As someone who is an artist (not professionally, but I do have thousands of notes on one or two things I made), I wish the average Tumblr user artist (who maybe gets some tips in their Ko-Fi but does not do it professionally and isn't affected by workforce automation) were more willing to admit that it's about clout and attention and feedback and other things without a price tag. I wish we could talk about how to increase visibility for artists without co-opting labour language. Also, I have to say: Posting art online has always had its ups and downs. If it wasn't one thing, it was another. Sometimes it's art thieves pretending your work is theirs, or repost accounts reposting an artwork and cashing in all the engagement while people ignore the artist who actually made it. It's always been a little rough, and a flood of AI art drowning out regular art stings, but feels like same old in a way. I'm used to having to fight for every scrap of engagement, you know? But the response the community has had to AI art? The witch hunts? People taking art people post for their followers and hyperanalyzing the pixels and shading and any lines that might be out of place to prove that the artist is "cheating"? Often without having a goddamn clue about anything? This from the community of art appreciators, the people who, theoretically, I'm posting FOR, when I post art for free? Now that makes me actively hate my own 'fanbase' and feel like I don't want to post anything for them. AI art in the art industry is one thing. But in the hobby circles, anti-AI art hysteria is so much worse for artists than the tech itself could ever be.
Thanks for speaking sense.
It does feel like there's an element of "temporarily embarrassed millionaires" present. Like we can't let AI artists hang around because what if *they* get all the fame and fortune *I* was supposed to get?!
But yeah. Yesterday I saw two different people comparing AI users to Nazis - one of whom was talking about dnd players who were just generating images of their dnd characters on a private server - and a person who runs an AI art blog getting multiple people telling them to kill themselves.
I fully support unions putting protections in place for their workers, I fully support people organizing to protect their jobs, and I fully support boycotting multi-million dollar companies who use AI instead of paying artists. But the sheer vitriol and hatred being leveled at people who are just fucking around having fun making stuff is so insanely overzealous right now. It's extremely performative and it's exhausting.