "All the other shit falls into place. And I can enjoy the remaining project sessions in peace, without feeling the nervousness radiating off of you.”
Oh my God. You definitely had issues, but Rafe? This guy had no idea how to express emotions or sympathy like a normal person. Instead of saying, I want to help you, he said… whatever the fuck this was supposed to be.
You frowned. “Yeah, no thanks. I’m not into drugs or hookup culture. And besides, it’s rude to show up uninvited to a party.”
“No one wants to see Kelce’s shitty face either, but he still crashes every party,” Rafe shot back before leaning back, now an irritated look on his face. “And I literally just invited you.”
THAT. You could practically hear your brain say: Maximum processing capacity reached. System shutting down.
“For fuck’s sake, just say yes.”
Fuck, everything in you wanted to understand—no, to rationalize—what the hell was going on in Rafe's head and—AHHHHHH.
“Okay,” you blurted out before your brain had the chance to overanalyze it.
For a split second, surprise flashed across Rafe’s face before it melted into a satisfied smirk. “Shit, I hope you’re aware I’m the best thing that’s happened to you this week.”
Or the worst, you thought, already tasting the regret on your tongue. Depending on how it'll end.
✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿
✿ A / N ✿
i wasn't sure if it was the right timing for a dispute like this. i was scared it would be 'too soon' or idk i feared it would feel forced plot-like for rafe to call her out like this but then i was like s1!rafe is a little shit and he def doesn't have the patience for people that, in his opinion, need constant reassurance. so hahaha pls tell me it was the right decision 😭😭
✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿
✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿