The Early Years: Four Electrode Surface Resistivity System
The Early Years: Four Electrode Surface Resistivity System
The Early Years: Four Electrode Surface Resistivity System
The oil industry has had an impact on every human on earth. The evolution of log analysis
methods over the years is less dramatic, but equally fascinating and illuminating.
Obsolete but traditional definitions, abbreviations, symbols, and methods still pervade our
industry. Newcomers often wonder why these old-fashioned ideas persist. In many cases,
methods were developed which required better logging tools or more powerful computational
methods than were available at the time. Such methods fell into disuse, to be resurrected years
later when the appropriate tools were developed. An appreciation of the history of logging and
the development sequence of analytical methods will help any geologist, geophysicist, or
engineer who works with well logs.
Well logging began around 1846 when William Thomson (Lord Kelvin) made
measurements of temperature in water wells in England. His first technical
paper on the subject was "Age of the Earth and its Limitations as
Determined by the Distribution and Measurement of Heat within It". Kelvin's
calculated age was 20 - 40 million years. Radioactivity had not been
discovered yet, so Kelvin was unaware of the heat generated internally from
this source. So Kelvin can be excused for a 100-fold error in his estimate of
the Earth's age. Controversy, debate, and a slew of additional papers
Although direct current was widely used, the Schlumberger brothers also experiment with
alternating current systems, the forerunner of modern electromagnetic (EM) surface
exploration methods.
They also had a brain-wave in 1927 - why not run the four electrode system vertically in a
borehole instead of horizontally on the surface? The general idea was not new. A patent for a
single electrode resistivity device was issued in 1883 to Fred Brown, but it appears not to have
seen use until 1913 in a mining drill hole. A single electrode survey is not very useful
quantitatively but the four electrode system can be calibrated to read resistivity of the material
surrounding the electrodes.
The brothers convinced the
Pechlebronn Oil Company,
drilling in Alsace, France, to
try such electrical
measurements as an aid to
understanding the rock
layers. The first such log in
the USA was run on 17
August l929 for Shell Oil
Company in Kern County,
California. Logs were run
that same year in Venezuela,
Russia, and India.
The first well logs in Canada were run in 1937 (Schlumberger) for a gold exploration project in
Ontario, and in 1939 (Haliburton) for oil in Alberta. The first Schlumberger log for oil
exploration in Canada was run in 1946.
A portion of the first resistivity log from Pecellebron 1927 (left) and the surface equipment circa
1930 (right). Various re-drafted versions of the first log have been published - this one looks
pretty authentic.
First logs outside France 1929: Maracaibo, Venezuela (left); Los Angeles, California (center);
Oklahoma City, Oklahoma (right). Note that some logs were presented on linear scales and
some on logarithmic scales; the latter did not reappear until the early 1960's. There was no SP
curve as it had not yet been invented.
Logs from 1932 in Oil City-Titusville area, Pennsylvania, the location of Edwin Drake's "First Oil
Well". His well was only 69 feet deep, so it penetrated just to the top of these logs, which found
deeper and more prolific reservoirs. His well was the first in the USA, but 5 other countries
produced oil from wells prior to his discovery. The SP, introduced in 1931, helps locate good
quality sands in this relatively low resistivity interval.